A History of the World in Six Glasses

Pdf fan Tap here to download this LitChart! (PDF)

Freedom and Self-Control Theme Analysis

Themes and Colors
Innovation and Competition Theme Icon
Imperialism Theme Icon
Freedom and Self-Control Theme Icon
Equality and Elitism Theme Icon
Drinking Spaces and Community Theme Icon
LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in A History of the World in Six Glasses, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work.
Freedom and Self-Control Theme Icon

It’s interesting to note that all six of the drinks Standage discusses in his book bring about some kind of mental or physical change in the drinker: drunkenness, alertness, calmness, etc. At various points in history, these six drinks have been feared for their ability to do exactly this. People have criticized alcohol for causing violence and unruliness for as long as people have been drinking it, and there were even those who believed that tea caused the same symptoms.

While many of the medical and moral complaints about drinks seem silly in retrospect, they point to the same important truth: drinking a beverage poses a challenge for one’s freedom and one’s self-control. In the act of drinking a drink—both because of the chemical effects of the drink and because of the cultural expectations that go along with drinking it—people might become more honest, more direct, or more alert to their own emotions. This is one of the reasons that people conduct business meetings or have frank discussions while drinking—the act of drinking is an act of contemplation and self-contemplation. The question then becomes: while drinking a beverage, should one let down all defenses and give into one’s instincts and emotions, or try to fight these urges through rigorous self-control?

One of the most common answers to this question, judging by Standage’s research, is that drinkers should use the occasion of drinking as an opportunity to build up one’s self-control and strengthen one’s mind. In the Greek symposium, for example, Socrates held that consuming large quantities of wine presented both a danger and an opportunity. The drunkard would be more likely to give in to his sexual urges, but if he could fight these urges until he sobered up, then he would be sure to go through life with more self-control and self-awareness. To drink a beverage and still be the same person was considered a high mark of maturity. One sees a similar philosophy in the machismo of drinking hard liquor: to be able to “hold your liquor” is the ultimate sign of maturity in many cultures.

And yet Standage ends his book by detailing the history of Coca-Cola, a beverage whose “culture,” according to Standage himself, is one of hedonism, unlimited freedom, and giving into desire. The supremacy of Coke in the modern world, he claims, reflects the supremacy of an idea: the idea that the best kind of life is one in which people do what they want to do, whenever they want to do it.

Standage isn’t judging the “culture” of Coke, wine, or coffee—he’s merely describing them. At the same time, he points out the major differences between the respective cultures of each of these beverages. In the case of wine, coffee, and arguably spirits, the goal at one point in time was to translate the physical satisfaction of drinking a drink into some intellectual or socially acceptable behavior: conversing, theorizing, debating, etc. Perhaps the supremacy of Coke in the world thus suggests a change in the way people think about freedom and self-control. Where once the highest ideal was controlling one’s instincts and biological urges, the model of “good” behavior now is to have a good time, savoring physical pleasures above all else.

Get the entire Six Glasses LitChart as a printable PDF.
A history of the world in six glasses.pdf.medium

Freedom and Self-Control ThemeTracker

The ThemeTracker below shows where, and to what degree, the theme of Freedom and Self-Control appears in each chapter of A History of the World in Six Glasses. Click or tap on any chapter to read its Summary & Analysis.
How often theme appears:
Chapter length:

Freedom and Self-Control Quotes in A History of the World in Six Glasses

Below you will find the important quotes in A History of the World in Six Glasses related to the theme of Freedom and Self-Control.
Chapter 2 Quotes

Enkidu’s primitive nature is demonstrated by his lack of familiarity with bread and beer; but once he has consumed them, and then washed himself, he too becomes a human and is then ready to go to Uruk, the city ruled by Gilgamesh. The Mesopotamians regarded the consumption of bread and beer as one of the things that distinguished them from savages and made them fully human.

Related Characters: Gilgamesh , Enkidu
Related Symbols: Beer
Page Number: 27
Explanation and Analysis:

In this passage, we're told that the legendary character Enkidu, from the Mesopotamian poem The Epic of Gilgamesh, was a savage, dangerous individual, as evidenced by his unfamiliarity with beer.

It might seem unusual to associate civilization with the ability to make an alcoholic beverage, since alcohol has traditionally been associated with wildness, violence, and uncontrollable energy. (It might also seem odd to link beer and civility, since most "civilized" people nowadays don't have a clue how to make beer!) Even so, Standage argues that the Mesopotamians admired the ability to brew and consume beer because it represented the ability to master one's environment. Brewing beer was one of the earliest forms of agriculture, meaning that it was one of the key steps in the history of civilization. The history of beer, therefore, is the history of the birth of civilization—an excellent example of how we can study history and culture by studying drinks.


Unlock explanations and citation info for this and every other A History of the World in Six Glasses quote.

Plus so much more...

Get LitCharts A+
Already a LitCharts A+ member? Sign in!
Chapter 3 Quotes

Plato saw drinking as a way to test oneself, by submitting to the passions aroused by drinking: anger, love, pride, ignorance, greed, and cowardice. He even laid down rules for the proper running of a symposion, which should ideally enable men to develop resistance to their irrational urges and triumph over their inner demons.

Related Characters: Plato
Related Symbols: Wine
Page Number: 65
Explanation and Analysis:

Plato, the important ancient Greek philosopher, wrote extensively about the importance of wine and alcohol to human thought. Plato was interested in wine because it dimmed the powers of the intellect and aroused humans' natural tendencies to be wild, angry, greedy, etc. In short, Plato saw wine as bringing out the worst in human nature. It's for this reason that wine was so important to Plato: he believed that drinking wine was a way for intellectuals to "build up" control over their base urges. If a philosopher could drink wine and still be intelligent and self-controlled, then he was a great man. (At the end of Plato's Symposium, Socrates wins an elaborate argument while drinking massive amounts of wine, proving that he's truly the wisest man at the party.)

Chapter 7 Quotes

The diffusion of this new rationalism throughout Europe was mirrored by the spread of a new drink, coffee, that promoted sharpness and clarity of thought. It became the preferred drink of scientists, intellectuals, merchants, and clerks—today we would call them “information workers.”

Related Symbols: Coffee
Page Number: 134-35
Explanation and Analysis:

In this quotation, Standage discusses the influence of coffee on the Age of Enlightenment—the period of European history in the 17th and 18th century when European intellectuals came to celebrate the importance of rationality, deep thought, and experimentation. As Standage sees it, coffee contributed to rationalism in the most literal of ways: it stimulated the brain, allowing people to think, talk, and focus for longer periods of time.

The popularity of coffee in Europe, Standage further points out, marked changes in the structure of European society, too. While many kinds of people enjoyed coffee, the drink was especially popular among information workers. The popularity of coffee among these kinds of people shows that Europe was transitioning from an economy founded on manual labor, military valor, and other physical endeavors, to an economy based on intelligence, quick thinking, and other intellectual endeavors. In short, coffee set the Western world on its current path.