Buddenbrooks
Buddenbrooks
by Thomas Mann

or to save your progress

Buddenbrooks: Part 1, Chapter 5 Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
Dinner carries on, and the men discuss politics. Johann praises Napoleon’s “personal greatness,” but the consul disagrees: he and his younger generation can’t justify supporting such a brutal tyrant. Pastor Wunderlich thinks the consul is exaggerating, but the consul stands firm: his Christian values won’t permit him to praise such a man. At this, Johann and Wunderlich smile in amusement. Then Johann admonishes today’s culture, which values “[t]rade schools and technical schools” over “classical education.”  
The older men’s skepticism toward (and rather patronizing disregard for) the consul’s political opinions continues the theme of generational divide. Johann’s condemnation of “classical education” and praise for “[t]rade schools and technical schools” reflects his worldview, pointing toward his negative view of the arts and humanities as self-indulgent and a waste of time. His worldview firmly aligns with a so-called Protestant ethic, which values honest, hard work and strict self-discipline.
Active Themes
Tradition, Modernity, and Change  Theme Icon
The Protestant Ethic  Theme Icon
Personal Fulfillment and Self-Knowledge  Theme Icon
Meanwhile, Madame Kröger goes on about the best way to poach fish. Someone mentions a time they visited a large garden the Buddenbrooks own outside Burg Gate, and Johann laments how unkempt it was at the time. The consul mocks his father for being so obsessive about nature, of all things. Johann insists that if he owns something, he has every right to tend to it as he sees fit.
Active Themes
The Protestant Ethic  Theme Icon
Personal Fulfillment and Self-Knowledge  Theme Icon
Pretense and Etiquette  Theme Icon