Frank Quotes in Dreams from My Father
Chapter 4 Quotes
“I don’t suppose he would have. Stan doesn’t like to talk about that part of Kansas much. Makes him uncomfortable. He told me once about a black girl they hired to look after your mother. A preacher’s daughter, I think it was. Told me how she became a regular part of the family. That’s how he remembers it, you understand—this girl coming in to look after somebody else’s children, her mother coming to do somebody else’s laundry. A regular part of the family.”
Here, Gramps’s Black friend Frank suggests that Barack’s white grandparents—while perfectly nice and loving—still have some ignorant and even racist attitudes. When Gramps told Frank about hiring a Black babysitter, he framed the woman’s presence in their home as familial rather than professional. Gramps likely meant to show Frank that his family home was open to Black people like him, but Frank heard this quite differently; Gramps didn’t respect the humanity of Black people enough to acknowledge that being a paid employee is actually nothing like being a family member. Gramps is able to have these delusions because he’s white and he’s so used to having power that he doesn’t even recognize when he’s using it. To him, in other words, the experience of hiring a babysitter does not register as an exercise of power over another person. Obviously, though, Frank and the babysitter both recognize that Gramps—as a white person paying for a service—is dictating the terms of the interaction. It’s absurd to suggest that this is anything like a familial relationship between equals.
This moment is also important because it helps Barack understand that Gramps, while well-meaning, often tells stories that are meant to make himself seem more moral or virtuous than he actually is. Because of these distortions, his stories don’t give Barack a true sense of who Gramps is or the world that he came from—they only reveal who Gramps wishes he were. Frank hints here that there are aspects of Gramps’s Kansan upbringing that Gramps would never mention to Barack, presumably because it would reveal his own complicity in the pervasive racism where he grew up. It’s sad that Gramps is so protective of his own image. Acknowledging his ignorance would be a step towards atoning for his past behavior and changing his future behavior, and knowing the truth about the world in which Gramps and Toot grew up would help Barack understand his family and his own experiences of racism better. However, Gramps prioritizes protecting his own image over helping his grandson understand the racism that he faces, which is selfish and emblematic of his own fragility.
Frank Quotes in Dreams from My Father
Chapter 4 Quotes
“I don’t suppose he would have. Stan doesn’t like to talk about that part of Kansas much. Makes him uncomfortable. He told me once about a black girl they hired to look after your mother. A preacher’s daughter, I think it was. Told me how she became a regular part of the family. That’s how he remembers it, you understand—this girl coming in to look after somebody else’s children, her mother coming to do somebody else’s laundry. A regular part of the family.”
Here, Gramps’s Black friend Frank suggests that Barack’s white grandparents—while perfectly nice and loving—still have some ignorant and even racist attitudes. When Gramps told Frank about hiring a Black babysitter, he framed the woman’s presence in their home as familial rather than professional. Gramps likely meant to show Frank that his family home was open to Black people like him, but Frank heard this quite differently; Gramps didn’t respect the humanity of Black people enough to acknowledge that being a paid employee is actually nothing like being a family member. Gramps is able to have these delusions because he’s white and he’s so used to having power that he doesn’t even recognize when he’s using it. To him, in other words, the experience of hiring a babysitter does not register as an exercise of power over another person. Obviously, though, Frank and the babysitter both recognize that Gramps—as a white person paying for a service—is dictating the terms of the interaction. It’s absurd to suggest that this is anything like a familial relationship between equals.
This moment is also important because it helps Barack understand that Gramps, while well-meaning, often tells stories that are meant to make himself seem more moral or virtuous than he actually is. Because of these distortions, his stories don’t give Barack a true sense of who Gramps is or the world that he came from—they only reveal who Gramps wishes he were. Frank hints here that there are aspects of Gramps’s Kansan upbringing that Gramps would never mention to Barack, presumably because it would reveal his own complicity in the pervasive racism where he grew up. It’s sad that Gramps is so protective of his own image. Acknowledging his ignorance would be a step towards atoning for his past behavior and changing his future behavior, and knowing the truth about the world in which Gramps and Toot grew up would help Barack understand his family and his own experiences of racism better. However, Gramps prioritizes protecting his own image over helping his grandson understand the racism that he faces, which is selfish and emblematic of his own fragility.