Hope Leslie

Hope Leslie

by

Catharine Sedgwick

Teachers and parents! Our Teacher Edition on Hope Leslie makes teaching easy.

Religious Conflict and Tolerance Theme Analysis

Themes and Colors
Religious Conflict and Tolerance Theme Icon
Interracial Relationships Theme Icon
Violence and Historical Memory Theme Icon
Women’s Roles Theme Icon
The Puritan Heritage Theme Icon
LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in Hope Leslie, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work.
Religious Conflict and Tolerance Theme Icon

Hope Leslie portrays events surrounding the Fletcher household in the 17th-century Massachusetts Bay Colony, a context that was infamously intolerant of diverse religious beliefs. The colony was founded by the Puritans, or pilgrims, a Calvinist Protestant group fleeing religious persecution in England and seeking to establish a purely Christian society in the American wilderness. This quest led to conflict with the beliefs of already-present American Indian groups, such as the Pequots, who occupy a prominent role in the story. Such conflict is personal to the Fletchers, whose devoutly Puritan household includes among its adoptive children Hope Leslie, whose Christianity is less sectarian, and Magawisca, a non-Christian Pequot. Though Sedgwick does openly acknowledge the threats of persecution and extinction faced by American Indians in particular, Sedgwick’s portrayal of the convictions and interactions among Native peoples and the Puritan and other Christian characters suggests that close proximity will lead, over time, to increased tolerance in society as a whole.

Puritan religious intolerance poses an existential threat to non-Puritans in the Massachusetts Bay Colony. After Magawisca tells her friend Everell Fletcher about the massacre of her village by men who professed Christian beliefs, “Magawisca’s reflecting mind suggested the most serious obstacle to the progress of the Christian religion […] the contrariety between its divine principles and the conduct of its professors; which, […] is too often the darkest cloud that obstructs the passage of its rays to the hearts of heathen men.” Magawisca, as an outsider to Christianity, perceives that Christianity doesn’t spread more successfully among so-called “heathen” people because it’s readily apparent that Christians don’t always live up to the beliefs they profess—especially when they behave violently toward people whom they professedly desire to convert to their faith.

When the old Pequot woman Nelema uses her healing skills to save the life of a member of the Fletcher household, she is quickly accused of witchcraft, which will likely lead to a death sentence. Hope Leslie attempts to defend Nelema, asking Mr. Fletcher “if it were right to take the confession of these poor children of ignorance and superstition against themselves,” and even defending Magawisca’s belief that she can communicate with the benign spirits present in nature. “Why not believe the one,” Hope asks Mr. Fletcher, “as well as the other?” In other words, though Hope classifies non-Christian American Indian beliefs as “ignorant” and “superstitious,” she deflects the representation of Nelema’s practice as “witchcraft” by arguing that Indian beliefs include relationships with both good and bad spiritual elements, and therefore that their beliefs as a whole shouldn’t be dismissed as wicked or devilish. Though Nelema is still arrested, Hope’s public defense (and secret rescue) of Nelema show that tolerance for different views is possible, even within Puritan society.

Seeds of tolerance can be found even within Puritan society, suggesting that society as a whole is moving toward greater open-mindedness at this time. When William Fletcher tells his wife about an American Indian woman who died without having converted to Christianity, he says, “But, Martha, we should not suit God’s mercy to the narrow frame of our thoughts. This poor savage’s life […] was marked with innocence and good deeds,” and thus they have grounds to hope for her soul’s salvation (though he warns Martha not to express such hopes aloud). Though the Fletcher household is a model of Puritan religious observance, even here a measure of religious tolerance can be found—even if it’s not considered fit for public utterance.

Protagonist Hope Leslie’s upbringing is influenced by various Christian denominations, which lends itself to a certain open-mindedness: “like the bird that spreads his wings […] [she] permitted her mind to expand beyond the contracted boundaries of sectarian faith. Her religion was pure and disinterested,” showing Sedgwick’s belief that “pure” truth is to be found in the rejection of too-particular religious affiliation. Hope’s “purity” and “disinterestedness” in supporting and defending non-Christians Nelema and Magawisca, for example, contrast with the narrower, harsher motivations of those who condemn the women’s beliefs as satanic.

Hope’s and Magawisca’s mothers are buried near each other in the same Boston graveyard, and this prompts Magawisca to consider the mercy of the being she refers to as the “Great Spirit”: “Think ye not that the Great Spirit looks down on these sacred spots […] with an equal eye; think ye not their children are His children, whether they are gathered in yonder [church] […] or bow to Him beneath the green boughs of the forest?” Here, Magawisca utters religious claims—essentially, that all religions and their believers are equal—that would perhaps have been considered heretical if uttered by a Christian character, allowing Sedgwick to subtly champion tolerance and common humanity without explicitly advancing these ideals.

Catharine Maria Sedgwick, though raised in a Calvinist family, became a Unitarian as an adult—a denomination that rejected many traditional Christian beliefs and even questioned the validity of formalized doctrines and acknowledged value in other religious traditions. Although Sedgwick portrays all of her devout characters with respect, her critique of what she saw as a dangerously narrow Puritanism is obvious, and indeed, her more tolerant characters—whether Christian or Native American—sound notably Unitarian in their theological musings. This unsurprising congruence suggests that Sedgwick saw Unitarianism, or at least a progressive, non-doctrinal Christianity, as the answer to the Puritans’ search for a truly Christian society in the wilderness.

Related Themes from Other Texts
Compare and contrast themes from other texts to this theme…
Get the entire Hope Leslie LitChart as a printable PDF.
Hope Leslie PDF

Religious Conflict and Tolerance Quotes in Hope Leslie

Below you will find the important quotes in Hope Leslie related to the theme of Religious Conflict and Tolerance.
Volume 1, Chapter 4 Quotes

Magawisca's reflecting mind suggested the most serious obstacle to the progress of the christian religion, in all ages and under all circumstances; the contrariety between its divine principles and the conduct of its professors; which, instead of always being a medium for the light that emanates from our holy law, is too often the darkest cloud that obstructs the passage of its rays to the hearts of heathen men. Everell had been carefully instructed in the principles of his religion, and he felt Magawisca's relation to be an awkward comment on them, and her inquiry natural[.]

Related Characters: Magawisca, Everell Fletcher
Page Number: 53
Explanation and Analysis:

The stories of the murders of Stone, Norton, and Oldham, are familiar to every reader of our early annals; and the anecdote of the two English girls, who were captured at Wethersfield, and protected and restored to their friends by the wife of Mononotto, has already been illustrated by a sister labourer; and is precious to all those who would accumulate proofs, that the image of God is never quite effaced from the souls of his creatures; and that in their darkest ignorance, and deepest degradation, there are still to be found traits of mercy and benevolence.

Related Characters: Mononotto, Monoca
Page Number: 59
Explanation and Analysis:
Volume 1, Chapter 9 Quotes

It has been seen that Hope Leslie was superior to some of the prejudices of the age. […] Those persons she most loved, and with whom she had lived from her infancy, were of variant religious sentiments. […] Early impressions sometimes form moulds for subsequent opinions; and when at a more reflecting age, Hope heard her aunt Grafton rail with natural good sense, […] at some of the peculiarities of the puritans, she was led to doubt their infallibility; and like the bird that spreads his wings and soars above the limits by which each man fences in his own narrow domain, she enjoyed the capacities of her nature, and permitted her mind to expand beyond the contracted boundaries of sectarian faith. Her religion was pure and disinterested—no one, therefore, should doubt its intrinsic value, though it had not been coined into a particular form, or received the current impress.

Related Characters: Hope Leslie (Alice), Mrs. Grafton
Page Number: 127
Explanation and Analysis:
Volume 2, Chapter 2 Quotes

"There lies my mother," cried Hope, without seeming to have heard Magawisca's consolations, "she lost her life in bringing her children to this wild world, to secure them in the fold of Christ. Oh God! restore my sister to the christian family."

"And here," said Magawisca, in a voice of deep pathos, "here is my mother's grave; think ye not that the Great Spirit looks down on these sacred spots, where the good and the peaceful rest, with an equal eye; think ye not their children are His children, whether they are gathered in yonder temple where your people worship, or bow to Him beneath the green boughs of the forest?"

Related Characters: Hope Leslie (Alice) (speaker), Magawisca (speaker), Monoca, Alice Fletcher
Related Symbols: Wilderness
Page Number: 197
Explanation and Analysis:
Volume 2, Chapter 5 Quotes

“[M]y sweet mistress […] this having our own way, is what every body likes; it's the privilege we came to this wilderness world for; and though the gentles up in town there, with the Governor at their head, hold a pretty tight rein, yet I can tell them, that there are many who think what blunt Master Blackstone said, 'that he came not away from the Lords-bishops, to put himself under the Lord's-brethren.' […] I know which way the wind blows. Thought and will are set free. […] Times are changed—there is a new spirit in the world—chains are broken—fetters are knocked off—and the liberty set forth in the blessed word, is now felt to be every man's birth-right.

Related Characters: John Digby (speaker), Hope Leslie (Alice), Governor John Winthrop
Related Symbols: Wilderness
Page Number: 235
Explanation and Analysis:
Volume 2, Chapter 6 Quotes

[Antonio’s] invocation was long enough to allow our heroine time to make up her mind as to the course she should pursue with her votary. She had recoiled from the impiety of appropriating his address to the holy mother, but protestant as she was, we hope she may be pardoned for thinking that she might without presumption, identify herself with a catholic saint. "Good Antonio," she said, "I am well pleased to find thee faithful, as thou hast proved thyself, by withdrawing from thy vile comrades. […] Now, honest Antonio, I will put honour on thee; thou shalt do me good service. Take those oars and ply them well till we reach yon town, where I have an errand that must be done."

Related Characters: Hope Leslie (Alice) (speaker), Antonio Batista
Page Number: 253
Explanation and Analysis: