Lakota Woman
by Mary Crow Dog
✓

or to save your progress

Lakota Woman: Chapter 15 Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
After the siege of Wounded Knee, Leonard knew that government agents would find a reason to imprison him. He had been sentenced to prison for 13 years because of his role in the Wounded Knee Occupation, but he was able to get out on probation. While he didn't understand why the government officials wanted so badly to imprison him—he saw himself as a religious leader, not a revolutionary—Mary knew then and knows now that, because the militant youth of AIM would listen to a medicine man, Leonard was a threat to the system. For example, when Leonard instructed the youth to never sell their lands—no matter what company offered to purchase it—the youth listened.
The book suggests that the government saw Leonard as a revolutionary because he was encouraging the younger generations of the indigenous community to resist complying with the government or white society—he not only helped lead a cultural revival for indigenous cultures, but he also urged people to not sell their land, which companies wanted for its natural resources. Because of his refusal to comply with white society—even if he attributed his stance to his religious beliefs and not to political beliefs—he was a threat to the capitalist and colonialist system.
Active Themes
Activism and Resistance Theme Icon
Quotes
Shortly after the Ghost Dance of 1974, the government seized their opportunity. On September 2, 1975, two drunk men named Beck and McClosky crashed their car in Leonard's yard. Their rowdy shouts—they were bragging about how they had attacked one of Leonard's young nephews—woke up several of the relatives who were staying on the Crow Dogs’ property. The drunk men and the relatives started fighting, during which someone broke McClosky's jaw.
At this point in the narration, the book implies that the government exploited the Beck and McClosky event to arrest Leonard, as they saw him as a revolutionary who preached resistance against capitalism. 
Active Themes
Activism and Resistance Theme Icon
 Beck and McClosky pressed charges against Leonard, and, just a few days later, a team of nearly 185 agents and officers stormed the Crow Dogs’ property to arrest Leonard. These officers acted with excessive violence, throwing young Pedro against a wall and putting guns to Mary's head as they ransacked the house.
Active Themes
Activism and Resistance Theme Icon
The agents took Leonard in for questioning, during which they repeatedly asked him where a man named Peltier was hiding, a question that had no connection to what he was being arrested for, which was McClosky's broken jaw (even though it had been one of Leonard's relatives, and not Leonard, who had broken the man's jaw). It was only years later that Mary and Leonard found out that the FBI had staged the Beck-McClosky incident with the goal of arresting Leonard.
Active Themes
Activism and Resistance Theme Icon
Get the entire Lakota Woman LitChart as a printable PDF.
"My students can't get enough of your charts and their results have gone through the roof." -Graham S.
Lakota Woman PDF
Mary interrupts her narrative to explain why the FBI had decided to frame Leonard. The reason is tied to a shoot-out between AIM activists and FBI agents that took place in 1975. The gunfight resulted in the death of one Native American and two FBI agents. The FBI relentlessly searched for the killer of the two agents.
Active Themes
Activism and Resistance Theme Icon
The FBI eventually decided to charge a radical AIM leader named Leonard Peltier for the deaths of the two FBI agents. They threatened several "witnesses" into testifying, and so established their "case." Supposedly, someone gave the FBI a false tip that Peltier was staying with Leonard Crow Dog. So, the government agents staged the Beck-McClosky incident to have a reason to investigate the Crow Dog property and arrest Leonard Crow Dog.
Active Themes
Activism and Resistance Theme Icon
Mary describes Leonard Crow Dog's trials as a complete "farce." The Native Americans often won cases when tried outside of South Dakota and had an unbiased jury, which is why, Mary suspects, the government set the trial in South Dakota, a notoriously anti-Native American state. Sure enough, Leonard was found guilty and sentenced to 23 years.
Active Themes
Activism and Resistance Theme Icon
Mary was broken-hearted and at a complete loss when Leonard was imprisoned. Leonard had been so important for his community—from healing others to leading ceremonies—that Mary knew she could never fill the void he left behind.
Active Themes
Assimilation, Tradition, and Identity Theme Icon
Unity, Inclusion, and Equality Theme Icon
From the moment that Leonard went to jail, the friends and activists of AIM rallied and raised money to set him free. Over the two-year struggle to free Leonard, Mary learned about the corruption of the justice system. Money, she says, is more important than guilt or innocence; if one has enough money to spend on good lawyers, one's chances at winning are infinitely better. With the help of fundraising and donations, Leonard was able to get a good team of lawyers and organizers. Among them were Bill Kunstler, Sandy Rosen, and Richard and Jean Erdoes.
Active Themes
Unity, Inclusion, and Equality Theme Icon
Leonard was mistreated horribly in prison. Before describing the treatment he faced, Mary interjects to say that imprisonment is excruciatingly difficult for a man as connected with nature as Leonard is. When he arrived in prison, they confined Leonard to an isolation cell, where he became disoriented. In an effort to keep his sanity, Leonard sang, even making up his own peyote songs.
Active Themes
Assimilation, Tradition, and Identity Theme Icon
The prison guards (Mary calls them “hacks”) did their best to humiliate Leonard Crow Dog. They sexually harassed him, tried to cut his braids, and taunted him, telling him to become a bird “if [he was] such a big-shot medicine man.”
Active Themes
Assimilation, Tradition, and Identity Theme Icon
At one point, Leonard asked the warden for permission to obtain his pipe. He argued that since Jewish prisoners had a right to the Talmud, and Catholic priests could keep their Bibles, he—and all members of the Native American Religion—should be able to have access to his pipe. After a legal struggle (in which the Native American Religion was recognized), the warden granted Leonard the right to his pipe, although he refused to allow him access to tobacco. When it became clear that the warden would not relent on this point, Leonard gave him back his pipe, saying that, without the tobacco, his pipe was useless.
Active Themes
Activism and Resistance Theme Icon
Assimilation, Tradition, and Identity Theme Icon
Several psychiatrists visited Leonard, but almost all of them were useless. One gave up after Leonard explained that the only irritation he suffered from was the many broken promises of the U.S. government. Another one tried to put Leonard on Valium. There was, however, one psychiatrist who helped Leonard. After recognizing that Leonard didn’t need psychiatric help, he wrote favorable reports for him and supported Leonard in his attempt to regain freedom.
Active Themes
Unity, Inclusion, and Equality Theme Icon
Leonard suffered only two mental breakdowns during his time in prison. The first happened when another man in prison told Leonard (whom he called “Chief”) that he was going to get lobotomized, like the uncooperative man in the book One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest. Leonard panicked—he knew too well that, should the prison officials want to lobotomize him, he would have no power to stop them. Leonard called Mary and Richard and Jean Erdoes to inform them. Mary, Richard, and Jean spent the night trying to talk to lawyers to stop the lobotomy, only for them to discover that the man had been playing a cruel joke on Leonard.
Active Themes
Activism and Resistance Theme Icon
Unity, Inclusion, and Equality Theme Icon
Leonard’s second breakdown took place after his home, the old Crow Dog home, burned to the ground under suspicious circumstances. The fire consumed all the cultural relics and sacred items in the house. Leonard was heartbroken and yearned to be reunited with his people and his land.
Active Themes
Assimilation, Tradition, and Identity Theme Icon
Leonard’s imprisonment took a toll on Mary as well. She missed him, and it was difficult to see him frequently—the officials in charge moved him a couple times, usually far from where Mary was living, which made visiting an expensive inconvenience. But as various civil and religious rights groups began advocating for Leonard and rallying for his freedom, Mary made many friends and acquaintances with other political leaders, artists, and attorneys.
Active Themes
Unity, Inclusion, and Equality Theme Icon
Racism and Sexism Theme Icon
Leonard credits his spiritual power with helping him endure his imprisonment. Even when in isolation, he felt the presence of spirits and communicated with the Great Spirit.
Active Themes
Assimilation, Tradition, and Identity Theme Icon
Generally, the other inmates greatly respected and appreciated Leonard. He made friends with inmates of all races, and he especially bonded with those who were imprisoned for life. He felt a great deal of empathy for them—he understood that living life eternally isolated from loved ones and the world outside was a type of living death.
Active Themes
Unity, Inclusion, and Equality Theme Icon
In the spring of 1976, Leonard was released for three months pending appeal. Along with several friends, Mary picked up Leonard. Although the prison guards added petty requests to delay Leonard’s release by a few hours, Mary was able to at last greet Leonard outside the prison. That evening they had a big feast with friends, but Leonard wasn’t able to relax that night. As he told Mary, “mentally [he was] still in prison.”
Active Themes
Unity, Inclusion, and Equality Theme Icon
Leonard and Mary at last returned to Rosebud, only for them to receive a notice that Leonard’s appeal had been denied, so he had to return to prison. To echo history, Leonard gave himself up in Deadwood at the same courthouse that his great-grandfather, the first Crow Dog, had surrendered himself.
Active Themes
Activism and Resistance Theme Icon
Assimilation, Tradition, and Identity Theme Icon
So, Mary and Leonard’s team of lawyers appealed once again. They appealed to the case’s judge, a Judge Robert Merhige, whom they despised for having sentenced Leonard to prison time in the farcical assault-and-battery charges. But the international outpouring of support for Leonard began to change his mind. Judge Merhige received thousands of letters from people all over the world—Richard Erdoes even met with Merhige’s bishop and successfully persuaded him to write the judge a letter in support of Leonard’s release. So, at last, the judge ordered Crow Dog’s immediate release.
Active Themes
Activism and Resistance Theme Icon
Unity, Inclusion, and Equality Theme Icon
Quotes
Unfortunately, all the additional paperwork delayed Leonard’s release for another three months. When Leonard at last returned home, a huge crowd of medicine men, tribal members, tribal leaders, and even missionary priests gathered to welcome him. They also honored Mary, whom they gave the name Ohitika Win, or Brave Woman.
Active Themes
Unity, Inclusion, and Equality Theme Icon
Mary pauses the narrative to add that a film was made about Leonard’s imprisonment and legal battles. In it, Bill Kunstler makes a speech in which he argues that many white people and U.S. government officials persecute Native Americans and “hate them because their claims are totally justified—and [they] know it.” Mary adds that while she recognizes that it was a good speech, she was too exhausted at the time for any more speeches. All she craved was her private life with Leonard and their children.
Active Themes
Activism and Resistance Theme Icon