Obasan

by

Joy Kogawa

Teachers and parents! Our Teacher Edition on Obasan makes teaching easy.

Obasan: Chapter 32 Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
The news Naomi received that day in the spring was of Father’s death, but she can’t make herself believe it until 1951, when she says the words out loud. That year, the Nakanes move off the Barkers’ property and into their own house. At the same time, Naomi begins high school, while Stephen is in his final year, and is composing a cantata with his music teacher. The Barkers ignored the Nakanes when they lived on the farm, but their daughter Penny Barker attends Naomi’s school and is vying for a part in Stephen’s cantata, so one day in December she asks Naomi to see the family’s new house. Naomi reluctantly invites her over. When Penny sees the old family photographs in the house, Naomi admits for the first time that her father is dead.
In her denial of Father’s death, Naomi enters the tradition of silence that her family practices. While her relatives shield her from the truth with silence, she hides from the truth herself by refusing to acknowledge her father’s death. Only by speaking the words aloud does she accept that Father is dead.
Themes
Speech vs. Silence Theme Icon
Looking at the photographs makes Naomi think of Mother and Grandma Kato. Nakayama-sensei searched for them when he visited Japan after the war, but he found no trace of them. Stephen believes that they must be dead, since they would write to the family otherwise. Naomi writes to Aunt Emily, but Emily also insists that her sister and mother must be dead. Naomi eventually loses hope that Mother and Grandma Kato are alive, but she still occasionally imagines that they are. However, when Naomi looks through Emily’s box of documents in 1972, she finds letters that prove that Mother and Grandma Kato at least survived the war.
The mystery of what happened to Mother haunts Naomi her entire life. This mystery is compounded by the family’s silence. The documents in Emily’s box prove that the family had more information on Mother and Grandma Kato than they revealed to Naomi and Stephen, which adds another layer of mystery: why has the family chosen to hide the truth? The fact that Naomi begins to find answers to this lifelong question in the box also underlines its importance and the broader importance of preserving historical records.
Themes
History and Memory Theme Icon
Speech vs. Silence Theme Icon