Previous
Chapter 4
Themes
and Colors
Key
LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in Poetics, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work.
Tragedy vs. Epic Poetry
Imitation
Fear, Pity, and Catharsis
Component Parts and Balance
Summary
Analysis
Aristotle claims that plot is the most important component part of tragedy, and so it is important to discuss the qualities and structure of plot.
Again, Aristotle points out how important plot is in tragedy, and he offers a comprehensive discussion of what exactly plot is.
Active
Themes
5.1 Completeness. Tragedy “is an imitation of a complete, i.e. whole, action, possessing a certain magnitude.” To be “whole,” a tragedy must have a beginning, a middle, and an end. A beginning does not necessarily follow anything, but something must follow after it. An end, on the other hand, does follow something, but there is nothing after it. A middle has something before it and something after it. A successful tragedy does not begin or end at arbitrary points, and it follows this simple form.
Aristotle’s definition of what makes a tragedy “whole” seems rather straightforward; however, it is important to remember that Aristotle was the first to put such definitions down in writing, thereby making them official and legitimate. Elevating literature to a scientific level is one of the aims of literary theory. Thus, every possible aspect of literature is defined, categorized, and explored, just as would be done within the sciences.
Active
Themes
5.2 Magnitude. An imitation of an object, be that object a human being or something else, must possess all the parts it aims to imitate, and its magnitude cannot be arbitrary. “Beauty consists in magnitude as well as order,” Aristotle says. If an object is too small, its beauty is too difficult to discern. Conversely, if an object is too large, its beauty can also be difficult to appreciate. The problem with objects that are too big is that unity of observation becomes impossible and the sense of completeness is lost.
Objects possess a specific magnitude, and they should be readily taken in with just one view. The same goes for plot, which should be of a very specific length and should be easily held in memory. Aristotle defines the magnitude of plot as “the magnitude in which a series of events occurring sequentially in accordance with probability or necessity” gives rise to a change in fortune from either good to bad or vice versa.
Active
Themes
Get the entire Poetics LitChart as a printable PDF.
"My students can't get enough of your charts and their results have gone through the roof." -Graham S.
5.3 Unity. Focusing on a single person is not what makes a plot unified—lots of things can happen to any one person, and any combination of these things does not necessarily constitute unity. Similarly, an actor may perform several actions, but these actions might not constitute a single action. This is why, Aristotle reasons, Homer did not include in the Odyssey every last thing that happened to Odysseus. Instead, the whole of the Odyssey constitutes a single unified action—Odysseus’s journey home from the Trojan War—and nothing more.
Active
Themes
5.4 Determinate State. An imitation is considered to have unity if it imitates a single object. The same goes for plot, which should imitate a single and complete action. The structure of a plot must be created in a way that if a single part of it is taken out or moved, it changes the plot as a whole. If the absence of a single part does not affect the whole, it is not truly a part of the whole and does not belong.
Active
Themes
5.5 Universality. It is not the poet’s job to write “what has happened,” Aristotle claims, but to write what “would happen, i.e. what is possible in accordance with probability or necessity.” The historian and the poet are not different because one writes in verse and the other prose; they are different because one writes what has happened, and the other writes what would happen. Even if the works of Herodotus were written in verse, Aristotle claims, Herodotus would still be a historian.
History expresses particulars, but poetry expresses universals. A universal is speech or behavior that matches what a certain kind of person would most likely do or say. Because poetry is universal, it is more serious and philosophical than history. The plot of a comedy, for instance, is constructed based on probabilities, and then characters are selected. This process is different from the construction of a lampoon or tragedy, which often focus on a specific person. What has happened is possible in tragedy, Aristotle says, but even in such cases, only one or two characters are familiar and the rest are inventions.
Active
Themes
A poet is “a maker of plots,” Aristotle clarifies, not a maker of verses, and the object of a poet’s imitation is action. If a poet does write about the sort of thing that has happened, they are still a poet. If something has happened before, it is obviously the sort of thing that could and would happen. Writing about the sort of the thing that would happen (whether or not it actually has happened) is what makes a poet.
Active
Themes
5.6 Defective Plots. Episodic plots are by far the worst of the simple plots, Aristotle argues, which means the sequence of the episodes occur in such a way that seems unlikely or implausible. Bad poets compose episodic plots, as do some good poets for the purposes of “competitive display,” during which a plot can be extended past its potential, wrecking the entire sequence.
Active
Themes
