Clyde Richter is Amal’s first attorney, a White man who claims to fight for justice but never actually proves he’s on Amal’s side. Amal quickly comes to distrust him, noting how Clyde puts on one face in private and another in court. His defense is lukewarm at best—he fails to adequately challenge the prosecution’s narrative and recruits Ms. Rinaldi, Amal’s White, biased former art teacher, to testify as Amal’s character witness. Her damaging testimony solidifies Amal’s portrayal as an angry Black teen. Umi eventually fires Clyde and hires Tarana Hudson to represent Amal instead, a Black attorney who sees him clearly and believes in his innocence. Ultimately, Clyde is someone who claims to care but whose support is superficial, mirroring the very systems that failed Amal in the first place.