Tender Is the Night

Tender Is the Night

by

F. Scott Fitzgerald

Teachers and parents! Our Teacher Edition on Tender Is the Night makes teaching easy.

Tender Is the Night: Book 2, Chapter 17 Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
Dick bumps into Tommy Barban, a natural leader and “hero,” playing cards in a café in Munich. Tommy is joking around with three men—Prince Chillicheff, Mr. McKibben, and Mr. Hannan—when he sees Dick and exclaims, “You don’t look so—[…] jaunty as you used to.”
Tommy immediately notices the marked difference in Dick—he looks sullen and fatigued and doesn’t have his usually bouncy charm about him. Tommy, on the other hand, is as active and amiable as ever.
Themes
Excess, Destruction, and the Failed American Dream Theme Icon
Chillicheff, McKibben, and Hannan go on to explain how they were imprisoned in Russia and tell a captivating story about their escape. When McKibben invites Dick to travel with him in the car to Innsbruck the following day, Dick quickly declines the invitation. Distracted for a moment by the unappealing thought of squeezing into a packed car with McKibben and his family, Dick realizes that the others are discussing Abe North. “Didn’t you read The Herald this morning?” asks Tommy, “He’s dead. He was beaten to death in a speakeasy in New York.”
Abe’s death was extremely undignified. The fact that he was beaten and left to die in a bar suggests that he was never able to overcome his drinking problem and continued to run into scuffs and problems after the Divers left him in Paris. Abe’s fate is contrasted with Tommy’s, who is portrayed as a brave and masculine warrior. Abe, then, becomes the image of an indulgent American who met his demise through excessive drinking and reckless behavior, while Tommy, the European, is cast as a sort of hero.
Themes
Excess, Destruction, and the Failed American Dream Theme Icon
Dick decides to leave, but he is so shocked by the news of Abe’s death that he is barely conscious of the journey back to his hotel. Tommy invites him to join them for dinner the following evening but Dick declines “hastily.” That night Dick awakes to a possession of war veterans marching outside his window “with a sort of swagger for a lost magnificence, a past effort, a forgotten sorrow.” Seeing the “mournful march,” Dick is overcome with “regret for Abe’s death, and his own youth of ten years ago.”
The war procession outside of Dick’s window remind him of all the hopes, dreams, and values he nurtured as a young man: to be honorable, manly, and heroic. Dick was spared from the war effort on the assumption that he would become a great medical man, but he has achieved little success in his life. The war veterans thus serve to remind Dick of his own failures.
Themes
Excess, Destruction, and the Failed American Dream Theme Icon