The Consolation of Philosophy

The Consolation of Philosophy

by

Boethius

Teachers and parents! Our Teacher Edition on The Consolation of Philosophy makes teaching easy.

The Consolation of Philosophy: Book V, Part V Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
Philosophy suggests that, for humans, sense perception comes before before the mind actively “judges [sensory experiences] of its own power.” But, for some kinds of knowing subjects, perception can happen without this kind of input from the body. Indeed, different beings are able to know in different ways: animals without “power of movement, like mussels and other shellfish,” can only know through sense-perception, while other animals have sense-perception and imagination, and only humans have reason in addition to these. “Intelligence,” in turn, “belongs only to divinity.” And, again, each higher form “transcends the others”—for instance, if reason were to conflict with the imagination and sense-perception, humans would trust reason over them. Because “divine intelligence” is the highest form of knowledge, Philosophy continues, “human reason [should] bow before” it. And this “supreme intelligence,” she hopes to show, can have foreknowledge of things that aren’t certain to occur.
After summarizing the conclusions of the Stoics she cited in the last song, Philosophy explains how her hierarchy of ways of knowing corresponds to a hierarchy of forms of being. Humans are the second-highest, after God, and this lets Philosophy restate her earlier claim that God can know things unavailable to humans in a more clear and specific way: God has intelligence, but humans do not, so while He can know things that aren’t certain to occur, humans cannot imagine this form of knowledge because they are not capable of it. Therefore, the problem of divine foreknowledge is solved. However, Philosophy has still done little to explain how God’s “divine intelligence” actually works (to the extent that humans can know it), so this is the subject of the Consolation’s final section.
Themes
Human Free Will and God’s Foreknowledge Theme Icon
Quotes
Philosophy sings about the different ways that life takes shape on earth. There are animals that slither on  the ground, others that fly, and others still that walk across the earth—but all of these kinds of life “look […] downward to the ground.” In contrast, only humans can look upwards rather than downwards. They should also “raise up” their minds and “thoughts.”
Philosophy’s ode to the diversity of being is a reminder that numerous, diverse kinds of knowledge are possible, but it also implies that humans have supremacy over the rest of the animal kingdom because of our capacity for reason. This argument, long taken for granted, is in turn a justification for humans’ attempts to control and shape nature. And clearly, the “rais[ing] up” of the mind refers to humans looking to heaven, where they can encounter God, His “divine intelligence,” His perfectly-ordered Providence, and the perfect wisdom and happiness he promises.
Themes
Classical Philosophy and Medieval Christianity Theme Icon
Wisdom, Fortune, and Happiness Theme Icon
The Problem of Evil Theme Icon
Human Free Will and God’s Foreknowledge Theme Icon