The grand situational irony of the beginning of the novel is that Michael Henchard, rather than being punished for drunkenly "selling" his wife and daughter for five guineas, has become a sober, successful, and seemingly happy man by the third chapter. This is framed in Chapter 4 as a surprise for his wife, who returns with her daughter to find him, and the reader feels the unfairness of the situation for Susan keenly:
Time, the magician, had wrought much here. Watching him, and thus thinking of past days, she became so moved that she shrank back against the jamb of the wagon-office doorway to which the steps gave access, the shadow from it conveniently hiding her features. She forgot her daughter till a touch from Elizabeth-Jane aroused her. “Have you seen him, mother?” whispered the girl. “Yes, yes,” answered her companion hastily. “I have seen him, and it is enough for me! Now I only want to go—pass away—die.”