Bernard Gui Quotes in The Name of the Rose
Fifth Day Quotes
What Bernard wanted was clear. Without the slightest interest in knowing who had killed the other monks, he wanted only to show that Remigio somehow shared the ideas propounded by the Emperor's theologians. And once he had shown the connection between those ideas […] and had shown that one man in that abbey subscribed to all those heresies and had been the author of many crimes, he would thus have dealt a truly mortal blow to his adversaries.
Bernard demands that Remigio confess to two crimes: that he is a heretic who followed Fra Dolcino, and that he is guilty of all the murders that have taken place at the abbey. Adso observes that Bernard doesn’t have “the slightest interest” in knowing who killed the other monks, but only wants to make a connection between the crimes and those like Fra Dolcino, Ubertino, and Michael, who advocate for the poverty of Christ and deny the authority of the Pope. If he can show that Remigio was both a follower of “the ideas propounded by the Emperor’s theologians” and a murderer, that would be a “truly mortal blow” to the credibility of Bernard’s enemies. Under threat of torture, Remigio falsely confesses, naming Salvatore as his accomplice. Bernard tells the Emperor’s supporters that anyone who shares their heretical ideas will be punished. This threat effectively prevents any chance of reconciliation between the Emperor’s supporters and the Pope’s envoys. Ubertino flees under cover of darkness, and Michael leaves the abbey dejected. Throughout the trial, Bernard shows little regard for the truth. This is a miscarriage of justice because Bernard doesn’t care about finding and punishing the murderer; he only wants to use the trial to attack the Pope’s political enemies. In this way, Eco shows that the supposedly moral proceedings of the church were often thinly-veiled displays of political power.