The Signalman
by Charles Dickens
✓

or to save your progress

The Signalman Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
The narrator calls out to a signalman working below ground in a trench, yelling, “Halloa! Below there!” The signalman, instead of looking up immediately, glances toward the train tracks, which the narrator finds strange—it seems obvious to the narrator that his voice is coming from above. Eventually, though, the signalman spots the narrator above him. The narrator asks whether he can come visit the signalman in the trench, and a train passes with a “violent pulsation,” which the narrator almost believes will drag him downward. The signalman guides the train through his station with a flag.   
The physical position of the signalman and narrator establishes their dynamic and respective social positions: the narrator seems to be casually passing by the signalman’s trench, suggesting he has some free time. The signalman, meanwhile, works below ground—his social position is literally below the narrator’s, and he stands below him at the start of the story. The narrator’s decision to greet the narrator seems to be an impulsive one; because the first line of the story is “Halloa! Below there!” readers aren’t privy to his reasoning. The signalman’s instinctive reaction, which leads him to look toward the tunnel instead of at the narrator, suggests that something is amiss. But only thing that immediately appears to be amiss is the passing of a “violent” train, which symbolizes the crushing power of industry over humans. The narrator’s fear that the train will harm him by dragging him down—presumably to where the signalman is—establishes the signalman’s trench as a hellish landscape where someone would go only if forced.
Active Themes
Helplessness, Fate, and Death Theme Icon
Quotes
Literary Devices
After the narrator repeats his question, the signalman points out a path leading down to his post—the narrator notices that the signalman does so reluctantly and awaits the narrator’s approach with “expectation.” Once the narrator is below ground, he notices how bleak the signalman’s surroundings are: the stone walls block the sky, and the only thing to look at is a black tunnel with a red light above it. Even the smell is “deadly,” the air is cold, and the narrator almost feels that he has “left the natural world.”
The narrator has to descend below ground to visit the signalman at his post, again suggesting the signalman’s trench is in some way akin to Hell. Because the signalman doesn’t actually want the narrator to visit him, the way he awaits the narrator with “expectation” suggests that he’s waiting for some grim encounter and isn’t trying to stop it. The narrator’s observations about the signalman’s trench seem to confirm that it is a hellscape, since the narrator observes that there’s no sign of life there: the signalman can’t look up at the sky, it smells “deadly,” there’s no warm air, and the place seems to be separate from the “natural world.”
Active Themes
Helplessness, Fate, and Death Theme Icon
Quotes
Literary Devices
The narrator tries to make conversation; after living a sheltered life, he’s now interested in the railroad industry. But the signalman keeps looking at the red light and then back at the narrator. The narrator asks whether the red light is part of the signalman’s job, and the signalman strangely replies, “Don’t you know it is?” The narrator notices that the signalman seems afraid of him, and the signalman tells the narrator that they may have met before, near the red light. The narrator replies that he’s never been there before, which the signalman accepts.
Active Themes
Responsibility and Guilt Theme Icon
Quotes
Friendlier now, the signalman answers the narrator’s questions about his job. The signalman acknowledges that monitoring trains requires “exactness and watchfulness.” It’s lonely, but he says that he’s used to it—he’s dabbled with hobbies, but ultimately, his work has to be his priority. Even when he’s able to go above ground to see the sunlight, he can be called back by his bell at any moment, and as a result is always listening for it anxiously.
Active Themes
Responsibility and Guilt Theme Icon
Helplessness, Fate, and Death Theme Icon
Quotes
Get the entire The Signalman LitChart as a printable PDF.
"My students can't get enough of your charts and their results have gone through the roof." -Graham S.
The Signalman PDF
The signalman takes the narrator into his box (the little room he works in near the tracks), which contains the bell that warns of approaching trains. The narrator remarks that the signalman seems unusually well educated, and the signalman tells him that he was once a natural philosophy student but squandered his opportunities. He doesn’t resent this, and he explains that “he had made his bed, and he lay upon it”—there’s no way to change his circumstances now.
Active Themes
Responsibility and Guilt Theme Icon
Helplessness, Fate, and Death Theme Icon
Quotes
Literary Devices
The narrator finds the signalman to be humble and responsible: during their conversation, the signalman sometimes has to leave to fulfill various tasks, such as displaying flags and speaking to train drivers. In this, the narrator notes that the signalman is “exact and vigilant,” even stopping in the middle of a syllable to fulfill his duty. However, the narrator also notices that the signalman is distracted. Twice, the signalman stops speaking, turns pale, and looks toward the silent bell. He then opens the door of his box and looks toward the red light before returning inside, clearly shaken.
Active Themes
Responsibility and Guilt Theme Icon
Hoping to get him to speak about this distraction, the narrator tells the signalman that he seems content. The signalman replies that he was once but is now “troubled,” and he says that he’ll explain why if the narrator visits again tomorrow. The signalman warns the narrator that if he does visit, he shouldn’t call out this time. He then asks why the narrator said “Halloa! Below there!” The narrator doesn’t know, but the signalman wonders whether the words may have been “conveyed” to the narrator in “a supernatural way.” The narrator denies this and leaves the trench.
Active Themes
Helplessness, Fate, and Death Theme Icon
The Supernatural and the Unknown Theme Icon
Quotes
The next night, the two men sit in the signalman’s box again, and the signalman reveals that when he first saw the narrator, he mistook him for someone else. Though the signalman doesn’t know this other person’s face, they waved to him; the signalman demonstrates the gesture, which the narrator thinks looks similar to saying “For God’s sake, clear the way!” The figure called to the signalman one night, standing near the red light and yelling, “Halloa! Below there!” and “Look out!” The signalman followed the figure into the tunnel, but it disappeared. The signalman left the tunnel, which frightened him, and telegraphed an alarm to nearby stations, who replied that nothing was wrong.
Active Themes
Responsibility and Guilt Theme Icon
The Supernatural and the Unknown Theme Icon
Quotes
Literary Devices
The narrator tells the signalman that this encounter must have been a figment of his imagination, especially because the wind in the “unnatural valley” of the trench could sound like a cry. But the signalman continues his story, saying that six hours after the encounter, there was a crash on the train line, which killed and wounded passengers. The narrator agrees that this is a coincidence but says that the signalman shouldn’t dwell on coincidences in his life.
Active Themes
The Supernatural and the Unknown Theme Icon
Literary Devices
Undaunted, the signalman reveals that six months after the accident, the figure—which he now believes is a ghost—appeared at the red light again. This time it was silent, holding its hands over its face in an “action of mourning.” The signalman retreated into his box. The next day, he noticed hands waving in a passing train; he ran after the train, signaling the driver to stop, but the train drifted many yards before stopping. By the time the signalman reached the train, a young woman had died and was laid down in the signalman’s box.
Active Themes
Responsibility and Guilt Theme Icon
Helplessness, Fate, and Death Theme Icon
The Supernatural and the Unknown Theme Icon
Quotes
Literary Devices
The signalman presses on with his story, telling the narrator that a week ago, the ghost returned at the red light and has been haunting him in “fits and starts” ever since. The ghost gestures with the motion the narrator believed to mean “For God’s sake, clear the way!” and yells “Below there! Look out!” The narrator realizes that the signalman was distracted last night because he heard and saw the ghost, which the signalman claims rang his bell (though the narrator never heard it). In an attempt to prove that the signalman’s hauntings are imaginary, the narrator takes the signalman out to look at the red light, and the ghost isn’t there.
Active Themes
Helplessness, Fate, and Death Theme Icon
The Supernatural and the Unknown Theme Icon
Literary Devices
While the narrator thinks about other ways to convince the signalman, the signalman tells the narrator that he wants to figure out what the ghost means and what it’s warning him about, because he’s now certain that there will be a third accident. He believes that this is a “cruel haunting”: if he telegraphed an alarm, he wouldn’t be able to give specifics and might be fired. The narrator notes that the signalman seems to have an “unintelligible responsibility involving life.” The signalman wonders why, if the accidents were preventable, the ghost wouldn’t give him more details, or wouldn’t notify someone with more power than him.
Active Themes
Responsibility and Guilt Theme Icon
Helplessness, Fate, and Death Theme Icon
The Supernatural and the Unknown Theme Icon
Quotes
Literary Devices
The narrator decides that he should try to calm the signalman, rather than convince him the hauntings aren’t real. He tells the signalman that even if he doesn’t understand the hauntings, he at least “understood his duty.” After leaving, the narrator reflects that the signalman’s story is disturbing but is primarily concerned about his ability to do his job: though the signalman is careful now, he might grow more distracted and accidentally cause a rail accident. The narrator decides that the next day, instead of expressing his concerns to the signalman’s boss, he’ll offer to accompany the signalman to a doctor.
Active Themes
Responsibility and Guilt Theme Icon
Helplessness, Fate, and Death Theme Icon
Quotes
However, when the narrator arrives at the signalman’s station, he notices a man waving his arms near the tunnel and is temporarily frightened. This turns out to be a train worker, standing with a group of other workers, apparently demonstrating the gesture. The red light is off, and the narrator notices a hut made out of wood “no bigger than a bed.” Climbing down to the scene, the narrator worries that there’s been a rail accident, and that it was his fault for leaving the signalman alone.
Active Themes
Responsibility and Guilt Theme Icon
The Supernatural and the Unknown Theme Icon
Quotes
Literary Devices
Instead, one of the workers tells the narrator that the signalman was “cut down” and killed by a train earlier that day. He was standing outside the tunnel with a lamp, and the train hit him after emerging from the tunnel. The engine-driver, Tom, who was conducting the train, demonstrates where the signalman was standing. Tom had no time to “check speed,” and the signalman seemed not to hear the whistle, so he turned it off, instead waving his arms and yelling, “Below there! Look out! […] For God’s sake, clear the way!”
Active Themes
Responsibility and Guilt Theme Icon
Helplessness, Fate, and Death Theme Icon
The Supernatural and the Unknown Theme Icon
Quotes
Literary Devices
The narrator decides to end the story without “dwell[ing] on any one of its curious circumstances,” but he reminds readers that Tom’s words included both his initial greeting to the signalman (“Below there!”) and the phrase he assigned to the ghost’s gesture (“For God’s sake, clear the way!”). However, the narrator never spoke the second phrase out loud.
Active Themes
Responsibility and Guilt Theme Icon
The Supernatural and the Unknown Theme Icon