Tec writes that she intuitively knew after reading Simon’s story that, for her, forgiveness would not be an option. Her initial certainty was followed by a “flood of arguments,” through which she came to recognize the complexity of the situation. As a Holocaust survivor, Tec has been asked whether she thought Jews should stop prosecuting the Nazis, particularly as so many of them are now so old. Her answer had been a clear-cut no, because the survivors have no right to forgive crimes committed against others.
While other Jewish respondents believe that the Nazis should not stop being prosecuted because this enables the world to forget their crimes, Tec takes a different angle on the issue, writing that allowing the crimes to go unpunished is a form of implicit forgiveness.
Tec points out that Karl’s guilt over a single family did not seem to include the Jews in general, nor did he show any compassion for Simon. His self-pity blinds him to the suffering of others. Karl himself states “I do not know who you are, I only know that you are a Jew and that is enough.” Only Simon’s Jewishness matters, making him a faceless representative of a mass of people.
In terms of Karl’s forgiveness, Tec’s argument is one of the most biting ones, quoting Karl directly to show that he seems uninterested in Simon’s personal story and his suffering. Karl is merely interested in Simon’s Jewishness.
On the other hand, Tec believes that Simon’s actions are remarkable. His silence not only shows an appropriate lack of forgiveness, but also a measure of compassion. Whereas Karl was indifferent to issues that did not bear on him directly, Simon and his friends demonstrated immense humanity in considering the moral implications of forgiveness in the concentration camp.
Whereas Karl has lost his ability to relate to other human beings, particularly the Jews, Simon treats a person who is complicit in the system causing his own suffering with immense humanity and compassion, especially in even asking himself whether Karl deserves forgiveness at all.