The Warmth of Other Suns

The Warmth of Other Suns

by

Isabel Wilkerson

Teachers and parents! Our Teacher Edition on The Warmth of Other Suns makes teaching easy.

The Warmth of Other Suns: Part Four: Los Angeles Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
Los Angeles, April 1953. Robert Foster drives into smoggy, wide-open Los Angeles and goes to meet William Beck, his old medical school professor. Beck decided to become a country doctor after his own father caught tuberculosis and died because there were no Black doctors around and no white doctor would treat him. After World War II, Beck and his wife moved to Los Angeles, where they decided to buy a grand mansion. A clause in the deed limited the house to white buyers, but the realtor found a way around it. Still, the night the Becks moved in, someone burned down a tree in their front yard. Then, all of their white neighbors moved out.
Dr. Beck’s life trajectory is a reminder that Black people chose to leave the South for diverse reasons, at all stages of their lives and careers. Beck shared a formative childhood experience with Ida Mae: both watched their fathers die because medical attention wasn’t available to them in the segregated South. Fortunately, Beck had the resources to help fight this problem and dedicated his life to it, like Robert’s brother Madison. Meanwhile, the Becks’ experience moving to a white neighborhood was depressingly typical in the mid-20th century. In fact, the federal government legally mandated that mortgages be restricted to all-white neighborhoods and whites-only clauses be put in property deeds. This meant that the government systematically funneled capital toward white neighborhoods and away from Black ones, while many white homeowners learned to expect financial disaster when Black neighbors moved in. These policies are the foundation of the close link between race, home values, and residential segregations that still shapes American cities today.
Themes
Migration and Freedom Theme Icon
History, Memory, and Identity Theme Icon
The Legacy of the Migration Theme Icon
The Economics of Racism Theme Icon
Love and Family Theme Icon
Decision, Consequence, and Regret Theme Icon
There are very few Black people in California until the Great Migration. And when they start arriving, they encounter a totally different system than in the South or North. They have to compete for jobs with immigrants from China, Japan, Mexico, and Europe, and every workplace is segregated differently.
Northeastern and Midwestern cities received most of their immigrants from Europe, so the racial hierarchy was familiar to Black newcomers: native-born white people were above white immigrants, who were above Black people, who took the worst available jobs. But California’s unique, less consistent ethnic mix meant that Black migrants didn’t reliably end up in the same jobs—even though they did reliably face discrimination.
Themes
Migration and Freedom Theme Icon
The Economics of Racism Theme Icon
Unsure what his future will hold, Robert Foster visits Dr. Beck at his office. Beck eagerly offers him a place to stay and the opportunity to work at his practice. Then, Robert meets some old classmates, who show him around Hollywood and Beverly Hills. Los Angeles is all he dreamed it would be: vast, beautiful, vibrant, and clean. It’s still divided by race, but a few successful Black families can break the color barrier.
Robert tours Los Angeles to decide whether he wants to live there. Dr. Beck’s hospitality and the city’s glamor charm him: he can easily picture himself building a life there, or even achieving the same standard of living as the city’s white professionals. In a word, he feels freer there than he ever has anywhere else, and his perilous journey seems to have been worth it.
Themes
Migration and Freedom Theme Icon
Decision, Consequence, and Regret Theme Icon
Next, Robert heads north to Oakland, his other option, where he knows more people from Monroe than in Los Angeles. But he finds that, even though the migrants are doing well, it looks just like Monroe. People have small cottages with gardens in the back—it isn’t glamorous at all. He stays with his friend John Dunlap, a mortician who is working at a shipyard. The next morning, he visits hospitals to look for a job, but he comes back empty-handed. So his decision is easy: he heads back to Los Angeles.
For many migrants, the opportunity to recreate a piece of the South in Oakland is a source of comfort and pride. But for Robert, it’s merely a reminder of a past that he would rather leave behind. So even though he recognizes that he could succeed in either city (and that it’s just a coincidence that John Dunlap happens to be in Oakland while Dr. Beck happens to be in Los Angeles), he never doubts his decision.
Themes
Migration and Freedom Theme Icon
History, Memory, and Identity Theme Icon
The Legacy of the Migration Theme Icon
Decision, Consequence, and Regret Theme Icon
Get the entire The Warmth of Other Suns LitChart as a printable PDF.
The Warmth of Other Suns PDF