What Men Live By

by Leo Tolstoy

Mikhail Character Analysis

Mikhail is the strange man whom Semyon finds naked and freezing on the roadside. He later becomes an unofficial member of Matryona and Semyon’s family, moving in with them and working as Semyon’s shoemaking apprentice. From his very first appearance, Mikhail exudes a mysterious energy. Not only is he strong and uninjured (which strikes Semyon as strange, considering his very vulnerable position when he was out naked in the road), but he also refuses to explain how he ended up there, or to shed any light on his past in general. Indeed, over the course of the next six years, Mikhail divulges very little about himself. He is a hard worker and a very talented shoemaker who quickly masters everything that Semyon teaches him, but he remains quiet and serious, seeming to hold himself slightly apart from the rest of the family. That Mikhail only smiles three times—at seemingly odd moments and with a strange, private intensity—also increases his aura of mystery. Mikhail also seems to understand things that are not clear to the other characters. For instance, he knows to make the rich gentleman light slippers even before the man’s death is announced. At the end of the story, Mikhail explains his mysterious presence by revealing himself to be an angel; having disobeying God, he was sent to earth in the form of a mortal to learn three lessons.

Mikhail Quotes in What Men Live By

The What Men Live By quotes below are all either spoken by Mikhail or refer to Mikhail. For each quote, you can also see the other characters and themes related to it (each theme is indicated by its own dot and icon, like this one:
Mystery Theme Icon
).

Chapter 1 Quotes

And if he doesn’t throttle me I might get lumbered with looking after him. But how can I help a naked man? I couldn’t let him have the last shirt off my back.

Related Characters: Semyon (speaker), Mikhail
Page Number and Citation: 125
Explanation and Analysis:

‘Please God, help me!’

Related Characters: Semyon (speaker), Mikhail
Page Number and Citation: 125
Explanation and Analysis:

Chapter 3 Quotes

[Matryona’s] heart seemed to melt and she felt that she wanted to banish all those spiteful feelings and to find out who that man really was.

Related Characters: Matryona, Mikhail, Semyon
Related Symbols: Coats
Page Number and Citation: 130
Explanation and Analysis:

Chapter 4 Quotes

‘We’re always giving, but why does nobody ever give us anything?’

Related Characters: Matryona (speaker), Mikhail, Semyon
Related Symbols: Bread
Page Number and Citation: 132
Explanation and Analysis:

Chapter 6 Quotes

Mikhail kept staring until suddenly he smiled and his whole face lit up.

‘What are you grinning at, idiot?’ the gentleman asked. ‘You’d better see to it that the boots are ready on time!’

Related Characters: The Gentleman (speaker), Mikhail, Semyon
Page Number and Citation: 135
Explanation and Analysis:

Chapter 7 Quotes

Matryona went over to watch Mikhail working and was amazed to see what he was doing.

Related Characters: Matryona, Mikhail, The Gentleman, Semyon, Marya
Page Number and Citation: 135
Explanation and Analysis:

Chapter 10 Quotes

“‘Children cannot live without a father or mother,’ she pleaded. So I did not take that woman’s soul.”

Related Characters: Mikhail (speaker), Marya, The Gentleman
Related Symbols: Bread
Page Number and Citation: 141
Explanation and Analysis:

Chapter 11 Quotes

“And I could hear this man wondering how to protect his body from the winter cold and feed his wife and children. And I thought, ‘I am perishing with cold and hunger, but here is someone whose only thought is how to find a warm coat for himself and his wife, and food for his family.’”

Related Characters: Mikhail (speaker), Semyon, Matryona, The Gentleman
Related Symbols: Coats
Page Number and Citation: 142
Explanation and Analysis:

Chapter 12 Quotes

‘I came to understand that God does not wish men to live apart and that is why He does not reveal to each man what he needs for himself alone.’

Related Characters: Mikhail (speaker), The Gentleman
Page Number and Citation: 143
Explanation and Analysis:
Get the entire What Men Live By LitChart as a printable PDF.
"My students can't get enough of your charts and their results have gone through the roof." -Graham S.
What Men Live By PDF

Mikhail Character Timeline in What Men Live By

The timeline below shows where the character Mikhail appears in What Men Live By. The colored dots and icons indicate which themes are associated with that appearance.
Chapter 1
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
...but then he realizes that it is a naked man. Semyon can’t tell if this stranger is dead or alive, and he speculates that perhaps someone has murdered the man, taken... (full context)
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
Selfless Love Theme Icon
Looking over his shoulder one last time, however, Semyon notices that the stranger is moving. He wonders if he should go back and help, but he convinces himself... (full context)
Mystery Theme Icon
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
Selfless Love Theme Icon
...stops suddenly and reproaches himself for his callousness. Is he really going to leave this stranger to die alone? He asks himself sarcastically if he has become so rich that he... (full context)
Chapter 2
Mystery Theme Icon
Selfless Love Theme Icon
Getting closer to the stranger, Semyon sees that he looks young, healthy, and uninjured. As Semyon approaches, the naked man... (full context)
Mystery Theme Icon
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
Semyon reaches to take his hat off his head and give it to the stranger. But his head feels cold, and he reasons that the young man has a full... (full context)
Mystery Theme Icon
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
Selfless Love Theme Icon
As they walk, Semyon asks the stranger where he is from. The man responds vaguely that he is “not from these parts.”... (full context)
Mystery Theme Icon
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
Selfless Love Theme Icon
Continuing on the road with the stranger, Semyon begins to feel cold. He starts to think again about his unsuccessful expedition: not... (full context)
Chapter 3
Mystery Theme Icon
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
Just then, Semyon and the stranger arrive home. Matryona smells the alcohol on her husband’s breath, and she immediately realizes that... (full context)
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
Selfless Love Theme Icon
...can do about this and pretends not to notice it. He offers food to the stranger and then turns to Matryona, asking her what they will be having for dinner. At... (full context)
Mystery Theme Icon
Selfless Love Theme Icon
...decides that she wants to “banish all those spiteful feelings” and find out who the stranger is. (full context)
Chapter 4
Mystery Theme Icon
Selfless Love Theme Icon
Matryona asks her husband to explain how he met the stranger. Semyon tells her that the man was sitting naked by the chapel; he believes that... (full context)
Mystery Theme Icon
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
Selfless Love Theme Icon
Suddenly Matryona pities the stranger, and she feels her anger leave her. She gets out dinner, kvass, and the last... (full context)
Mystery Theme Icon
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
Selfless Love Theme Icon
After dinner, Matryona begins to question the stranger, asking where he is from and how he came to be naked by the church.... (full context)
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
Selfless Love Theme Icon
...Matryona cannot fall asleep. At first, she frets about the fact that she gave the stranger their last piece of bread, and now they won’t have anything to feed their children... (full context)
Chapter 5
Mystery Theme Icon
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
The next morning, while Matryona is borrowing bread from a neighbor, Semyon asks the stranger what kind of work he can do. The stranger says he doesn’t know how to... (full context)
Mystery Theme Icon
Semyon teaches Mikhail how to twist and wax yarn. Mikhail proves to be a very quick study; within... (full context)
Chapter 6
Selfless Love Theme Icon
Time passes; Mikhail has now been living with Semyon and Matryona for a year. Mikhail’s outstanding workmanship has... (full context)
Mystery Theme Icon
Selfless Love Theme Icon
Semyon is afraid of the gentleman and his high-stakes proposal. He looks to Mikhail to ask whether they should accept the job, and Mikhail nods. Then Semyon takes the... (full context)
Mystery Theme Icon
Selfless Love Theme Icon
Semyon turns to look at Mikhail and sees that Mikhail is staring blankly into a corner. Suddenly and seemingly without cause,... (full context)
Chapter 7
Mystery Theme Icon
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
Semyon and Mikhail begin to make the gentleman’s boots. They have decided that Mikhail will do the bulk... (full context)
Mystery Theme Icon
...be made into a pair of slippers for the gentleman to wear in his coffin. Mikhail exhibits no surprise on hearing this news; he calmly takes the slippers he has already... (full context)
Chapter 8
Mystery Theme Icon
Several more years pass, and Mikhail continues to be an invaluable addition to the family and business. He remains quiet and... (full context)
Mystery Theme Icon
...are identical twins. As Semyon is discussing the job with the woman, he notices that Mikhail is still behaving strangely: he has stopped working and is staring at the two girls.... (full context)
Chapter 9
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
Selfless Love Theme Icon
...and then she leaves with the twins. After she leaves, Semyon and Matryona turn to Mikhail: they are surprised to find that his face has once again been overtaken by a... (full context)
Chapter 10
Mystery Theme Icon
Semyon asks Mikhail what has made him smile this way. Mikhail stands up, bows, and says that God... (full context)
Mystery Theme Icon
Mikhail explains that he is glowing because God has forgiven him; up until this moment, God... (full context)
Mystery Theme Icon
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
Selfless Love Theme Icon
Mikhail says that God punished him for disobeying him. When Mikhail was an angel, God asked... (full context)
Mystery Theme Icon
However, when Mikhail returned to heaven and told God about what had happened, God told him that he... (full context)
Chapter 11
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
Selfless Love Theme Icon
Hearing Mikhail’s story, Semyon and Matryona begin to weep. The angel then recalls how he sat beside... (full context)
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
Selfless Love Theme Icon
Mikhail then remembers how Semyon turned back for him. Semyon’s whole face seemed to have changed,... (full context)
Mystery Theme Icon
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
Next, Mikhail recalls the episode with the wealthy man. He tells Matryona and Semyon that he could... (full context)
Mystery Theme Icon
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
Selfless Love Theme Icon
But, Mikhail continues, he did not learn the answer to the third question—“what men live by”—until today,... (full context)
Chapter 12
Mystery Theme Icon
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
Selfless Love Theme Icon
The moment Mikhail finishes telling his story, his body becomes so bright that Semyon and Matryona cannot look... (full context)
Mystery Theme Icon
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
Selfless Love Theme Icon
...rather through the selfless love that others show them. Semyon and Matryona’s selfless love saved Mikhail’s life, just as the woman’s selfless love saved the twins’ life. Mikhail now understands that... (full context)