When Will There Be Good News?

When Will There Be Good News?

by

Kate Atkinson

Teachers and parents! Our Teacher Edition on When Will There Be Good News? makes teaching easy.

When Will There Be Good News?: The Prodigal Wife Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
Louise is getting ready to drive to Hawes with Marcus. She thinks about how innocent he looks. In her own youth, most of the men she’d been with had been older and, she now realizes, probably “pervy.” When she and Patrick were getting to know each other, Louise lied and said she’d only been with a few guys and had lost her virginity at 18. She reflects that she would have made a good con woman. She should have told the truth—that she has no idea how to love another person. Louise and Patrick had a small fight when Louise had told him she was taking a trip to England. She told him not to tell her how to do her job, and he told her that the “Scottish chip on [her] shoulder” was getting in the way of her better self.
Louise has finally decided to pursue the lead to find Joanna’s aunt, and she takes her young protege, Marcus, with her. Thinking about Marcus’s youth makes Louise think about her own, which she’d deliberately misrepresented to Patrick, showing that she both mistrusts him and doesn’t respect herself. She believes herself incapable of both loving and being loved for who she is, hence constantly burying herself in her work and refusing to open up to Patrick.
Themes
Trauma, Survival, and Reckoning with the Past Theme Icon
Appearances vs. Reality Theme Icon
Lies and Deceptions Theme Icon
Family Theme Icon
Quotes
During the trip, Louise makes fun of Marcus’s CD collection, telling him, “You’re too young to die yet.” When they see a newspaper headline about Andrew Decker (“Freed Killer Flees”), Marcus muses that Decker has paid his dues; “should he pay forever?” Louise says yes and promises Marcus that he, too, will be “hard and unfeeling” someday.
Louise’s playful comment to Marcus turns out to be foreshadowing. Marcus wonders whether the prolonged hounding of Decker is just, but Louise attributes this attitude to his lack of cynicism.
Themes
Family Theme Icon
Louise gets several agitated messages from Reggie, including a license plate number and the contents of Joanna Hunter’s purse. Louise is beginning to suspect that Reggie might be right. Louise has the license number run, and the station reports back that it’s registered to a Glasgow chauffeur company. She also tells Marcus that the “Andrew Decker” in the hospital was an “ordinary guy.” Privately, she’d checked on Jackson’s whereabouts and was annoyed that “the bastard” had discharged himself without even saying goodbye to her. They reach Hawes, “a small market town with a big cheese thing going on.” Louise isn’t fond of it—she prefers the city. “[T]he countryside unsettled her because she didn’t know who the enemy was.” Meanwhile, being in Yorkshire keeps reminding Louise of Jackson.
From Louise’s investigation, it appears certain that Neil’s business associates are connected with Joanna’s disappearance. The identity swap between Jackson and Decker is still a mystery, however. Louise feels out of place in the country because she can’t identify the dangers in advance—similar to the way she feels in a secure, conventional marriage.
Themes
Appearances vs. Reality Theme Icon
Lies and Deceptions Theme Icon
Quotes
Louise and Marcus knock at the address of Agnes Barker. The big, unattractive renter who answers the door has never heard of her, but gives Louise a phone number. The girl at the rental agency directs them to a nursing home. Meanwhile, the station has been unable to locate a car rental for Joanna Hunter. They did find one for Andrew Decker, with his “daughter.”
Their investigation proves that the claim that Joanna went to her aunt’s house is false; it appears that someone has taken her somewhere else. Meanwhile, Jackson has apparently absconded with Reggie, naively using Decker’s ID.
Themes
Appearances vs. Reality Theme Icon
Lies and Deceptions Theme Icon
Get the entire When Will There Be Good News? LitChart as a printable PDF.
When Will There Be Good News? PDF
The nursing home is “everything Louise feared for herself.” It’s a “place to send people whom nobody wanted.” Louise decides she will kill herself before winding up helpless and set aside. The girl at the reception desk informs them that Agnes Barker can’t meet with them—she died a couple of weeks ago of a massive stroke, leaving only estranged family behind her. Louise doesn’t know what to do next. Did Joanna lie to everyone about the sick aunt, or did Neil lie about Joanna’s whereabouts? Louise suspects that Joanna can “dissemble with the best of them.” She can imagine Joanna pursuing vengeance on Decker 30 years later, because Louise would do the same herself.
Louise is fearful of winding up unloved and alone like everyone at the nursing home. It turns out that everything concerning the sickly aunt was a big lie—but whose lie? Louise recognizes that Joanna is not as innocent as she appears, so Louise wouldn’t put such a lie past her—even an attempt to track down and kill Decker. She assumes that Joanna would think and act much as Louise herself would.
Themes
Lies and Deceptions Theme Icon
Family Theme Icon
Quotes
Louise feels adrift. She and Marcus go to a café for afternoon tea. Reggie calls Louise, and she ignores the call, then reconsiders and calls her back. Jackson answers. Louise thinks, “Didn’t it make sense that two of the most provoking people she could think of would somehow be together.” The reception is lost before Louise can get an explanation. Then she gets a call from the station—Andrew Decker was stopped and taken to the hospital after some sort of accident. Louise also learns that Joanna Hunter had visited Decker a month before his release from prison. Louise wonders why Joanna had never mentioned this. A final call from the station tells Louise that Joanna’s calls have been traced, and that several of the received calls are registered to Jackson Brodie’s mobile.
Louise calls Reggie and can’t understand how in the world Jackson answers instead, but isn’t surprised that two such doggedly stubborn personalities would gravitate to one another. She also learns that Joanna hasn’t been completely forthcoming about her relationship with Decker—and now she appears to have some sort of a connection with Jackson Brodie as well. Louise begins to piece together that there’s been some sort of identity mix-up between Brodie and Decker.
Themes
Appearances vs. Reality Theme Icon
Lies and Deceptions Theme Icon