Themes
Key
LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in White Fragility, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work.
White Fragility
White Supremacy
Racism and the Good/Bad Binary
Individualism, Objectivity, and Meritocracy
Summary
Analysis
Robin DiAngelo, who is a white woman, and her colleague, who is a Black woman, are leading a workplace diversity training workshop. During the workshop, DiAngelo acknowledges that white people hold social and institutional power over people of color. In response, a white man in the room pounds his fists on the table and yells that it’s impossible for white people to get jobs anymore. DiAngelo observes that 38 of the 40 employees in the room are white—only two are people of color. She wonders why the man is so angry, and why the other white people are remaining silent in the face of his outburst.
The book opens with a classic example of white fragility, though it doesn’t yet name it as such. Addressing racism triggers this man’s anger and causes him to frame white people as victims—despite the fact that white people clearly have an advantage in being hired at the company. By remaining silent on the issue, the other white people in the room are giving tacit approval to what the man is saying—exhibiting what DiAngelo will term “white solidarity.”
Themes
White people in the United States live in a deeply unequal society, and they benefit from that inequality. As a result, they are insulated from racial stress and feel entitled to their advantage. Any challenge to their racial worldview is seen as a challenge to their identities as good, moral people, and they become defensive, angry, afraid, guilty, and often silent. These responses uphold the existing racial hierarchy because they restore racial comfort and repel any challenge to their worldview. This concept is what DiAngelo terms “white fragility.” It is a powerful means of control and protection of white people’s advantage.
This passage defines the book’s central topic: white fragility. White supremacy has given white people systemic advantages, but part of its power derives from the fact that it often goes unnamed and unchecked. Calling out white supremacy, by contrast, makes white people angry and uncomfortable—reactions that only deflect from the topic of white supremacy and thereby reinforces the racial status quo.
Themes
As a diversity trainer, DiAngelo is amazed at how many white people are angry and defensive over the assertion that they are connected to racism. These reactions are especially strange in places where there are few or no people of color in their workplace, or among people who have few relationships with people of color. DiAngelo observes the beliefs that prop up these responses: the idea that only bad people are racist, and that racism only involves intentional acts. But recognizing racism as a system can help white people receive feedback, learn, and grow. However, at the moment, white people often respond with anger and denial rather than gratitude about being informed about problematic behavior so that they can correct it.
This section hints at the book’s later discussion of the good/bad binary definition of racism. Because people believe that exhibiting racist behavior and being a good person are mutually exclusive, it is difficult to confront white people about their racist behavior because it challenges their self-image. As a result, they react with white fragility in order to defend their character, but this diverts the focus from remedying that racist behavior.
Themes
Race is a complicated social dilemma that influences every aspects of our lives: where we live, our schools, our friends and partners, our careers, how much money we will earn, and how healthy we will be. DiAngelo’s goal is not to provide the solution to racism or to prove it exists (she starts with that assumption). Instead, her goal is to explain white fragility, how it protects racial inequality, and how to counteract it.
Here, DiAngelo introduces the idea that the systems of racism and white supremacy greatly impact people’s lives, even today. These systems provide white Americans with great advantages, ranging from health to financial success. She also explicitly states her goal of demonstrating the problems with white people reacting with white fragility.
Themes
Get the entire White Fragility LitChart as a printable PDF.
