Letters from Yorkshire Summary & Analysis

Question about this poem?
Have a question about this poem?
Have a specific question about this poem?
Have a specific question about this poem?
Have a specific question about this poem?
A LitCharts expert can help.
A LitCharts expert can help.
A LitCharts expert can help.
A LitCharts expert can help.
A LitCharts expert can help.
Ask us
Ask us
Ask a question
Ask a question
Ask a question

The Full Text of “Letters from Yorkshire”

The Full Text of “Letters from Yorkshire”

  • “Letters from Yorkshire” Introduction

    • "Letters from Yorkshire" is a poem by the British poet Maura Dooley. In the poem, the speaker juxtaposes their modern lifestyle with the agrarian world of an acquaintance, with whom they exchange letters. These letters describe farming life and the natural world, which the speaker believes is "more real" than the speaker's own life of working indoors at a computer. Even as the poem highlights both the wonders and the harsh realities of working outdoors, it underlines the extent to which nature is missing from modern life, and how that void could create a feeling of unfulfillment.

  • “Letters from Yorkshire” Summary

    • In February, while planting potatoes in his garden, he saw the first lapwing birds return from their winter migration. He then went inside to write to me. His knuckles reddened in the warmth of the indoors, happy to be out of the cold.

      There's nothing romantic or extraordinary about his outdoor lifestyle. It just is what it is. You're outside in the cold, watching the seasons change, while I'm indoors typing articles at a computer screen. Is your life more real than mine because you're a farmer and spend more time in nature?

      You wouldn't say that's the case, especially while doing difficult winter chores like shoveling snow and breaking ice off of a water container. Still, you're the one who writes to me and tells me about this world that's so different from mine, and each of your letters brings a piece of that natural world to me. Even at night, while we're watching the same news in separate, far-away houses, our letters to each other help us to stay in touch across the cold distance that separates us.

  • “Letters from Yorkshire” Themes

    • Theme Agrarian vs. Modern Life

      Agrarian vs. Modern Life

      In Maura Dooley’s “Letters from Yorkshire,” the speaker envisions an acquaintance (a friend, relative, or lover) writing letters to the speaker after working outside in his garden. This acquaintance’s letters seem filled with the “air and light” of the natural world, causing the speaker to wonder if the letter writer’s experience is “more real” than the speaker’s own—which is spent indoors at a computer. This wondering on the speaker's part suggests a nagging anxiety about modern life—that is, that this life, closer to a computer screen than to nature, is emptier than that spent working outside with one’s hands. Yet despite highlighting nature’s importance, the poem also recognizes the degree to which a modern office worker might romanticize or misunderstand the reality of agrarian life.

      Throughout the poem, the speaker links the physical labor of their correspondent to a sensory experience of nature that is both meaningful and desirable. The poem opens with the speaker’s acquaintance “planting potatoes” while seeing the first “lapwings” (a kind of bird) return from migration. Even though it is “February” and likely uncomfortable outside, the speaker seems to think that these are pleasurable and worthwhile moments for the letter writer.

      The speaker then describes his knuckles “singing as they reddened in the warmth” of the indoors. While this sudden reddening would suggest how bitterly cold it must be outside, the speaker’s use of a pleasant, musical term gives manual labor a sense of beauty. It seems, then, that the speaker is envious of their acquaintance’s ability to go “out there, in the cold, seeing the seasons turning,” while the speaker sits at their computer “feeding words into a blank screen.” Rather than being able to “plant potatoes,” or give life back to the earth, the speaker interacts only with the virtual world of a computer. The feeling of being “cold” and the physical act of “planting potatoes” are tangible ways to relate to the natural world that the speaker cannot experience from her house.

      The speaker then wonders if their acquaintance’s life is “more real” because he is a farmer. With this question, the speaker makes explicit their doubt about how much life they are genuinely experiencing while sitting at their computer. The modern world, it seems, creates a barrier between people and the “real” world.

      The speaker knows, however, that their own perception of agrarian life is not the same as that of their correspondent. The speaker thinks that their acquaintance “wouldn’t” describe his agrarian lifestyle as “more real,” especially as he completes the unpleasant tasks of “breaking ice on a waterbutt” and “clearing a path through snow.” The speaker recognizes that their vision of outdoor labor is romanticized, and by acknowledging these multiple perceptions of agrarian life, the poem suggests that neither lifestyle (agrarian or modern) is “more real” than the other.

      Even so, to the speaker, the acquaintance’s letters contain “air” and “light,” and become metaphors for the kind of experiences the speaker cannot have. The speaker seems to crave the connection to nature offered by the letter writer, while also sensing that the letter-writer does not crave news of the speaker’s day-to-day in an office. The poem implies that a connection to nature is crucial to living a fulfilled life, and that this connection is something that modern life does not sufficiently provide.

      Where this theme appears in the poem:
      • Lines 1-3
      • Lines 4-13
    • Theme Communication and Connection

      Communication and Connection

      “Letters from Yorkshire” explores several kinds of communication: letter-writing, the “heartful of headlines” belonging to the speaker (implied to be a journalist, or some sort of writer), and the “nightly news.” Of these three forms of communication, the poem ascribes the most importance to letter-writing. Although the speaker can interact with the outside world via the news and her own articles, neither form of communication seems as meaningful to the speaker as do letters. This might be because, with a letter, the speaker receives a window into the life and world of another person whom the speaker can interact with individually. The poem thus subtly suggests that genuine connection requires a sense of intimacy and reciprocation.

      The poem’s opening lines make the intimate power of letter writing apparent. The poem begins with the speaker looking through the letter-writer’s eyes as he plants potatoes and watches “lapwings” return. The speaker also ascribes a musical quality to the act of letter writing. In the third line of the first stanza, the speaker perceives their acquaintance’s knuckles as “singing” as he begins crafting a letter indoors. This musical act seems more intimate and positive than the speaker’s later description of “feeding words onto a blank screen.” Unlike letter-writing, the poem suggests, writing articles isn’t a two-way form of communication; instead, it is a one-way stream of thoughts and information. As such, the blank screen cannot offer the same warm connection that a letter can.

      The poem ends with the lines “So that / at night, watching the same news in different houses, / our souls tap out messages across the icy miles.” Both the speaker and their correspondent may be engaged in the nightly news in separate houses, but their habit of letter writing gives them a warm, soul-level intimacy that transcends “icy miles.” In this closing image, letter writing is portrayed as a more powerful means of communication than nightly news. Even though current events are obviously important, the speaker seems much more interested in the news of their correspondent, which is that of agriculture and the natural world. Rather ironically, this intimate news seems to make the speaker feel more connected to the world than does any nightly broadcast about the state of that world, for the letters brings “air” and “light.” These two qualities ("air" and "light"—two things that every living being needs to survive) underline the vital necessity of one-on-one communication for the speaker.

      Where this theme appears in the poem:
      • Lines 2-4
      • Lines 7-8
      • Lines 11-15
  • Line-by-Line Explanation & Analysis of “Letters from Yorkshire”

    • Lines 1-4

      In February, digging ...
      ... in the warmth.

      The poem opens with an image of the speaker's penpal working in his garden. Even though the penpal is the one writing to the speaker about farm life, this scene is presented from the point of view of the speaker; this is how the speaker images the penpal spends his time. Right from the get go, then, the speaker's fascination with and romanticization of farm work starts to become clear.

      It is still wintertime ("February"), but when looking through the speaker's eyes, the outdoor work seems peaceful rather than cold or harsh. The penpal digs in his garden, "planting potatoes," and sees a kind of bird (called a "lapwing") return, perhaps from a long migration. The alliteration and consonance of these descriptions imbue them with a sense of musicality, elevating the penpal's humble labor. Note the hard /g/ sounds of "digging," the popping /p/ and /t/ of "planting potatoes." His knuckles, despite being subject to the cold air and soil, are "singing" as they "reddened in the warmth" of the indoors.

      On a literal level, this refers to the way that people's hands turn red when coming in from the cold, due to increased blood flow. "Singing" evokes the tingling warmth that accompanies this reddening. And by personifying the knuckles as "singing," the speaker also imbues this reddening with a subtle sense of beauty and joy. This seeming joy is likely due, in part, to the relief of being inside, out of the cold. The knuckles might also be "singing" in joyful anticipation to "write" about the natural world they just experienced. Either way, the speaker instills the entire scene with a sense of comforting, welcoming warmth, even though the farm work itself was cold and probably unpleasant to perform. At this early stage, the speaker seems to set up the natural world, and farm work, more specifically, as an enviable and important aspect of their penpal's life.

    • Lines 5-8

      It’s not romance, ...
      ... a blank screen.

    • Lines 9-11

      Is your life ...
      ... path through snow.

    • Lines 11-13

      Still, it’s you ...
      ... into an envelope.

    • Lines 13-15

      So that ...
      ... the icy miles.

  • “Letters from Yorkshire” Poetic Devices & Figurative Language

    • Apostrophe

      The poem uses contains apostrophe throughout as the speaker addresses a penpal who is not actually present. One of the most striking instances comes in line 9, when the speaker wonders if this penpal's life is "more real" because he digs and sows—that is, because he is a farmer and thus works with his hands in the natural world. Readers can tell from this question that the speaker is dissatisfied, to some extent, with their modern lifestyle because it does not allow them to be in nature on a more regular basis.

      The word "real" could also imply a lack of tangibility or physical interaction in the speaker's life. Based on their descriptions of their penpal's farming, the speaker seems interested in the tangible ways he interacts with the natural world. For example, the farmer digs in his garden, "planting potatoes," and he understands the pleasure of his hands reddening with warmth after being out in the cold. The speaker's main means of physical interaction, by contrast, is the simple act of typing words into a computer. The speaker likely believes their own life to be less "real" because they do not have as many different things to touch and feel, and cannot relate to the world in as physical a way. Instead, they are stuck in the virtual (perhaps the opposite of "physical") world of computer work.

      It's also worth thinking about how apostrophe functions given that this poem is in part about communication. The poem ultimately suggests that intimate, reciprocal communication (such as letter writing) is more meaningful than one-way, mass communication (such as news stories). Here, the speaker is asking a question to a figure who is not actually present, meaning the speaker's question is sent off into the world much like the speaker's "headlines" are fed "onto a blank screen." The poem's use of apostrophe, then, subtly bolsters the speaker's sense of isolation in the modern world.

      Where apostrophe appears in the poem:
      • Lines 6-7
      • Line 9
      • Lines 10-15
    • Assonance

    • Caesura

    • Consonance

    • Enjambment

    • Imagery

    • Personification

    • Metaphor

  • "Letters from Yorkshire" Vocabulary

    Select any word below to get its definition in the context of the poem. The words are listed in the order in which they appear in the poem.

    • Lapwings
    • Singing
    • Romance
    • Heartful of headlines
    • Sow
    • Waterbutt
    • (Location in poem: Line 2: “lapwings”)

      "Lapwings" are a kind of bird that appears in Britain (where the author of this poem, Maura Dooley, lives) and elsewhere across the globe.

  • Form, Meter, & Rhyme Scheme of “Letters from Yorkshire”

    • Form

      "Letters from Yorkshire" is broken into five, three-line stanzas. This form is steady throughout, creating a sense of measured pacing. At the same time, the frequent enjambment between stanzas suggests that the speaker isn't all that interested in making their thoughts adhere strictly to the poetic form in front of them. Altogether, the poem is both structured and free-flowing, declarative and contemplative.

      The stanzas seem to track the progression of the speaker's thoughts. In the first stanza, the speaker opens with peaceful descriptions of the natural world, seeming to envy their penpal's ability to spend time outdoors. In the next two stanzas, the speaker clarifies the difference between the penpal's life and their own, as well as wonders whether or not their life is less "real" because it involves being inside most of the time, away from nature. In the fourth stanza, the speaker acknowledges the reality that working outdoors may not be pleasant all the time, before returning, in the fifth stanza, to their affection for news of the natural world via "air and light" in an envelope.

    • Meter

      "Letters from Yorkshire" does not have a consistent, overarching meter. Instead, it is written in free verse. This adds to its natural, free-flowing and reflective tone. There are still some interesting metrical moments, however.

      For example, in the first line, the two activities mention follow the exact same pattern of stresses, adding a sense of rhythm to the line and emphasizing that these are both equally important parts of the farmer's routine:

      digging his garden
      planting potatoes

      As is also clear from this example, the poem makes frequent use of caesura to add a sense of deliberate rhythm and pacing to its lines in the absence of a strict meter. For instance, notice how the opening line, "In February, digging his garden, planting potatoes," pauses at a regular interval to give equal weight to each part of the penpal's outdoor life. This same rhythm is echoed in line 6, which reads: "You out there, in the cold, seeing the seasons / turning ..." All of these caesuras appear within descriptions of the penpal's farm life. The sonic effect of a caesura is to slow down the reading experience of a set of words or lines, and perhaps the slowing of descriptions of the penpal's life reflects the slower pace of an outdoor, computer-free world.

    • Rhyme Scheme

      "Letters from Yorkshire" does not have a consistent, overarching rhyme scheme. Instead, it is told in natural, free-flowing prose that reflects the speaker's contemplative tone. That said, it does make use of assonance to string similar vowel sounds together throughout the poem and add a sense of musicality. Take, for example, the long /ee/ sounds in "seeing the seasons."

      There are also some subtle moments of internal rhyme, most apparent in lines 9-11:

      ... because you dig and sow?

      You wouldn’t say so, breaking ice on a waterbutt,
      clearing a path through snow.

      Interestingly, this is a description of the farmer's likely objections to the speaker's characterization of farm life. Here, the poem lays out the more difficult aspects of the penpal's work, yet it's also one of the only moments in the poem with any rhyme. Perhaps the speaker is attempting to add some sonic beauty even to these objections. Or perhaps the repeated /o/ sound here is meant to feel forced or rehashed, like this is some argument the speaker has heard many times before from the farmer.

  • “Letters from Yorkshire” Speaker

    • The speaker of this poem is the recipient of the so-called "Letters from Yorkshire," which originate from a penpal who primarily works outdoors. From the poem, readers know that the speaker feeds "words onto a blank screen," and spends most of their day sitting at the computer. This suggests that the speaker is probably a journalist or works in news in some way. It's also clear that the speaker feels somewhat isolated and disconnected from the natural world.

      The driving force behind this poem, arguably, is the question that appears in line 9: "Is your life more real because you dig and sow?" The speaker doubts that their life could be "more real" than one that involves the natural world, and feels compelled to express a great appreciation and longing for that world throughout the poem. By the poem's end, even after the speaker acknowledges that working outdoors comes with its own set of challenges, they deem the natural world as ultimately fulfilling. Each letter they receive from their penpal is full of "air and light," a suggestion that even basic news of the outdoors is enough to sustain their life.

  • “Letters from Yorkshire” Setting

    • The poem contains several different physical spaces. Most prominently, it consists of "that other world," which is the world of the outdoors that is the object of the speaker's fascination. The speaker's penpal is seen "digging his garden, planting potatoes," while "the first lapwings return." The poem also mentions the speaker's indoor world, which involves sitting at a computer, "feeding words into a blank screen." In the final lines, both the speaker and their penpal watch "the same news in different houses," and continue to "tap out messages" to each other via letter. In other words, they're both home watching TV and writing to each other. Ultimately, the way "Letters from Yorkshire" navigates between indoor and outdoor spaces allows it to maintain a realistic perception of both while highlighting how important nature can seem to someone living constantly in front of their computer.

  • Literary and Historical Context of “Letters from Yorkshire”

    • Literary Context

      Dooley's poem might best be thought of as falling into the current tradition of ecopoetry. Rather than simply denoting poems about nature, ecopoetry describes writing that relates to the natural world in a deeper, more meaningful way. Often, ecopoems will direct readers' attention to endangered or unprotected parts of the planet, or perhaps use nature as a vehicle for communicating a particular emotion, such as love or loss. Other ecopoems focus on the way nature interacts with the modern, technology-driven world, and it is this area that Maura Dooley's "Letters from Yorkshire" most easily fits in. After all, the poem is about someone who finds the natural world so fulfilling in comparison to their modern lifestyle that even their penpal's epistolary descriptions of it seem full of "air and light."

      Other poets that have contributed to ecopoetry include Mary Oliver, Gary Snyder, Forrest Gander, and perhaps most famously, W.S. Merwin. Interestingly, Merwin is famous for not using punctuation in his poetry, a formal decision that could suggest a willingness to let his natural imagery flow unrestricted from the regulations of grammar, allowing the reader to focus more on the images themselves.

      Historical Context

      This poem was published in the year 2000. Computers and the internet had both been around for quite a while at the time of the poem's composition, and were becoming more and more a part of regular people's everyday lives. People could communicate via email, get the news online, and talk to strangers in chatrooms. On the one hand, then, technology seemed to be having a positive affect on people's lives by increasing productivity and allowing people to stay in touch like never before.

      At the same time, people worried about over-reliance on computers. Technological innovations led to increasingly sedentary lifestyles devoid of any significant interaction with the natural world (especially when compared to the time before electricity itself existed). Notably, the characters in the poem—or, at least, the penpal—use real paper and envelopes to communicate, suggesting a hesitancy to fully engage with the digital world.

  • More “Letters from Yorkshire” Resources

    • External Resources

      • Yorkshire Farms Photograph — This photo shows the kind of rural lifestyle made possible in Yorkshire, England, that the speaker of Dooley's poem envies. The accompanying photo gallery shows other photos from similar regions in England and the United Kingdom.

      • Maura Dooley's Life Story — The British Council's website offers biographical information about Dooley and her poetry. 

      • Dooley's Favorite Poets — A transcription of a short interview with Dooley from the Forward Arts Foundation, in which she discusses how she became interested in poetry as well as the other poets she most admires. 

      • Maura Dooley Out Loud — A YouTube video showing Maura Dooley reading her poetry in England in 2007.