The Full Text of “Hotel Room, 12th Floor”
The Full Text of “Hotel Room, 12th Floor”
-
“Hotel Room, 12th Floor” Introduction
-
"Hotel Room, 12th Floor" is a free verse poem written by the Scottish poet Norman MacCaig, first published in MacCaig's 1968 collection Rings on a Tree. The poem, which was was inspired by one of several trips MacCaig made to the United States in the mid-1960s, describes a visitor's impressions of New York City from the vantage point of their high-up hotel room. The speaker is unimpressed by the city's massive skyscrapers and compares New York after dark, when the sounds of sirens and violence fill the streets, to the old American frontier. The poem suggests that civilized society is something of an illusion and that the violent side of human nature is inseparable from human progress.
-
-
“Hotel Room, 12th Floor” Summary
-
Looking out the window of a hotel room in New York City one morning, the speaker sees a helicopter, which resembles some kind of broken bug, flying close to the Empire State Building, which looks to the speaker like an enormous version of a drill you'd find in a dentist office. The helicopter lands on top of the tall PanAmerican Airlines building. Night arrives like a traveler from some distant land, and the speaker imagines the lights from all the rows and rows of building windows as a kind of gunfire, shooting out at the wild, barbarous darkness.
This light is not enough to defeat the darkness, however, and as the speaker lies down in their hotel bed with a radio and TV on either side, they can hear wild yelps and cries rising up from the narrow streets far below. These sparkling streets are like canyons in the earth. The speaker can hear the sirens of police cars and ambulances as they rush to help injured people, as well as the sounds of rough arguments in apartments. The speaker envisions the sidewalks being covered in blood.
Wild, uncivilized territory is never some faraway place, the speaker says, and no fences human beings build can stop the barbarous darkness from getting in.
-
-
“Hotel Room, 12th Floor” Themes
-
Civilization and the Darkness of Human Nature
Norman MacCaig’s “Hotel Room, 12th floor” suggests that no amount of human progress can defeat the essential darkness of human nature. The speaker, a visitor to the U.S. staying at a hotel in New York, finds the city’s massive skyscrapers ugly and unnerving and compares the city after dark to the "Wild West"—the historic American frontier that white settlers once sought to tame. As night falls and the sounds of sirens and screams rise from the streets far below, the poem suggests that humanity’s violent instincts still lurk beneath the wonder and ingenuity of even the most modern societies.
Despite being in one of the world's most advanced cities, the speaker seems unimpressed by the surrounding feats of technology. The speaker calls a passing helicopter a “damaged insect” and deems the Empire State Building, the tallest free-standing building in the world at the time, a “giant dentist's drill.” These images convey the speaker's sense of unease and discomfort, and they also suggest that there's something broken and frightening about the modern world.
When night then falls, the speaker describes a kind of battle between "midnight" and “the million lit windows” of the city’s buildings, whose lights are like pops of gunfire ineffectually trying to pierce the darkness. People cling to markers of technological progress, the speaker implies here, in order to feel like they’re living in a civilized world, but none of this technology can actually “keep the midnight” (or wildness of human nature) “out.”
Things get worse after night fully envelops the city and sounds of violence and terror fill the streets below. As the speaker sits in their hotel room between a radio and television set, these modern comforts (which were relatively new at the time the poem was written) aren't enough to drown out the sounds of “police cars and ambulances racing” toward scenes of "broken bones" and "harsh screaming."
The speaker concludes by comparing modern-day New York to the historic “Wild West,” suggesting that modern society is nothing more than a thin veil draped over humanity’s violent instincts. The speaker's description of the city’s narrow streets as “glittering canyons and gulches” evokes the landscape of the western U.S., once considered a dangerous new frontier by white settlers. The “warwhoops continually ululating” between the city's massive buildings are meant to evoke the stereotypical sounds made by the American Indians those settlers clashed with.
On one level, this comparison of New York to the Wild West reminds readers that the modern world was built by force and subjugation: these settlers believed it their duty to tame the western wilderness and “civilize” its indigenous peoples (very often via outright violence). At the same time, the poem is saying that this wild, brutal world never disappeared. The “frontier is never somewhere else,” the speaker concludes, meaning that the potential for chaos and violence is always present in human beings—no matter how many fancy skyscrapers they build.
Where this theme appears in the poem:- Lines 1-21
-
-
Line-by-Line Explanation & Analysis of “Hotel Room, 12th Floor”
-
Line 1
This morning I watched from here
The first line of "Hotel Room, 12th Floor" plays off the poem's title: based on that title, readers can assume that "here" refers to the speaker's room on the 12th floor of a hotel building. At the time this poem was written, this would be one of the higher floors—and, as such, likely one of the more expensive ones.
The fact that the speaker is staying in a hotel also implies that this person is a visitor—that they've come from somewhere else to "here." This positions the speaker as an outsider looking in on another culture or place.
The speaker also specifies the poem starts at a certain time of day: "this morning." It's important to note that "this morning" refers to the past tense (along with the past-tense verb "watched"), which means the speaker is looking back on something that happened. The poem thus begins with a reflection; the speaker has had time to consider what they've seen and perhaps has a bit of insight to share.
Finally, the word "watched" is an interesting word choice because "to watch" something is typically considered a passive act. This suggests the speaker did not feel directly involved in what was happening outside their window. They possibly felt more like an onlooker, which emphasizes their position as a visitor or outsider.
-
Lines 2-5
a helicopter skirting ...
... the PanAm skyscraper. -
Lines 6-7
But now midnight ...
... from foreign places. -
Lines 7-9
Its uncivilised darkness ...
... ups and acrosses -
Lines 10-14
But midnight is ...
... canyons and gulches— -
Lines 15-18
police cars and ...
... glazed on sidewalks. -
Lines 19-21
The frontier is ...
... the midnight out.
-
-
“Hotel Room, 12th Floor” Symbols
-
Darkness and Light
Light in the poem symbolizes order, progress, and civilization itself. Darkness, meanwhile, symbolizes chaos, disorder, terror, and so forth—all the things that aren't supposed to exist in a "civilized" society.
The poem begins in the"morning," when the speaker can see the city's skyscrapers clearly. A helicopter buzzes around as well. These daytime images of technological achievement reflect how supposedly advanced the city is, marking it out as a center of civilization and progress.
Yet things take a turn when "midnight" swoops across the city, bringing with it "uncivilised darkness." The speaker describes the electric lights from "a million lit windows" of the city's buildings shooting out at the night as though it were a physical enemy. This battle between light and darkness represents a battle between order and chaos, progress and destruction.
Yet even a million lights aren't enough to brighten up the darkness of "midnight," the speaker says—implying that no amount of human technological prowess can defeat the inherent darkness of human nature. Instead, night covers the city and the world becomes increasingly chaotic and violent, ultimately reminding the speaker of the days of the wild, lawless American frontier.
Where this symbol appears in the poem:- Lines 6-9: “But now midnight has come in / from foreign places. Its uncivilised darkness / is shot at by a million lit windows, all / ups and acrosses”
- Lines 10-11: “But midnight is not / so easily defeated.”
- Lines 15-18: “police cars and ambulances racing / to the broken bones, the harsh screaming / from coldwater flats, the blood / glazed on sidewalks.”
- Lines 20-21: “And no stockades / can keep the midnight out.”
-
-
“Hotel Room, 12th Floor” Poetic Devices & Figurative Language
-
Simile
The speaker uses a simile in line 2 when comparing a helicopter flying around the Empire State building to a "damaged insect."
One might think that a helicopter buzzing around a huge skyscraper would be an impressive sight and a sign of just how advanced human technology has become. Yet the image of an injured insect flying around in distress certainly isn't a pleasant one. People also often consider insects pesky or annoying. This simile thus suggests that the scene looks off to the speaker—that there's something broken or wrong here. This technologically advanced, highly "civilized" setting isn't impressive to the speaker but rather unsettling and strange.
The fact that the speaker compares a machine to a bug might also suggest something about the relationship between huamnity and nature. That is, the simile here might subtly suggest that human technology is something of a perversion of nature or an affront to the natural world.
Where simile appears in the poem:- Lines 2-3: “a helicopter skirting like a damaged insect / the Empire State Building”
-
Metaphor
-
Extended Metaphor
-
Enjambment
-
Personification
-
Synecdoche
-
Consonance
-
Alliteration
-
-
"Hotel Room, 12th Floor" Vocabulary
Select any word below to get its definition in the context of the poem. The words are listed in the order in which they appear in the poem.
- The Empire State Building
- PanAm
- Uncivilised
- Ululating
- Gulches
- Frontier
- Stockades
-
(Location in poem: Lines 2-3: “a helicopter skirting like a damaged insect / the Empire State Building”)
New York City's famous Empire State Building was constructed in 1931 and remained the world's tallest building until 1970.
-
Form, Meter, & Rhyme Scheme of “Hotel Room, 12th Floor”
-
Form
"Hotel Room, 12th floor" is a free verse poem that doesn't follow any traditional form. It consists of 21 lies broken into three stanzas. The first and second of these each have nine lines, while the third has just three.
The short third stanza clearly stands apart from the first two and acts as a kind of commentary on everything that's happened so far in the poem. While those longer stanzas describe what happens in the city as day transitions to the darkness of night, the final stanza makes a broad philosophical statement about the darkness of human nature.
-
Meter
"Hotel Room, 12th Floor" is written in free verse, which means that there's no regular meter here. This is common for contemporary poetry and lends the poem a conversational tone. Readers get the sense that they're hearing the speaker's intimate thoughts and observations as they happen.
-
Rhyme Scheme
As a free verse poem, "Hotel Room, 12th Floor" doesn't follow a regular rhyme scheme. Instead, it feels unpredictable and uncontained. A steady pattern of rhyme might feel too rigid and controlled for a poem about chaos and darkness overtaking civilization.
-
-
“Hotel Room, 12th Floor” Speaker
-
Norman MacCaig's trips to the U.S. may have influenced the poem, but there's no reason readers have to take this poem's speaker as being the poet himself. All readers know is that the speaker is someone visiting New York City.
The fact that the speaker is staying in a hotel implies that this person isn't actually from New York. As such, the speaker has an outsider's perspective on the city and its famous buildings. Instead of being impressed, however, the speaker seems disturbed and even repulsed. They describe the Empire State Building as a giant "dentist's drill," for example, and think a buzzing helicopter looks likes "a damaged insect."
It's also fair to assume that the speaker is either middle or upper class. A 12th-floor hotel room implies that they're staying in a high-rise building (at least, what would have been a high-rise in the 1960s, when the poem was written). They're thus far above the "coldwater flats" below, which are apartments that lack hot running water and are typically occupied by people of a lower socioeconomic status. The speaker seems acutely aware (and disapproving) of the distance between these worlds.
-
-
“Hotel Room, 12th Floor” Setting
-
"Hotel Room, 12th Floor," is set in, well, a hotel room on the 12th floor of a building! The mention of the Empire State Building and PanAm skyscraper reveals that this hotel is located in New York City. (The mention of the PanAmerican skyscraper also dates the poem to the mid-20th century, given that PanAmerican Airlines no longer exists.)
The setting plays an important role in the poem for several reasons:
- For one thing, this setting establishes that the speaker is a visitor to New York and thus has an outsider's perspective on the city.
- The fact that the speaker's hotel room is on the 12th floor also places the speaker far above the violence and terror that take place below when night falls. In this way, the poem suggests that a sharp divide exists in this city: between the upper-class world of upper-level hotel rooms and skyscrapers and the lower-class world of "coldwater flats" and sidewalks "glazed" with blood.
- Finally, the fact that this is specifically New York City situates the poem in a cultural, technological, and economic hub of modern life. The city's skyline, filled with enormously tall buildings, is famous worldwide. the Empire State Building was in fact the tallest free-standing building in the world when this poem was written.
Setting the poem in New York City is vital to the poem's point. Even here, in one of the most supposedly civilized and advanced cities in the world, the darkness of human nature exists right alongside human progress.
-
-
Literary and Historical Context of “Hotel Room, 12th Floor”
-
Literary Context
The Scottish poet Norman MacCaig published "Hotel Room, 12th Floor" in his 1968 collection Rings on a Tree. MacCaig had visited New York City a few times in the mid-'60s, and these trips undoubtedly inspired the perspective of this poem.
MacCaig was a popular writer in his lifetime, known for his often humorous poems written in clear, simple language. This poem's introspective free verse style was pretty common by the mid-1960s, a time when many writers had turned away from strict meters and rhyme schemes in favor of looser, more stream-of-consciousness styles. MacCaig's poetry, like that of many authors in the mid-to-late 20th century, might also fall under the category of post-modernism, a movement that often challenged the nature of power and language in society.
MacCaig was hardly the first poet to bristle at humanity's technological progress. Centuries before this poem was written, for example, the Romantic poets railed against the urbanization of society following the Industrial Revolution (see: "London, 1802"). And in the wake of World War I, a war whose technology caused death and destruction on an unprecedented scale, modernist poets like T.S. Eliot grew deeply disillusioned with humanity itself (see: "The Waste Land").
Historical Context
The 1960s were a time of intense technological optimism. New York City, where this poem is set, was considered one of the most advanced cities in the world and a pillar of modern civilization. The Empire State Building was the tallest free-standing building on Earth at the time and a testament to humanity's technological prowess. Pan American World Airlines, the namesake of the "PanAm skyscraper" that the speaker mentions in line 5, was a major international airline. This was also the era of the "Space Race"—the decades-long battle between the U.S. and the Soviet Union to create better aerospace capabilities.
However, massive social and political upheaval was taking place right alongside all this technological advancement. This was the era of the civil rights movement and the Vietnam War, for example, and a time when millions questioned and openly protested established social structures and hierarchies.
MacCaig's poem also alludes to the U.S.'s violent and racist history of westward expansion. From the 17th to the 19th centuries, white pioneers sought to head further west and tame the American frontier. This push resulted in frequent conflicts with the native peoples already living in this region. The U.S. government also attempted to "civilize" American Indians through policies of forced assimilation into white society and authorized their direct removal from their ancestral lands. In the end, white westward expansion caused the utter devastation of indigenous peoples and their ways of life.
-
-
More “Hotel Room, 12th Floor” Resources
-
External Resources
-
"The Enduring Appeal of Norman MacCaig" — Read an article about Norman MacCaig's poetic legacy.
-
"When Native Americans Were Slaughtered in the Name of 'Civilization'" — An article from History.com about clashes between white settlers and native peoples on the American frontier.
-
The American Frontier — Learn more about the history of westward expansionism in the U.S.
-
The Empire State Building — Check out the official website of the famous New York City landmark.
-
Norman MacCaig's Life and Work — Learn more about Norman MacCaig via the Scottish Poetry Library.
-
-
