The Full Text of “The Convergence of the Twain”
(Lines on the loss of the "Titanic")
I
1 In a solitude of the sea
2 Deep from human vanity,
3And the Pride of Life that planned her, stilly couches she.
II
4 Steel chambers, late the pyres
5 Of her salamandrine fires,
6Cold currents thrid, and turn to rhythmic tidal lyres.
III
7 Over the mirrors meant
8 To glass the opulent
9The sea-worm crawls — grotesque, slimed, dumb, indifferent.
IV
10 Jewels in joy designed
11 To ravish the sensuous mind
12Lie lightless, all their sparkles bleared and black and blind.
V
13 Dim moon-eyed fishes near
14 Gaze at the gilded gear
15And query: "What does this vaingloriousness down here?" ...
VI
16 Well: while was fashioning
17 This creature of cleaving wing,
18The Immanent Will that stirs and urges everything
VII
19 Prepared a sinister mate
20 For her — so gaily great —
21A Shape of Ice, for the time far and dissociate.
VIII
22 And as the smart ship grew
23 In stature, grace, and hue,
24In shadowy silent distance grew the Iceberg too.
IX
25 Alien they seemed to be;
26 No mortal eye could see
27The intimate welding of their later history,
X
28 Or sign that they were bent
29 By paths coincident
30On being anon twin halves of one august event,
XI
31 Till the Spinner of the Years
32 Said "Now!" And each one hears,
33And consummation comes, and jars two hemispheres.
The Full Text of “The Convergence of the Twain”
(Lines on the loss of the "Titanic")
I
1 In a solitude of the sea
2 Deep from human vanity,
3And the Pride of Life that planned her, stilly couches she.
II
4 Steel chambers, late the pyres
5 Of her salamandrine fires,
6Cold currents thrid, and turn to rhythmic tidal lyres.
III
7 Over the mirrors meant
8 To glass the opulent
9The sea-worm crawls — grotesque, slimed, dumb, indifferent.
IV
10 Jewels in joy designed
11 To ravish the sensuous mind
12Lie lightless, all their sparkles bleared and black and blind.
V
13 Dim moon-eyed fishes near
14 Gaze at the gilded gear
15And query: "What does this vaingloriousness down here?" ...
VI
16 Well: while was fashioning
17 This creature of cleaving wing,
18The Immanent Will that stirs and urges everything
VII
19 Prepared a sinister mate
20 For her — so gaily great —
21A Shape of Ice, for the time far and dissociate.
VIII
22 And as the smart ship grew
23 In stature, grace, and hue,
24In shadowy silent distance grew the Iceberg too.
IX
25 Alien they seemed to be;
26 No mortal eye could see
27The intimate welding of their later history,
X
28 Or sign that they were bent
29 By paths coincident
30On being anon twin halves of one august event,
XI
31 Till the Spinner of the Years
32 Said "Now!" And each one hears,
33And consummation comes, and jars two hemispheres.
-
“The Convergence of the Twain” Introduction
-
"The Convergence of the Twain," subtitled, "Lines on the loss of the Titanic," was written by English poet Thomas Hardy for the Titanic Disaster Fund. The Titanic, a luxurious ship believed to be unsinkable, infamously collided with an iceberg and sank on April 15, 1912, killing over 1,500 people. Hardy's poem is a chilling meditation on human vanity and powerlessness before the indifferent, destructive powers of nature.
-
-
“The Convergence of the Twain” Summary
-
The speaker begins by imagining where the Titanic is now. Isolated deep beneath the ocean, far away from the rich, self-indulgent passengers who sailed on her and the ambitious, overconfident engineers who built her, the ship now lies motionless.
Through the steel-plated boiler rooms, where the fires once burned that powered the ship, chilly currents of water now flow, almost turning the wreck into an instrument that is "played" by the moving water.
In the wreck are mirrors where glamorous, wealthy passengers were meant to see their reflections. Now, however, disgusting, slimy sea-worms crawl silently over those mirrors, completely undisturbed by the wreckage and the carnage.
Also in the wreck lie jewels that once belonged to passengers or decorated the ship. These jewels were meant to delight wealthy people who concerned themselves primarily with luxurious material goods. Now, they reflect no light, and instead lie colorless, without any sparkle, beneath the dark ocean.
Nearby, drab fish with dull eyes look at the wreck and the fine materials that once covered its exterior surfaces, as if they are asking themselves, "What is this self-indulgent luxury doing down at the bottom of the ocean?"
The answer is that, while people were building a ship that was meant to effortlessly pierce the sea's waves as it sailed, something else was also taking action: a supernatural power, like God or Fate, that sets in motion and directs everything that happens.
This supernatural power began creating an object that would match the ship in size and grandeur: an enormous iceberg. These two closely matched objects would meet at a time far in the future, when no one expected them to meet.
As the builders were making their impressive ship greater in size, capability, and beauty, the iceberg, also, far away, was growing silently larger.
The ship and the iceberg would have seemed completely unrelated to anyone watching; no human observer could have anticipated how their futures would ultimately come to be closely intertwined.
Likewise, no human observer could find any clue that the paths of the iceberg and the path of the ship would ultimately cross, making them two equal participants in a single awe-inspiring occurrence.
People only realized what would happen when the supernatural power, who determines how long each human life will last, decreed that the ship and the iceberg would meet at this moment. Both the ship and the iceberg obeyed the decree, coming together in a collision that was both the inevitable outcome of the earlier chain of events and the most fitting and perfect conclusion to the ship's career. The collision physically shook the ship and the iceberg, the two halves that made up the whole event, and emotionally shook the two halves of the planet, shocking the entire world.
-
-
“The Convergence of the Twain” Themes
-
Human Hubris vs. Nature's Power
The poem is about the Titanic, the enormous ship that infamously sunk after smashing into an iceberg in 1912. The speaker contrasts the human-made majesty of the ship with the alternatively “indifferent” and destructive natural environment that now surrounds it beneath the sea. The ship was supposed to represent human beings' ingenuity and ability to master the natural world. Now, however, the poem argues that the wreck has come to represent the opposite: it is a testament to the fragility of human creation in the face of nature’s might, and a reminder of the perils of hubris.
According to the speaker, the ship was created by “the Pride of Life” and “human vanity.” The ship was originally intended to represent human achievement and the pride such achievement inspires. For example, the ship was formerly powered by “salamandrine fires.” Salamanders, which can live unharmed in fire according to legend, represent a triumph over the elements. The Titanic, similarly, was meant to triumph over the element of water by being unsinkable.
Such achievements also represented human vanity, the poem implies, as many elements of the ship revealed an obsession with opulence, riches, and appearances. The speaker takes care to mention the “mirrors” and “jewels” that beautified the ship and made it “gaily great.” The ship wasn’t just a marvel of engineering, then; it was also the height of luxury. The ship’s accommodations were designed for rich, “opulent” passengers whose “sensuous mind[s]” were consumed, or “ravish[ed],” by extravagant, expensive material goods, and whose vanity was pleased by being “glass[ed]” (in other words, by seeing their own beautiful appearances reflected back to them).
And yet, all this technology and wealth ultimately proved helpless in the face of nature’s might—a fact the poem makes clear by juxtaposing the intentions of the human shipbuilders with the current state of the ship at the bottom of the sea. The ship is now “Deep” in the ocean, far from “the Pride of Life that planned her.” It was never part of the shipbuilders’ plan that the ship should be found “[i]n a solitude of the sea.” But, of course, the sea overcame their plan.
Similarly, the ship’s “[s]teel chambers” were built to hold fire, but now they hold only “[c]old currents.” The jewels were meant to dazzle the ship’s wealthy, glamorous passengers with their “sparkles,” as the mirrors were “meant” to reflect the passengers’ beautiful appearances. Now, though, the jewels are “lightless” and the mirrors reflect “grotesque” sea-worms.
Nature is portrayed not only as powerful but also as "indifferent" toward the life it destroys. The sea-worms that crawl over the wreckage are totally unaffected by the destruction and loss of life that surround them. The sea even destroys any semblance of honor for all those who died in the wreck. The word “pyre” traditionally refers to a fire built to burn a dead body as a funereal rite. The sea has extinguished the “pyres” and replaced them with “rhythmic tidal lyres.” This image suggests that the sea is so unconcerned with human death that it plays music in the wreck.
Finally, the fish that swim through the shipwreck are baffled rather than mournful, asking, “What does this vaingloriousness down here?” Their reaction reinforces the reader’s sense that nature is utterly unmoved by human loss—something that, the poem argues, is perhaps an inevitable outcome of excessive vanity and pride.
- See where this theme is active in the poem.
-
Fate and Human Powerlessness
The world described in the poem is a fearful one. First, it is both predestined and unpredictable: certain events are destined to occur, but humans cannot anticipate them or guard against them. Second, the poem implies that destiny is controlled by a power that does not care about human suffering.
This power, which, according to the speaker, planned the collision of the Titanic and the iceberg, is unconcerned with the death it causes. In fact, it seems to find the wreck a pleasing spectacle. In describing a power that finds such pleasure in destruction and is indifferent to suffering, the poem is designed not to comfort readers after loss but to warn them of their own insignificance and powerlessness—in the face of God, fate, or perhaps death itself.
The poem argues that it was predestined, or planned, that the ship and the iceberg collide. The world is controlled by “The Immanent Will that stirs and urges everything.” Basically, the speaker thinks that some supernatural power influences all events. Again, this power might be God, fate, nature, or something less specific. In any case, the poem implies that people do not control their destinies.
This power “prepared” the iceberg as a “sinister mate” for the Titanic. As mates are meant to go together, this implies that the ship and the iceberg were meant to meet. Thanks to this power, the ship and the iceberg were on “paths coincident.” If two objects are on paths that coincide, or cross, the two objects cannot help meeting. Likewise, the ship and the iceberg could not help colliding—it was their destiny.
The poem also suggests that this convergence, though predestined, could not be predicted or prepared for by human beings. The ship and the iceberg seemed to human observers to be “[a]lien,” or unconnected. “No mortal eye could see” that, according to a supernatural plan, they would ultimately collide. And since they could not predict the wreck, people could not prepare to save themselves from it. If the world is shaped in this way by a powerful, unpredictable fate, then the poem suggests that human beings are ultimately powerless to control events or predict their lives.
What makes this world even more fearful is that the supernatural power regards the collision, not as a tragedy, but almost as beautiful. By emphasizing this power’s pleasure in the wreck, the poem offers no comfort to readers and instead warns them of their vulnerability. The collision is described as “august.” The term “august’ conveys something grand and magnificent that inspires admiration. The power seems to have found this “august event” impressive and enjoyable to watch.
The ship and the iceberg, meanwhile, are described as “twin halves” and “two hemispheres,” as though they are two pieces that only make one perfect whole when they come together. The collision is also described as “consummation.” Consummation can refer to an inevitable outcome. Perhaps the poem is saying, then, that if people cannot abandon their pride and vanity, then their overambitious ventures will always end in destruction. And no matter how hard human beings try to conquer nature, they will never be able to escape death itself.
Consummation can also refer to a fitting or perfect outcome, or to the accomplishment of an intended goal. The word thus suggests that the “Spinner of the Years”—another name for a supernatural power controlling human lives—meant for this collision to happen because it seemed a perfect ending, something fitting and beautiful. In suggesting that the world is controlled by an unstoppable, unsympathetic power, the poem serves as a stark reminder of how vulnerable human beings are—perhaps most of all when they pridefully overestimate their own power and importance in the grand scheme of things.
- See where this theme is active in the poem.
-
-
Line-by-Line Explanation & Analysis of “The Convergence of the Twain”
-
Lines 1-3
In a solitude of the sea
Deep from human vanity,
And the Pride of Life that planned her, stilly couches she.The speaker begins with a vivid image of the lonely depths of the ocean, with nothing in sight but dark water. But then, in the last three words of the stanza, the speaker suddenly adds, "stilly couches she." ("She" refers to a ship.) It is as if a shipwreck had suddenly loomed up out of the empty darkness. Because the speaker delays introducing the ship, there is an element of surprise in the image (just as there was a great deal of surprise when the ship sank!).
This ship, of course, is the Titanic: the famous ocean liner that stunned the world when it sank on April 15, 1912. The poem was written just a month after the Titanic sank, and Thomas Hardy would have expected his audience to know that the Titanic was the largest and most luxurious ship in operation at the time—and that its makers had designed it to be "unsinkable."
Yet the poem signals immediately that, although it is about "the loss of the 'Titanic,'" it is not simply going to mourn the victims or celebrate the passengers' bravery in their final hour. It will examine the reasons why the Titanic sank and critique the motivations behind its construction.
To that end, the speaker does not refer to the individual engineers or laborers who built the ship. Instead, the speaker says that it was "human vanity" and "the Pride of Life" that "planned" the ship. The speaker suggests that people built the ship out of pride in their own abilities, especially their ability to conquer nature by creating a ship that the ocean couldn't sink. The ship's grand scale pleased the vanity of the builders, while its extravagant luxury appealed to the vanity of the wealthy passengers.
Now, however, the ship has become a symbol of pride and vanity gone too far. It was never "planned" that the ship sink "[d]eep" into the sea, and the poem implies that it was an act of hubris for human beings to think they could conquer the natural world. The poem is thus a critique of such pride and vanity.
The speaker strengthens this critique, and reminds the reader of how widespread these traits are, by using biblical allusions. The word "vanity" would summon to many readers' minds the Book of Ecclesiastes, with its famous line, "Vanity of vanities; all is vanity." The full verse reads, "Vanity of vanities, saith the Preacher, vanity of vanities; all is vanity. What profit hath a man of all his labour which he taketh under the sun?" (Eccl 1:2-3).
This verse insists that all things are, in one sense, useless or profitless. In particular, labor (like the labor of shipbuilding) does not profit humans they way they hope it will do. With the word "vanity," the speaker thus suggests that the Titanic does not represent the bad judgment of a few 20th-century individuals, but rather a universal human failing.
The phrase "Pride of Life" is a biblical allusion as well. It comes from 1 John 2:16: "For all that is in the world, the lust of the flesh, and the lust of the eyes, and the pride of life, is not of the Father, but is of the world." In this context, the "pride of life" refers to a proud, arrogant assumption of greatness, and the desire that others admire and applaud one's greatness.
Biblical commentators have connected this trio of failings to the three reasons why the forbidden apple appealed to Eve in the Book of Genesis: "the woman saw that the tree was good for food, and that it was pleasant to the eyes, and a tree to be desired to make one wise" (Gen 3:6). It was "pride of life" that made Eve desire to be as wise as God Himself, and this was partly responsible for the Fall of humankind into sin.
In connecting the Titanic's sinking to humanity's original fall, the speaker makes the ship a stunning symbol of human failing itself and reminds the reader that humans still destroy themselves through pride.
-
Lines 4-6
Steel chambers, late the pyres
Of her salamandrine fires,
Cold currents thrid, and turn to rhythmic tidal lyres. -
Lines 7-9
Over the mirrors meant
To glass the opulent
The sea-worm crawls — grotesque, slimed, dumb, indifferent. -
Lines 10-12
Jewels in joy designed
To ravish the sensuous mind
Lie lightless, all their sparkles bleared and black and blind. -
Lines 13-15
Dim moon-eyed fishes near
Gaze at the gilded gear
And query: "What does this vaingloriousness down here?" ... -
Lines 16-18
Well: while was fashioning
This creature of cleaving wing,
The Immanent Will that stirs and urges everything -
Lines 19-21
Prepared a sinister mate
For her — so gaily great —
A Shape of Ice, for the time far and dissociate. -
Lines 22-24
And as the smart ship grew
In stature, grace, and hue,
In shadowy silent distance grew the Iceberg too. -
Lines 25-27
Alien they seemed to be;
No mortal eye could see
The intimate welding of their later history, -
Lines 28-30
Or sign that they were bent
By paths coincident
On being anon twin halves of one august event, -
Lines 31-32
Till the Spinner of the Years
Said "Now!" -
Lines 32-33
And each one hears,
And consummation comes, and jars two hemispheres.
-
-
“The Convergence of the Twain” Symbols
-
The Titanic
The main symbol in the poem is the Titanic itself. Especially in the first half of the poem, the wreck of the once glorious ship represents human vanity, pride, and hubris, and the way these flaws may lead to humanity's undoing.
In the first stanza, the speaker links the ship to "human vanity" and says it was "the Pride of Life" that planned the ship. Later, the fish refer to the ship as "vaingloriousness," reiterating its status as a testament to human hubris. People thought they were building something unsinkable, but nature had other plans.
In describing the ship, the speaker also takes care to emphasize its luxurious features—the jewels, the glittering, "gilded" surfaces, the mirrors—and the way these features pleased vain passengers. The mirror is actually a longstanding artistic symbol for vanity in its own right, so emphasizing the ship's mirrors in the poem help make the ship itself a symbol for vanity.
Similarly, worms are a traditional symbol of morality, as worms devour human corpses in graveyards. With the image of the sea-worms crawling over the mirrors, then, the speaker reminds the reader that all the luxurious goods that feed human vanity cannot save humanity from the powerful forces that govern the world itself, like fate and death.
The speaker also refers to the ship as a "creature" in line 17, which implies that it is a living thing. If human beings have designed and created a living thing, this suggests that they are attempting to play God—again, an act of hubris that the poem insists can only lead to destruction. Indeed, the Titanic now stands, not only in this poem but in cultural memory generally, as a symbol of human ambition overreaching itself.
- See where this symbol appears in the poem.
-
-
“The Convergence of the Twain” Poetic Devices & Figurative Language
-
Irony
Irony describes the contrast between expectation and reality as the speaker establishes it throughout the poem. The chief difference between what was expected and what really came to pass lies, of course, in the fate of the Titanic itself. Its makers and passengers expected it to cross the ocean with safety, speed, and comfort; in reality, it sank and killed hundreds.
The speaker brings out this larger irony through a series of smaller images focused on contrast. For example, stanza II features an image of the sea's currents flowing through the ship's boiler rooms. The image contrasts the water that now actually fills the "chambers" with the "salamandrine fires" that the ship's makers intended to fill the chambers. This contrast is made ironic because the opulent fireplaces now hold only the very element that puts fires out.
Stanza III offers an image of sea-worms crawling over mirrors. This juxtaposes the people who were expected to use the mirrors—the ship's "opulent" passengers—with the creatures who have actually ended up using thm, the "grotesque" worms. These images remind the reader of the vast difference between what the ship seemed to be—an unsinkable force, a human-made power greater than the power of nature—and what it actually turned out to be: something for the lowliest of creatures to crawl on.
Irony is also present in the poem's use of biblical allusions. For example, the terms "cleaving" and "mate" present the ship and the iceberg as parallel to Adam and Eve, who came together in the "consummation" of marriage just as the ship and iceberg come together in the "consummation" of a collision. But while God created Eve to help Adam and create life, the vague force (that "Immanent Will") in this poem "[p]repared" the iceberg to destroy the ship and cause death.
The phrase "stature, grace, and hue" and the term "consummation," create a parallel between the Titanic and Jesus Christ. But again, while Christ was sent by a compassionate God to save humanity, the ship is used by an indifferent deity/force to destroy humanity. It is ironic that the speaker would describe the wreck of the Titanic using the language and figures of the Bible when the emphasis in the Bible is on God's saving love for humankind and the poem depicts a supernatural power who plans and takes pleasure in humankind's destruction.
In describing the wreck from the perspective of this supernatural power, the speaker also adopts an ironic tone. Though describing a momentous tragedy, nothing in the speaker's tone suggests mourning or sorrow. Instead, like the "indifferent" sea-worms, the speaker is dispassionate. Some alliterated phrases ("Jewels in joy", "gilded gear") and the "praise" for the Titanic ("smart ship," "gaily great") even come across as outright mocking. The speaker's tone and implied attitude are ironic in that they violate the reader's expectations for how this tragic subject would be described.
Overall, the poem's irony functions both to chastise and to warn. The ship's makers seem even more at fault when their confidence is set against the ship's actual fate. And if this fate was planned by a supernatural power, the destructive indifference of this power is even more striking when contrasted with the sympathy of God.
- See where this poetic device appears in the poem.
-
Allusion
- See where this poetic device appears in the poem.
-
Juxtaposition
- See where this poetic device appears in the poem.
-
Imagery
- See where this poetic device appears in the poem.
-
Personification
- See where this poetic device appears in the poem.
-
Climax (Figure of Speech)
- See where this poetic device appears in the poem.
-
Enjambment
- See where this poetic device appears in the poem.
-
Consonance
- See where this poetic device appears in the poem.
-
-
"The Convergence of the Twain" Vocabulary
Select any word below to get its definition in the context of the poem. The words are listed in the order in which they appear in the poem.
- Titanic
- Vanity
- Pride of Life
- Stilly
- Couches
- Chambers
- Pyres
- Salamandrine
- Thrid
- Lyres
- Glass
- Opulent
- Grotesque
- Dumb
- Indifferent
- Ravish
- Sensuous
- Bleared
- Gilded
- Gear
- Query
- Vaingloriousness
- Creature of cleaving wing
- Immanent Will
- Stirs
- Urges
- Gaily
- Dissociate
- Smart
- Stature
- Grace
- Hue
- Alien
- Intimate
- Welding
- Bent
- Coincident
- Anon
- August
- Spinner of the Years
- Consummation
-
The Titanic was an ocean liner, the largest vessel afloat in its day, that took its first voyage in April 1912. It collided with an iceberg and sank on April 15 despite the fact that it had been designed to be unsinkable.
The poem's title, "The Convergence of the Twain," refers to the coming together (converging) of the two (twain) entities: the ship and the iceberg.
- See where this vocabulary word appears in the poem.
-
Form, Meter, & Rhyme Scheme of “The Convergence of the Twain”
-
Form
The poem is divided into eleven stanzas of three lines each (tercets). The stanzas are each numbered, making them feel like short vignettes or chapters from a story.
Besides the separation between the individual stanzas, there is also a clear separation between the first and second half of the poem. The first half of the poem focuses closely on the wreck of the Titanic after it has sunk beneath the sea. These stanzas create a series of distinct images: the crawling sea worms, the blackened jewels, the gaping fish. In the poem's second half, the stanzas zoom out to tell the story of the ship before the wreck, up until the very moment of the collision. The poem's first half thus explains the effect of the collision while the second half explains the cause. (This thematic shift between the poem's two parts is similar to the turn or volta between the octave and the sestet in a sonnet.)
-
Meter
The poem has a mixed meter. Within each 3-line stanza, the first two lines are written in iambic trimeter and the third line is written in iambic hexameter. An iamb is a poetic foot with an unstressed-stressed beat pattern, da DUM. Trimeter means there are three iambs, three da DUMs, per line, while hexameter means there are six. Stanza II is scanned, for example, like this:
Steel cham- | bers, late | the pyres
Of her sal- | aman- | drine fires,
Cold cur- | rents thrid, | and turn | to rhyth- | mic tid | al lyres.Even here it's clear that the poem's meter is frequently irregular. Above, there are a couple spondees (stressed-stressed) and anapests (unstressed-unstressed-stressed). Sometimes these irregularities have no strong effect on the poem, adding simple moments of sonic interest. Other times, though, they add deliberate extra emphasis to words. Line 9, for instance, scans like this:
The sea- | worm crawls | — grotesque, | slimed, dumb, | indif- | ferent.
The stress on "slimed," which creates another spondee, adds extra emphasis to the word, almost forcing the reader to visualize this unpleasant image.
The iambic rhythm is a common one in English poetry. It functions especially to stress important words at the ends of lines, since iambic lines conclude with a stressed syllable. In line 3, for example, the final stress emphasizes "she," the wreck of the Titanic lying at the bottom of the ocean; in line 19, "mate" is stressed, and so is the disturbing claim that the iceberg was meant to come together with the ship.
Less common in English poetry is the way the lines vary so starkly in length. One effect of this variation is to build suspense. The first two lines of each stanza are short, with only three feet. The third line, then, with its six feet, forces the reader to wait for what feels like an unusually long time before learning how the stanza ends.
Another intended effect of the short first two lines and the long final line might be to replicate the actual “convergence of the twain” in the poem's form. The two trimeter lines might represent the ship and the iceberg, which the poem describes as evenly matched. The final hexameter line could represent the two coming together. The ship and the iceberg are described as “twin halves” of one event, as two trimeter lines would be the twin halves that make up one hexameter line.
-
Rhyme Scheme
The rhyme scheme of the poem is simple. The three lines of each stanza rhyme with each other, like so:
AAA
BBB...etc. Essentially all the rhymes are full, clear perfect rhymes. The regularity of the rhyme scheme and the frequency of the rhymes (each rhyming sound appears not twice but three times) contributes to the emotional effect of the poem.
One of the themes of the poem is the way that the ship and the iceberg appeared to be unrelated and far apart but were actually destined to meet. The rhyme scheme almost recreates this relationship in sound. The regularity of the rhymes means that once the reader hears two A sounds, they expect that a third A sound will inevitably follow.
Of course, the final rhyme is delayed because the third line in each stanza is twice as long as the first two lines (a hexameter as compared to a trimeter line). This delay mimics the separation of the ship and the iceberg. The time of their meeting is "far and dissociate," there is "shadowy silent distance" between them. But of course, they are also "bent / By paths coincident" toward one unavoidable outcome. Similarly, the final rhyme is separated from the first two rhymes, but the reader still anticipates it as an unavoidable ending, and indeed, in each stanza, the anticipated ending arrives.
Because the rhyme scheme is so prominent, it gives additional prominence to the words that are the rhyming words. It creates a connection between them, inviting the reader to see how they are thematically related. For example, the terms "meant," "opulent," and "indifferent" are key words in stanza III, and they are fittingly highlighted as the rhyming words. The ship was "meant" to provide safety and power, but it ended up overpowered by natural forces that are "indifferent" to human intentions. The rhyme links "meant" and "indifferent" to highlight the thematic contrast between human desires and nature's unconcern with those desires.
-
-
“The Convergence of the Twain” Speaker
-
The speaker is not a character in the scene of the poem itself but more of an omniscient third-person narrator. This speaker is able to see what occurs in the "solitude of the sea" where no human being could actually be, and knows the movements and intentions of the "Immanent Will," the supernatural power in the poem. Despite this distance, the speaker does express certain definite attitudes in the poem. The speaker is critical of human "vanity" and "Pride," mocks the "gilded gear" of the sunken ship, and withholds sympathy from the human victims by never mentioning them in the poem.
-
-
“The Convergence of the Twain” Setting
-
Stanzas I-V are set in a specific place and time: "[d]eep" in the Atlantic Ocean, sometime after the Titanic 's sinking. The setting is eerie and inhospitable. The water is "[c]old" and "lightless," and sea-worms "crawl[]" over the wreck like the worms that eat away corpses in graveyards. The poem was published in May 1912, just a month after the ship sank, but it might be imagining how the wreck might look after months or even years on the ocean floor. The ship is already being penetrated by the sea's currents, and sea creatures have taken over the wreck.
Stanzas VI-XI shift location. They move back in time, starting from when the Titanic was first created and going right up to the moment of the collision. There is no one place in which all six stanzas are set, but they do describe the iceberg as sitting in "shadowy silent distance," far from where the ship being built.
-
-
Literary and Historical Context of “The Convergence of the Twain”
-
Literary Context
“The Convergence of the Twain,” like all of Hardy’s writings, is shaped by Christianity in that its language is filled with allusions to the Bible. But the allusions do not mean that “Convergence” is a Christian poem. On the contrary, they underscore its decidedly un-Christian outlook—an outlook that Hardy himself shared. Rather than believing that an all-powerful, all-loving God created and guided humankind, Hardy subscribed to the idea, influenced by Charles Darwin, that humans had evolved from earlier species by a natural process in an unconscious, uncaring universe. Hardy’s poems and novels—works like Jude the Obscure and Tess of the D’Urbervilles—often reflect this worldview.
Hardy’s poem was first printed in a 1912 program for an event to raise relief funds for the Titanic’s victims. In its bleak worldview and its anti-celebratory tone, Hardy’s poem contrasts sharply with several other poems printed in the same program and, more significantly, with other key poems in the English elegiac tradition.
For example, in Herbert Trenche’s “Requiem of archangels for the world” (a 1911 poem reprinted in the 1912 program), nature itself acknowledges and mourns for the dead: “All iron stands [Earth’s] wrinkled tree, / The streams that sang are stricken dumb.” In two other famous elegies, nature similarly weeps for the dead. In “Adonais,” Percy Shelley’s elegy for the poet John Keats, the speaker declares that “Grief made the young Spring wild, and she threw down / Her kindling buds.” Similarly, in “Lycidas,” John Milton’s elegy for a lost friend, “the woods and desert caves, / With wild thyme and the gadding vine o'ergrown, / And all their echoes mourn.”
In Hardy’s poem, by contrast, nature does not mourn or honor the victims but is simply baffled by the wreck. The victims are not mourned so much as critiqued for the “vanity” and “Pride” that led them so arrogantly to assume that they could escape death by building an unsinkable ship.
More commonly, elegies do not critique but celebrate their deceased subjects. “The Convergence of the Twain” offers no such comforting hope of resurrection or afterlife with God. The supernatural force in this poem actually planned the collision and, far from mourning the deaths, seems to find the collision a pleasing, impressive event. This is a far more disturbing idea for mourners to contemplate. Celebrating the dead and consoling those who mourn are the traditional functions of elegies. Hardy’s poem is almost an anti-elegy in how strongly it refuses to do either.
Historical Context
Hardy’s poem was first published in May 1912, one month after the Titanic sank. The R.M.S. Titanic was a British passenger liner that struck an iceberg and sank on April 15, 1912, during her very first voyage. There were an estimated 2,224 people on board and over 1,500 of them died. Hardy’s poem was printed in a program intended to raise funds for the victims, the “Dramatic and Operatic Matinée in Aid of the ‘Titanic’ Disaster Fund," which was held in London at the Royal Opera House on May 14, 1912.
Even before the disaster, the Titanic was famous as the largest ship currently afloat and one of the most luxurious ever built, with a swimming pool, a gymnasium, a library, and glamorous cabins and restaurants catering to its many wealthy passengers (there were also many poorer emigrants traveling in third class). The references to “the opulent” and “gilded gear” in the poem register this luxury.
The ship was also popularly believed to be unsinkable. An 1910 advertisement for the Titanic and its sister ship the Olympic stated that “as far as it is possible to do so, these two wonderful vessels are designed to be unsinkable.” This belief in the ship’s indestructibility may have contributed to passengers’ slowness to board the lifeboats. A headline in the New York Times on April 16, 1912, read “Manager of the Line Insisted Titanic Was Unsinkable Even After She Had Gone Down.” When Hardy refers to “human vanity” and “the Pride of Life,” he may well be referring to the belief that people could build something that could not be destroyed.
After the wreck, relief funds were established to raise money for survivors and families of those who had died. The Matinée on May 14, 1912, was held to raise money for one such fund, and a number of poets, including Hardy, contributed poems to the event program.
-
-
More “The Convergence of the Twain” Resources
-
External Resources
-
Thomas Hardy's Biography — A biography of the poet, with an emphasis on his development as a writer and the themes that run throughout his work.
-
The Poem Out Loud — A recitation of the poem by Ian Whitcomb, a British musician.
-
Poetry and the Titanic — An article from the Library of Congress on how the public used poetry to respond to the sinking, with links to other poems about the ship.
-
Timeline of the Titanic — An interactive timeline of the building, sailing, and sinking of the ship.
-
Titanic Relief Efforts — Images of programs from three different fundraising events for victims of the Titanic, including the program in which Hardy's poem was first published.
-
-
LitCharts on Other Poems by Thomas Hardy
-
