The Full Text of “The Clod and the Pebble”
1"Love seeketh not itself to please,
2Nor for itself hath any care,
3But for another gives its ease,
4And builds a Heaven in Hell's despair."
5So sung a little Clod of Clay
6Trodden with the cattle's feet,
7But a Pebble of the brook
8Warbled out these metres meet:
9"Love seeketh only self to please,
10To bind another to its delight,
11Joys in another's loss of ease,
12And builds a Hell in Heaven's despite."
The Full Text of “The Clod and the Pebble”
1"Love seeketh not itself to please,
2Nor for itself hath any care,
3But for another gives its ease,
4And builds a Heaven in Hell's despair."
5So sung a little Clod of Clay
6Trodden with the cattle's feet,
7But a Pebble of the brook
8Warbled out these metres meet:
9"Love seeketh only self to please,
10To bind another to its delight,
11Joys in another's loss of ease,
12And builds a Hell in Heaven's despite."
-
“The Clod and the Pebble” Introduction
-
"The Clod and the Pebble" is a poem by William Blake, first published in Songs of Innocence and Experience (1794). In the poem, a personified clod (a small clump of earth or clay) and pebble put forward two very different definitions of love. The clod, representing the more optimistic—and perhaps naive—perspective, views love as a kind of radical selflessness, in which giving and self-sacrifice are all-important. The pebble disagrees, declaring instead that love is in fact pure selfishness, something that only seeks to please itself. In the end, the poem leaves it up to the reader to make up their own mind about the true nature of love.
-
-
“The Clod and the Pebble” Summary
-
"Love doesn't try to make itself happy. It doesn't care about itself at all. Instead, it sacrifices its own comfort for others, and creates its own kind of Heaven even within the misery of Hell."
At least, that's according to a little lump of clay, who is often squashed by cow's walking overhead. But a pebble in a nearby stream sang out this tidy response:
"Love only wants to make itself happy, and to make others dependent on it. Love takes pleasure in other people's discomfort, and creates Hell even in the middle of Heaven."
-
-
“The Clod and the Pebble” Themes
-
The Nature of Love
“The Clod and the Pebble” offers two competing visions of love. The first kind of love is based on selflessness, as represented by the personified Clod, while the second is based on selfishness, as represented by the Pebble. The humble Clod thinks love is all about sacrifice and generosity in the name of making others happy, whereas the Pebble argues that it’s all about a lover getting what they want—even if that means other people get hurt. The poem doesn’t explicitly say which perspective is better or truer, and both have downsides. On one level, then, the poem implies that love is a combination of the two perspectives—a mixture of selflessness and selfishness. The poem could also be read as a kind of warning about the way that love can become a damaging force, by either making people too submissive or, alternatively, too self-interested.
The Clod believes that love is altruistic and all about generosity. Love requires nothing of others—its only need is fulfilled in the act of giving love. This idea doesn't need to be limited to romantic love, either; in fact, the Clod’s definition of love is in line with certain Christian ideals. Love is its own reward, the Clod says, and people should seek to manifest their love by denying their own comfort in the service of others' "ease."
The Clod, for its part, lives out this denial of self-interest on a daily basis: it’s constantly being squashed by the heavy tread of passing cows, yet feels no animosity about this at all. Even if the world around it is a kind of “Hell,” the Clod believes that selfless love can create its own little “Heaven”—a paradise—in the midst of such miserable circumstances.
The Pebble in a nearby stream argues against the clod’s point of view, however, suggesting instead that love is pure selfishness. Love only wants to please itself, the Pebble says, and to trap people through “bind[ing]” them to its “delight”—that is, by making other people fulfill the lover’s own desires. Love, according to the Pebble, even revels in making people uncomfortable or distressed. Love thus doesn't create any sort of “Heaven,” but rather builds its own “Hell.”
Just as the Clod represents selflessness in its willingness to be trodden own, so too does the Pebble physically embody its own attitude towards love: it holds strong in the stream and refuses to be moved, making the water travel around it. In other words, it doesn’t know what it’s like to make selfless sacrifices (unlike the Clod).
The poem doesn’t argue that either of these viewpoints is correct, and both have clear downsides. While at first the Clod’s viewpoint might seem more morally sound, it also might be taken as overly naive and passive, turning lovers into downtrodden victims without a sense of self or backbone. The Pebble, meanwhile, comes across as perhaps more realistic but also cold and hard-hearted, unwilling to bend and thus forcing the stream to move around it—remaining strong but totally alone in the process. In the end, the poem perhaps suggests that genuine, lasting love is a combination of these two perspectives.
- See where this theme is active in the poem.
-
-
Line-by-Line Explanation & Analysis of “The Clod and the Pebble”
-
Lines 1-2
"Love seeketh not itself to please,
Nor for itself hath any care,The poem opens with the song of the Clod (a small clump of earth or clay). In this song, the clod presents its vision of love, which is characterized by a kind of extreme selflessness. Love doesn't require or desire anything, according to the humble Clod, nor does it even have "any care" for itself at all. In other words, love is all about generosity and sacrifice.
As is often the case with Blake's poems, the simple and sparse language here masks complex ideas. First, there are multiple layers of personification at work here: the Clod is personified—given a voice—and the Clod in turn personifies love.
Love itself is portrayed as capable of selflessness or selfishness. This "Love" might refer specifically to the way that people love each other, but it could also refer to love as a kind of force—the expression of God, perhaps.
It's important to keep in mind Blake's strong commitment to the Christian faith (though his views on Christianity were fiercely independent). To that end, the Clod's definition of love aligns closely with typical Christian ideas. God gave the world his son, Jesus, as a kind of loving sacrifice (who, in turn, sacrificed himself for humanity). As the Clod seems to express, people should show a similar willingness to love—and sacrifice—without the expectation of reward.
The sound of the opening lines is very gentle, supporting the idea of love as self-sacrifice. The soft /th/ sounds in "seeketh" and "hath," combined with the sibilance running throughout the lines, grant the lines a hushed quiet—as though the poem itself is submitting to another authority.
These lines also establish the poem's meter of iambic tetrameter, four poetic feet per line in an ustressed-stressed syllable pattern:
"Love seeketh not itself to please,
Nor for itself hath any care,These lines aren't necessarily perfect in their meter—it's possible to stress the opening word "Love," for example, as we've done here—but they are relatively steady and familiar in their sound.
-
Lines 3-4
But for another gives its ease,
And builds a Heaven in Hell's despair." -
Lines 5-6
So sung a little Clod of Clay
Trodden with the cattle's feet, -
Lines 7-8
But a Pebble of the brook
Warbled out these metres meet: -
Lines 9-10
"Love seeketh only self to please,
To bind another to its delight, -
Lines 11-12
Joys in another's loss of ease,
And builds a Hell in Heaven's despite."
-
-
“The Clod and the Pebble” Symbols
-
The Clod
The personified Clod (which is a small lump of earth or clay) believes that love is a force for good, defined by humility and generosity. In turn, the humble Clod itself comes to symbolize those qualities; it stands (or, rather, lies down) for selflessness. The Clod is used to being trodden on—because cows are constantly walking over it—and thus knows what it's like to submit to someone else, to be made uncomfortable for someone else's benefit. The Clod is also less solid than the hard-hearted Pebble; it's soft and malleable, reflecting the way that its definition of love is all about doing whatever it takes to please others.
The fact that it is quite literally walked all over by lowly cattle, however, suggests that there is an element of naivety to the Clod's total humility—that it perhaps represents selflessness to the point of self-destruction.
- See where this symbol appears in the poem.
-
The Pebble
The Pebble presents a definition of love that is far more cynical than that of the Clod. The Pebble believes that love is entirely selfish, a kind of destructive force that has only its own satisfaction in mind and doesn't care about hurting others. The Pebble, like the Clod, becomes a symbol of its own point of view: it represents selfishness.
Unlike the soft, malleable Clod, the Pebble is tough and rigid, its physical solidity suggesting hard-heartedness. The Pebble also makes water bend its course, forcing it to move around the Pebble; this suggests the way love exerts control over others (as opposed to making sacrifices for them). And while the Clod happily gets squashed flat by cattle's feet, the Pebble could potentially trip the cattle up, suggesting that with stubborn selfishness comes the potential it for danger and pain.
- See where this symbol appears in the poem.
-
-
“The Clod and the Pebble” Poetic Devices & Figurative Language
-
Alliteration
Alliteration is an important part of "The Clod and the Pebble" and occurs through the poem. Generally speaking, alliteration gives the poem a song-like quality. The poem appears in Blake's Songs of Experience, but the first and third stanzas are clearly marked out as songs in and of themselves—one by the Clod, and the other by the Pebble. It makes sense, then, that the poem uses such clear alliteration in phrases like "So sung," "Clod of Clay," and "metres meet." All this alliteration (combined with consonance, assonance, and the poem's simple rhythms) gives the poem a very musical sound, one which lends itself well to memorization. These sonic devices help the poem feel like a lesson being taught.
Alliteration also has more specific effects as well. For example, lines 4 and 12 use alliteration in "Heaven" and "Hell." The proximity of the words, combined with the shared sound, suggests that they are not all that far apart; love can make all the difference in turning Hell into Heaven—and vice versa!
- See where this poetic device appears in the poem.
-
Antithesis
- See where this poetic device appears in the poem.
-
Assonance
- See where this poetic device appears in the poem.
-
Consonance
- See where this poetic device appears in the poem.
-
Personification
- See where this poetic device appears in the poem.
-
Repetition
- See where this poetic device appears in the poem.
-
-
"The Clod and the Pebble" Vocabulary
Select any word below to get its definition in the context of the poem. The words are listed in the order in which they appear in the poem.
- Seeketh
- Hath
- Ease
- Clod
- Trodden
- Brook
- Warbled
- Metres
- Meet
- Self
- Bind
- Joys
- Despite
-
Archaic form of "seeks."
- See where this vocabulary word appears in the poem.
-
Form, Meter, & Rhyme Scheme of “The Clod and the Pebble”
-
Form
"The Clod and the Pebble" has a very simple form in keeping with most of the other poems in Blake's Songs of Innocence and Experience. But also typically of Blake, simplicity of form masks the complexity of the ideas contained within. That is, this isn't a simple poem—it's a poem of opposites, or "contrary states" as Blake liked to call them.
The poem consists of12 lines broken up into three quatrains. But it can also be divided into two equal parts, with each one representing a different character and viewpoint. The poem neatly splits in two at the end of line 6, with the first half of the poem dealing with the Clod and the second with the Pebble.
Each of these personified objects expresses, through song, an opinion on the nature of love, and they could hardly be more different. The Clod takes the idealistic yet perhaps naive view that love is about a kind of radical self-sacrifice. This viewpoint opens the poem, and the second stanza attributes it to the Clod, while also adding the detail about the Clod being "Trodden" on by cattle. The second half expresses the alternative view, put forward by the Pebble. Love is selfish, hard-hearted, and destructive. The poem, then, is purely antithetical, laying two opposites side-by-side and providing very little commentary on which is correct.
This idea of antithesis as a kind of symmetry plays out in other ways too. For example, the similar vocabulary and sentence structure used in the first and third stanzas, or the pairs of alliterative sounds (e.g., "Clod" with "Clay"). Formally speaking, then, miniature elements of the poem represent the overall structure as a kind of pair—its the Clod and the Pebble, not the Clod or the Pebble. Accordingly, perhaps it's reasonable to see the poem as a subtle argument that love is a combination of selflessness and selfishness—neither fully one nor the other.
-
Meter
As with most of Blake's poetry, "The Clod and the Pebble" has a simple rhythm. The poem flows easily from start to finish, for the most part conforming to iambic tetrameter. This means there are four feet per line, each of which has an unstressed-stressed beat pattern (da-DUM). Line 5 provides a clear example:
So sung | a lit- | tle Clod | of Clay
Generally speaking, the regularity of the meter gives the poem a song-like quality, almost like a hymn. It gives the Clod and the Pebble the space to sing their respective songs of love, which, though markedly different in their philosophies, sound remarkably similar (perhaps suggesting that they have more in common that they realize, or that love is really a combination between their two opposing points of view).
But also typically of Blake, there are important variations in the meter as well. The most significant of these occur in lines 6 and 8, both of which trim the first unstressed syllable of the first foot (technically known as catalexis):
Trod- | den with | the cat- | tle's feet,
[...]
Warb- | led out | these met- | res meet:
The rest of the line conforms to the typical iambic meter. Some readers may break up the line differently—marking the feet here as trochees (stressed-unstressed) with a missing beat at the end of the line—but the result is the same: a heavy emphasis falls on "Trodden" and "Warbled." With the first word, this conveys the heaviness of the cattle's weight as their feet land down on the Clod. With "Warbled," the dramatic shift in stress signals that it is the Pebble's turn to sing—that it is taking over and turning up the volume of its own voice.
-
Rhyme Scheme
"The Clod and the Pebble" has a relatively simple rhyme scheme:
ABAB CDED AFAF
The first and last stanza have the same pattern, while second stanza has unrhymed first and third lines (C and E in the scheme above). The first and third stanza also both repeat the A rhyme words exactly ("please" and "ease"). This is just one of many similarities between these stanzas, which, though nearly identical in language and grammar, express completely opposing ideas about love (selflessness vs. selfishness). The fact that the second stanza is a bit different in its pattern of rhyme helps mark it out as separate from the other two—a third-person interjection between the arguments.
The most important overall function of the rhyme scheme is to give the poem a song-like quality. This makes sense, considering that the poem is taken from Songs of Innocence and Experience (1794) and explicitly mentions singing in the second stanza ("So sung" and "Warbled").
The rhyming pair in the second stanza also contains a small pun. Line 8's "meet" plays on the meaning of "feet" in line 6. While "feet" refers to the cattle that tread on little Clod, it also gestures towards the word's meaning in relation to poetry/song. "Feet" are the different segments of a metrical line of poetry (this poem, for example, has four feet in each line). There's also a contrast at work here between the heaviness of the cattle's feet and the lightness of the Pebble's warbling "metres meet."
-
-
“The Clod and the Pebble” Speaker
-
"The Clod and the Pebble" has three speakers. The two main speakers are the titular characters, the Clod (a little clump of earth/clay) and the Pebble. They form the poem's two opposing voices, which express antithetical views about the nature of love.
The Clod, speaking in the first stanza, represents the view that love depends on altruism, generosity, and selflessness. In its opinion, love—which both voices personify—cares only for others. This is an idealistic and somewhat naive conception of love that nonetheless gestures towards Christian ideas of charity and sacrifice. According to the Clod, this kind of love can create a "Heaven" even out of the worst situations. The Clod's physical properties match up with its point of view—its soft, malleable form, trodden on by passing cattle, representing its belief that love is about sacrifice for others.
The second main speaker, the Pebble, takes up the third stanza and believes that love is not selfless. On the contrary, it's purely selfish, seeking on to "please" itself. Furthermore, it has the power to dominate others, to "bind" them to itself like some kind of parasitic host. The Pebble even goes so far as to say that love actively enjoys the pain it can cause, hinting at the way love can drive people to desperate acts. Like the Clod, the Pebble's physical properties mirror its beliefs. Its tough, stony exterior represents a cynical hard-heartedness.
Though these are the two main speakers, there is also a third. The second stanza is spoken by neither the Clod nor the Pebble, but by a detached narrator. It's from this narrator that the reader learns who is singing, and a brief sketch of the environment in which the poem is set.
-
-
“The Clod and the Pebble” Setting
-
"The Clod and the Pebble" is set in a rural environment, a place with "cattle" (perhaps a farm) near a "brook," or small stream. The reader doesn't learn this until the second stanza, in which it's made clear that the two speakers, who each have bold statements to make about the nature of love, are not people, but rather a clump of earth and a small rock. The poem opts for this setting because it creates a platform from which the Clod and the Pebble can sing their respective songs. Of course, both are rather small, insignificant parts of a greater landscape, suggesting that there may be something incomplete about their grand theories about love.
The poem's setting also ties in with the symbolism of the Clod and the Pebble. Both define themselves in relationship with their environment. The Clod, which is used to being trampled on by passing cows, views love as a kind of radical self-sacrifice. Conversely, the Pebble rests firm in the brook, forcing water to travel around it, and thus believes that love is about taking advantage of others.
-
-
Literary and Historical Context of “The Clod and the Pebble”
-
Literary Context
"The Clod and the Pebble" appears in Blake's famous work, Songs of Innocence and Experience (1794), and is drawn from the Experience section of the book (the Innocence section was first published five years earlier). In these Songs, Blake sought to show what he called the two "contrary states of the human soul." This "contrary states" idea plays out here in the poem's two opposing definitions of love.
Throughout this collection, the "innocent" perspectives tend to express ideals that are beautiful and appealing, but which are also at times naive and unrealistic. That's because they aren't based on experience of the real world (with which, it's fair to say, Blake was deeply dissatisfied). The innocent perspective here is the Clod's, and so warrants comparisons with other similar perspectives in the first book: "Infant Joy," "The Shepherd," "Laughing Song," and so on.
As with some other characters in Songs of Innocence, the Clod believes in something that is probably unattainable: pure selflessness. The Pebble appears to be the more experienced perspective, but comes across as too cynical. For the Pebble, love is selfish—and such selfishness is on display in other Experience poems like "The Garden of Love" and "London."
In terms of subject, of course, the interrogation of the nature of love is practically as old as poetry itself. From Sappho of the classical era to the contemporary poets, love has puzzled, fascinated, and obsessed poets for centuries.
Historical Context
On the surface at least, little of Blake's historical context seems to find its way into this poem. As with many of the other poems in Songs of Innocence and Experience, "The Clod and the Pebble" takes place in what is a kind of timeless zone, as if the truths that it claims to speak have always been true and always will be. The reference to cattle suggests, at least, that the poem is set in a time of agricultural labor—though this hardly narrows it down.
Blake was writing during a time of considerable societal upheaval. The Industrial Revolution caused significant changes in the fabric of daily life, and Blake saw this shift as a kind of biblical Fall. Blake was consistently disappointed in the world around him, and perhaps something of the selfishness that he saw in late 18th century finds its way into the Pebble's perspective. Conversely, the Clod seems to speak of a more essential, instinctive, and innocent kind of love.
Religion is, of course, an important aspect of the poem as well. Blake was a Christian, but was highly critical of the Church of England institutions that dominated the British religious landscape at the time. For Blake, something fundamental to man's relationship with God had been lost. And if the "love"in this poem is taken to mean something more than romantic love, then perhaps implicitly criticizes the way that organized religion was failing to embody the true spirit of the Christian faith. The Bible is full of references to charity and selflessness—think about the Good Samaritan, for example—but the Pebble's perspective shows that, in the real world, this kind of love is not guaranteed.
-
-
More “The Clod and the Pebble” Resources
-
External Resources
-
The Illustrated Poem — "The Clod and the Pebble" in Blake's own hand, accompanied by his drawings.
-
Songs of Innocence and Experience — Various formats for the full collection in which this poem appears.
-
Blake's Visions — An excerpt from a documentary in which writer Iain Sinclair discusses Blake's religious visions.
-
The Poem Out Loud — A reading by the Youtube channel Tom O'Bedlam.
-
Blake's Radicalism — An interesting article that provides insight into Blake's political views.
-
-
LitCharts on Other Poems by William Blake
-