Everything Is Tuberculosis

by

John Green

Everything Is Tuberculosis: Chapter 12 Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
Along with Koch’s discovery of M. tuberculosis came small improvements in diagnosing and treating TB. X-rays were one of these tools, with Dr. Alan Hart (a trans man who struggled to practice because of rampant transphobia) pioneering the use of chest X-rays as a tool for diagnosing TB. While effective treatments were still hard to come by, tools for prevention also saw progress. Milk became pasteurized to limit spread from cows to humans, and a vaccine emerged. The Bacillus Calmette-Guerine (BCG) vaccine is now known to be ineffective at preventing illness in teens and adults, but it is effective in presenting severe illness in children.
Green’s intentional inclusion of Dr. Alan Hart’s hardships caused by transphobia develops both his aim for presenting the complex and diverse history of tuberculosis and the convergence of marginalized identities, social norms, and science. History does not always comply with normative ideals, and Hart’s trans identity is a perfect reflection of that. Additionally, his identity directly impacted his ability to practice medicine and develop more medical innovations; the social stigmas surrounding his identity thus directly interfered with the path of science.
Themes
Science and Injustice Theme Icon
Stigmatization and Dehumanization Theme Icon
Nuance, Empathy, and Understanding Theme Icon
Quotes
By the 1940s and 1950s, however, TB quickly became a treatable and curable disease. Multiple drugs were developed and proved effective in fighting TB, and death rates plummeted. Sanatoria emptied in the U.S. and Europe, where these drugs were easy to administer, but this cure did not reach the poor countries that desperately needed it. Much of the decisions to keep the cure from largely non-white countries stems from racism and colonialism, as people believed that these populations were too “‘child-like’ to be trusted to take or dispense medicine as prescribed.”
Once again, understandings of and treatments for tuberculosis were influenced by sociopolitical norms, in this case society’s history of racism and colonialism. Science and sociocultural norms are thus complexly intertwined.
Themes
Science and Injustice Theme Icon
History’s Influence on the Modern Day Theme Icon
Stigmatization and Dehumanization Theme Icon