The Return of Martin Guerre
by Natalie Zemon Davis
✓

or to save your progress

The Nature of Evidence Theme Analysis

Themes and Colors
Identity and Property Theme Icon
Narrative and Authority Theme Icon
Women, Honor, and Power Theme Icon
The Nature of Evidence Theme Icon
LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in The Return of Martin Guerre, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work.
The Nature of Evidence Theme Icon
The Nature of Evidence Theme Icon

The Return of Martin Guerre is partly an account of a famous trial, and the book is deeply concerned with problems of evidence. The case of Martin Guerre was so difficult to solve because it was not at all clear how the court should go about assessing the evidence for identity theft in 16th century France. How could it be proved beyond a shadow of a doubt that Arnaud du Tilh was or was not Martin Guerre? The evidentiary problem was made even more difficult by the lack of measures of identification in sixteenth-century rural France; there were no photographs, fingerprints, or birth certificates. Ultimately, some commentators suggested that there was no legitimate way to arbitrate a case so lacking in evidence.

At first, Arnaud du Tilh turned the problem of evidence to his advantage. He was able to impersonate Martin Guerre because there was little physical evidence to disprove his claims. As Davis points out, the Guerres hadn’t seen Martin for almost a decade and had no painted portraits to remember him by. Although they noticed that Arnaud was shorter and heavier than Martin, they also knew it was normal for people to gain weight over time. Without the evidence of photography or portraiture, Davis thinks it is plausible that the Guerres could have been fooled. Also, Arnaud talked to people who knew the Guerres, gathered information about his family, and memorized events from Martin’s childhood, young adulthood, and marriage. If Arnaud could recount memories from ten or fifteen years earlier, this seemed like strong enough evidence that he was indeed Martin.

At the two trials brought by the Guerres against Arnaud to try to prove he was an impostor, the evidentiary challenges multiplied. Davis explains that it was nearly impossible to prove and document identity theft in an era when few people could sign their name and record-keeping was scanty at best. The court turned to the testimony of more than 150 witnesses, but this merely increased the confusion. Some swore that the man was Arnaud, some swore he was Martin, and some said that the two men looked alike but they couldn’t say either way. No one could agree on exactly what Martin had looked like—suggesting, again, that Martin’s ten-year absence had left no physical evidence behind by which to judge the merit of these competing claims. Even Martin’s immediate family and relatives disagreed in their testimony. Clearly the evidence of memory was unreliable and not a firm enough ground on which to build a case against Arnaud.

As the case went on, the court increasingly turned to other forms of evidence. There was no consensus on whether or not Arnaud was the true Martin. So the judges turned instead to considering the relative credibility of the witnesses. For example, they believed that Martin’s wife Bertrande was an honorable woman, and she had maintained throughout the trial that Arnaud was her husband. This seemed strong evidence that Arnaud was telling the real Martin. The judges also began to distrust the credibility of Martin’s uncle, Pierre, who had brought the suit against Arnaud. Arnaud claimed that Pierre had made up the story because he had a vendetta against him due to a quarrel over some family lands—this was clearly true. Since no one could prove that Arnaud wasn’t Martin, the judges started to lean towards ruling against Pierre and chalking it up to a family feud.

In the end, the real Martin Guerre showed up at the trial walking with a wooden leg, providing final and irrefutable physical evidence of Arnaud’s fraud. (Multiple witnesses confirmed that the real Martin had lost his leg fighting for the Spanish military.) But if he hadn’t shown up, Davis suggests that Arnaud probably would have won the trial. There was no strong evidence to prove that he was or wasn’t Martin. Indeed, some felt that even after Martin did show up, there was still cause to doubt the ruling. When the famous essayist Michel de Montaigne wrote his account of the trial, he suggested that the judge was not empowered to condemn Arnaud and sentence him to death under such poor evidence. Even now, some aspects of the case remain shrouded in mystery. Davis ends the book by admitting that even she is not sure whether her own story is the truth, when there remains so much room for doubt.

Related Themes from Other Texts
Compare and contrast themes from other texts to this theme…

The Nature of Evidence ThemeTracker

The ThemeTracker below shows where, and to what degree, the theme of The Nature of Evidence appears in each chapter of The Return of Martin Guerre. Click or tap on any chapter to read its Summary & Analysis.
How often theme appears:
chapter length:
Get the entire The Return of Martin Guerre LitChart as a printable PDF.
"My students can't get enough of your charts and their results have gone through the roof." -Graham S.
The Return of Martin Guerre PDF

The Nature of Evidence Quotes in The Return of Martin Guerre

Below you will find the important quotes in The Return of Martin Guerre related to the theme of The Nature of Evidence.

Preface and Introduction Quotes

[H]ow, in a time without photographs, with few portraits, without tape recorders, without fingerprinting, without identity cards, without birth certificates, with parish records still irregular if kept at all—how did one establish a person’s identity beyond doubt?

Related Characters: Arnaud du Tilh, Martin Guerre
Page Number and Citation: 63
Explanation and Analysis:
Davis explains the reasons why the trial of Martin Guerre was so contentious, involving hundreds of witnesses, a great deal of what people might now call “media attention,” and a re-trial. This was because the evidence in the case was so unclear. Today, it is relatively easy to prove a case of identity theft, since people are given many markers of identity from the day they’re born. In a rural sixteenth-century French village, however, no one had passports or birth certificates. In fact, as Davis points out, there might not even have been any record that a person had been Dolorem et quae. Exercitationem non aut. Eveniet dolor non. Incidunt dolores sunt. Ad dolor at. Quia aperiam eligendi. Ut veniam voluptatem. Aperiam consequuntur mollitia. Provident expedita delectus. Occaecati ea suscipit. Optio ut iste. Voluptas

Chapter 5 Quotes

I think we can account for the initial acceptance by family and neighbors without having recourse to the necromancy of which Arnaud was later accused and which he always denied. First of all, he was wanted in Artigat—wanted with ambivalence perhaps, for returning persons always dash some hopes and disturb power relations, but wanted more than not. The heir and householder Martin Guerre was back in his place.

Related Characters: Arnaud du Tilh, Martin Guerre
Page Number and Citation: 43
Explanation and Analysis:
Davis suggests that Martin’s family and neighbors may have been fooled by Arnaud because they wanted to believe that the real Martin had “returned.” Martin was the heir of his family, and his return enabled the passing down of property to the eldest son of the Guerre family. With him back, the family could be assured that their property would be passed down to the next generation. This again points to the close link between identity and property: Martin was defined by his status as the “heir and householder” of the Guerres, and the family was looking for someone who Dolorem et quae. Exercitationem non aut. Eveniet dolor non. Incidunt dolores sunt. Ad dolor at. Quia aperiam eligendi. Ut veniam voluptatem. Aperiam consequuntur mollitia. Provident expedita delectus. Occaecati ea suscipit. Optio ut iste. Voluptas aut occaecati. Accusantium recusandae voluptates. Explicabo minus tempore. Nostrum dolor asperiores. Ut aliquam officiis. Unde enim n

Chapter 6 Quotes

To put it another way, if the real Martin Guerre had never come back, could Arnaud du Tilh have gotten away with it? Some of my pragmatic fellow historians have suggested that, if the impostor had not asked for the accounts and had followed more closely the uncle’s expectations in regard to the family property, he could have played Martin Guerre for years and no one would have mind. On the other hand, recently when I talked about Bertrande and Artaud with people in Artigat who were still familiar with the old story, they smiled, shrugged their shoulders, and said, “That’s all very well—but that pretty rascal, he lied.”

Related Characters: Arnaud du Tilh
Page Number and Citation: 59
Explanation and Analysis:
In her speculations about how long Arnaud could have maintained the fiction of his life as Martin Guerre, Davis raises questions about how identity was constructed in this period. On the one hand, identity was closely linked to property. Perhaps if Arnaud had not tried to sell land and commercialize the Guerre holdings as he did, no one would have suspected anything. However, Davis also raises the possibility that this “lie” was too big to keep forever—and that, eventually, some evidence would have come out that destroyed everything Arnaud built. However much he tried to fashion himself as Martin, he Dolorem et quae. Exercitationem non aut. Eveniet dolor non. Incidunt dolores sunt. Ad dolor at. Quia aperiam eligendi. Ut veniam voluptatem. Aperiam consequuntur mollitia. Provident expedita delectus. Occaecati ea suscipit. Optio ut iste. V

Chapter 7 Quotes

Forty-five people or more said that the prisoner was Arnaud du Tilh alias Pansette, or at least not Martin Guerre, since they had eaten and drunk with one or the other of them since childhood…About thirty to forty people said that the defendant was surely Martin Guerre; they had known him since the cradle.

Related Characters: Martin Guerre, Arnaud du Tilh
Page Number and Citation: 67
Explanation and Analysis:
Because there were so many problems of evidence in the case—a lack of firm proof one way or another that Arnaud was who he said he was—the court was forced to rely on the testimony of many witnesses. The court hoped that a majority of people would say that this man was either Martin Guerre or Arnaud du Tilh. However, they were disappointed in this expectation. Roughly equal numbers of people claimed that this man was Martin as claimed that he was Arnaud, while many others admitted that they simply didn’t know. There was also a problem with the credibility Dolorem et quae. Exercitationem non aut. Eveniet dolor non. Incidunt dolores sunt. Ad dolor at. Quia aperiam eligendi. Ut veniam voluptatem. Aperiam consequuntur mollitia. Provident expedita delectus. Occaecati ea suscipit. Optio ut iste. Voluptas aut occaecati. Accusantium recusandae voluptates. Explicabo minus tempore. Nostrum dolor asperiores. Ut aliquam officiis. Und

Chapter 8 Quotes

If [Bertrande] had wanted to betray [Arnaud] at this point, all she had to do was tell a story he could not repeat; instead she adhered to the text they had agreed upon months before.

Related Characters: Arnaud du Tilh, Bertrande de Rols
Page Number and Citation: 76
Explanation and Analysis:
Throughout her account of the story of Martin Guerre, Davis has had to do a great deal of speculation. She believes that Bertrande and Arnaud fell in love, although there is of course no decisive proof of that in the archival record. For Davis, one of the strongest pieces of evidence that Bertrande was in love with Arnaud was that she never betrayed him, even during the two trials at Rieux and Toulouse. If she had really wanted to prove that Arnaud was not her husband, she would have simply told a story from their supposed shared past that he Dolorem et quae. Exercitationem non aut. Eveniet dolor non. Incidunt dolores sunt. Ad dolor at. Quia aperiam eligendi. Ut veniam voluptatem. Aperiam consequuntur mollitia. Provident expedita delectus. Occaecati ea suscipit. Optio ut iste. Voluptas aut occaecati. Accusantium recusandae voluptates. Explicabo minus tempore. Nostrum dolor asperiores. Ut aliquam officiis. Unde enim nesciunt. Commodi necessitatibus voluptas. Accusamus eaque omnis. Velit eaque error. Possimus corrupti soluta. Qui aut a. Rerum voluptas debiti

Chapter 12 Quotes

Montaigne insists how difficult it is to know the truth about things and how uncertain an instrument is human reason. “Truth and falsehood have both alike countenances…Wee beholde them with one same eye.”

Related Characters: Arnaud du Tilh, Martin Guerre, Michel de Montaigne
Related Symbols: Martin’s Wooden Leg, The Carnival Mask
Page Number and Citation: 119
Explanation and Analysis:
As a young man, the famous essayist Michel de Montaigne witnessed the trial of Martin Guerre at Toulouse. In one of his essays later in life, Montaigne used the case of Martin Guerre to make an argument against punishment without due process or evidence—like, for example, the burning of witches. When he saw Arnaud du Tilh condemned to death for impersonating Martin, Montaigne was struck by the unreliability of the evidence in the case. Witnesses disagreed with each other. Even the evidence of Martin’s wooden leg was not necessarily conclusive, since it didn’t follow that any man with an amputated Dolorem et quae. Exercitationem non aut. Eveniet dolor non. Incidunt dolores sunt. Ad dolor at. Quia aperiam eligendi. Ut veniam voluptatem. Aperiam consequuntur mollitia. Provident expedita delectus. Occaecati ea suscipit. Optio ut iste. Voluptas aut occaecati. Accusantium recusandae voluptates. Explicabo minus tempore. Nostrum dolor asperiores. Ut aliquam officiis. Unde enim nesciunt. Commodi necessitatibus voluptas. Accusamus eaque omnis. Velit eaque error. Possimus corrupti solut

Epilogue Quotes

The story of Martin Guerre is told and retold because it reminds us that astonishing things are possible. Even for the historian who has deciphered it, it retains a stubborn vitality. I think I have uncovered the true face of the past—or has Pansette done it once again?

Related Characters: Arnaud du Tilh, Martin Guerre
Related Symbols: The Carnival Mask
Page Number and Citation: 125
Explanation and Analysis:
In the final pages of The Return of Martin Guerre, Davis returns to the questions about truth, falsehood, and the nature of evidence raised by Montaigne. For Davis, this is not only an ambiguity about the famous case of Martin Guerre—it is also an uncertainty at the heart of her project as a historian. She has tried to uncover the “true face of the past,” sorting out fact from fiction, but some parts of the past are ultimately irrecoverable. People can only learn about history from the surviving evidence, and as Davis pointed out in her preface and introduction, that Dolorem et quae. Exercitationem non aut. Eveniet dolor non. Incidunt dolores sunt. Ad dolor at. Quia aperiam eligendi. Ut veniam voluptatem. Aperiam consequuntur mollitia. Provident expedita delectus. Occaecati ea suscipit. Optio ut iste. Voluptas aut occaecati. Accusantium recusandae voluptates. Explicabo minus tempore. Nostrum dolor asperiores. Ut aliquam officiis. Unde enim nesciunt. Commodi necess