Bread Givers

by Anzia Yezierska

Bread Givers: Chapter 2 Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
The butcher, baker, and fish-peddler pay for Father’s bail and raise money to hire an excellent American lawyer for his trial, which results in Father’s charges being dropped. Rather than act grateful, he insists they are obligated to help him since he’s “their light.” For weeks after, it’s all anyone can talk about. They all decide the collector lady had it coming and that Father’s hitting her was “like David killing Goliath, the giant.” Shprintzeh Gittel’s “Americanized daughter" insists it’s wrong for a man to hit a woman, but the others immediately shoot her down, insisting that the greedy landlord and his collector lady are the ones in the wrong.
The unwavering support Father receives from his Jewish immigrant community emboldens him. Even if he on some level genuinely does feel he is acting in defense of his faith, it’s clear that his actions gain him power and influence, too. The opposing viewpoints of Shprintzeh Gittel and her “Americanized daughter” gestures toward one of the novel’s central themes: generational difference and fear of change and progress. Shprintzeh Gittel clings to the old ways and feels threatened, perhaps, when her daughter (and the younger generation she represents) challenge the old way of life.
Active Themes
Immigration, Poverty, and Struggle  Theme Icon
Independence  Theme Icon
Religion, Gender Roles, and Oppression Theme Icon
Change and Anxiety Theme Icon
Quotes
Word of Father’s assault on the collector lady spreads. Soon, everyone knows who Reb Smolinsky and his family are, and it becomes easy to rent out the front room. Things improve for the Smolinskys in other ways too: Bessie, Fania, and Mashah find jobs, and Sara continues to peddle herring on the street. Mother fixes the house up nice, and the family is able to buy new pots, pans, and plates. Sometimes they can even afford butter for their bread. But the more things they can buy, the more they want.
Father’s aggressive, domineering personality isn’t all bad—it earns him fame and respect throughout the wider community, and this in turn gives his family more financial stability. The idea that the Smolinskys want more and more things once they’re able to afford more contributes to the book’s ambiguous portrayal of change and progress. The immigrant family is working toward their dream of upward mobility and success in America, the land of opportunity, yet their greed and want grows as they work their way up.
Active Themes
Immigration, Poverty, and Struggle  Theme Icon
Change and Anxiety Theme Icon
Mother becomes a new person, laughing more than she yells. She starts to reflect wistfully on her youth in Russia, recalling how she used to have long hair and looked just like Mashah—a revelation that shocks Sara as she gazes on Mother’s “faded eyes” and plump figure. Mother recalls how rich men’s sons all wanted to marry her. But her father “wanted to buy himself honor in the family” and preferred Mother to marry a learned man, not a rich one. When Father came by the first time, Mother recalls, she ran from the house in shame.
Active Themes
Immigration, Poverty, and Struggle  Theme Icon
Independence  Theme Icon
Religion, Gender Roles, and Oppression Theme Icon
Change and Anxiety Theme Icon
Mother and Father eventually married, and Mother’s dowry was more opulent than anyone else’s in the village, containing feather beds, a dozen pillows, and beautifully embroidered towels. She was especially proud of her hand-crocheted tablecloth. She claims it was more beautiful than any of the machine-made goods one finds in America. Sara asks why Mother and Father came to America if things were so great back in Russia. Mother, suddenly angry, blames “the Tsar of Russia,” who wanted “free soldiers to make pogroms.” The Tsar, she insists, wanted to take Father away from his learning to serve as a soldier, so they had to sell everything to buy Father out of the army. But as much as they sold, it was never enough. And when there was nothing left to sell, that’s when they traveled to America. 
Active Themes
Immigration, Poverty, and Struggle  Theme Icon
Religion, Gender Roles, and Oppression Theme Icon
Change and Anxiety Theme Icon
Get the entire Bread Givers LitChart as a printable PDF.
"My students can't get enough of your charts and their results have gone through the roof." -Graham S.
Bread Givers PDF