The Imp of the Perverse
by Edgar Allan Poe
✓

or to save your progress

The Imp of the Perverse Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
The story’s unnamed narrator argues that human beings underestimate the importance of a certain universal impulse. He believes that schools of thought like phrenology (the “science” of predicting mental traits based on skull shape) have “overlooked” this impulse, ignoring it because it seemed to be illogical. Humans have missed the importance of this “propensity,” the narrator claims, largely because philosophies like phrenology attribute all impulses to God and assume that they know what God’s intentions are. Therefore, they describe humanity’s instincts using reason alone, rather than observing them scientifically via lived experience.
The story’s beginning seems more like an essay on human behavior than a piece of fiction, but it’s important to keep in mind that this is all in service of its plot. The narrator, who is later revealed to be a murderer, tries to emphasize that his ideas are wholly objective and scientific—more scientific even than the accepted science of the day (phrenology). He is also clearly very verbose and technical in his language, showing that he is an intelligent and thorough man. In essence, he is stating here that the science of his day has ignored a certain impulse because it seems to be illogical, or against the assumed intentions of God.
Active Themes
Reason vs. Impulse Theme Icon
Phrenology, for instance, suggests that humans eat because God designed them that way. However, phrenology doesn’t question why humans eat or examine the objective data that could suggest a scientific cause for eating. It simply attributes to God the impulse to eat, then “assign[s] to man an organ of alimentiveness” (the instinctual desire for food) and fails to investigate further. Similar irresistible impulses (such as the need to procreate) are also often attributed to God by phrenologists (or “Spurzheimites”). The narrator believes that this thinking does not allow for the possibility of free will in human beings. As he claims, attributing human impulses to God means “deducing and establishing everything from the preconceived destiny of man, and upon the ground of the objects of his Creator.”
Phrenology has been debunked as quackery—and racist quackery to boot—but it still carried influence in Poe’s day. Here, the narrator uses this pseudoscience as part of his explanation for why “perverse” impulses aren’t well understood. He’s trying to point out the flaws of what he sees to be the scientific consensus, specifically stating that scientists have worked backwards from assumed conclusions, rather than observing the way people really act and drawing conclusions from that. The narrator isn’t explicitly talking about himself here or justifying his actions, which gives his monologue an air of objectivity and credibility, but it’s worth remembering that this is all self-interested. Spurzheim was a leading proponent of phrenology, who popularized the pseudoscience in Europe in the early 1800s.
Active Themes
Reason vs. Impulse Theme Icon
The narrator claims that it would be far more useful to examine humanity’s actions in and of themselves, instead of relying on assumptions about what people are “intended” to do. After all, God is by nature impossible to understand, and so too are his intentions. A closer investigation of impulse, the narrator claims, would cause phrenologists to “admit” to a “paradoxical something” that he terms “perverseness.” These perverse impulses impel people to do what they “should not”—yet they are just as instinctual and “irresistible” as the impulses impelling people to do what they should. He clarifies that this is not a matter of self-defense through “combativeness,” but is something entirely opposite: a “strongly antagonistical sentiment” to the “desire to be well.”
Active Themes
Reason vs. Impulse Theme Icon
Quotes
The narrator appeals to the reader to examine their “own soul” and admit that they too have felt this impulse to perverseness, often doing what they know they should not do, and for no discernible reason. What occurs, he claims, is that “the impulse increases to a wish, the wish to a desire, the desire to an uncontrollable longing, and the longing […] is indulged.” The narrator gives examples of common situations where this impulse takes over, like stubbornly procrastinating in a task that one truly desires to do, or standing on the edge of a cliff and feeling a dizzying desire to leap, despite knowing that the fall would be deadly.
Active Themes
Reason vs. Impulse Theme Icon
Madness and Obsession Theme Icon
Quotes
Get the entire The Imp of the Perverse LitChart as a printable PDF.
"My students can't get enough of your charts and their results have gone through the roof." -Graham S.
The Imp of the Perverse PDF
The narrator concludes that such impulses come “solely from the spirit of the Perverse.” He says that one could attribute this impulse to the devil, or “arch-fiend,” except that sometimes it is “known to operate in furtherance of good.” The narrator then explains why he has offered this account: to explain why he is currently in prison, condemned for a crime. Though “the rabble” have called him insane, he declares that he is instead one of “the many uncounted victims of the Imp of the Perverse.”
Active Themes
Reason vs. Impulse Theme Icon
Crime, Justice, and Punishment Theme Icon
Madness and Obsession Theme Icon
Quotes
The narrator goes on to describe the crime for which he has been convicted. He claims that he spent months researching the means to commit murder, inventing and discarding "a thousand schemes" because he thought they might get him caught. After thorough research, the narrator reads a French memoir describing a woman who almost died when she lit a candle that had been "accidentally poisoned." This inspires him to replace the candle on his victim's nightstand with a poisoned one, since he knows “the victim’s habit of reading in bed,” and also that his apartment is “narrow and ill-ventilated.”
Active Themes
Crime, Justice, and Punishment Theme Icon
Madness and Obsession Theme Icon
Quotes
The plan succeeds: the narrator replaces the victim’s candle with a poisoned one, the victim lights the candle in his stuffy quarters, and he is swiftly killed. When his body is found “dead in his bed,” the authorities don’t detect the poison in the candle, and declare the death “a visitation from God.” The narrator then removes the remains of the candle without being detected, and covers up all other signs of the crime. He inherits his victim’s estate and lives quite comfortably for many years. Indeed, he revels in his seemingly perfect crime, claiming that “it is inconceivable how rich a sentiment of satisfaction” he gains whenever he thinks about getting away with it.
Active Themes
Crime, Justice, and Punishment Theme Icon
Madness and Obsession Theme Icon
Quotes
Eventually, however, the narrator begins to fear capture, with the satisfaction of successfully committing murder slowly giving way to a constant “pondering upon my security.” He becomes obsessed with the thought of capture, and begins to tell himself “I am safe” as a way of keeping his fear at bay. This works for a time, until one day he adds an extension to the thought: “I am safe—yes—if I be not fool enough to make open confession!” He then immediately fixates on this revised thought and fears suddenly and inexplicably confessing to the crime. He is familiar with the “fits of perversity” that he has previously described, and knows that he has never been able to resist acting on his perverse impulses.
Active Themes
Reason vs. Impulse Theme Icon
Crime, Justice, and Punishment Theme Icon
Madness and Obsession Theme Icon
Quotes
The thought consumes the narrator until “Every succeeding wave of thought overwhelmed me with new terror.” He walks faster and faster, and eventually begins running, fighting “a maddening desire to shriek aloud.” His actions draw a crowd, which begins to pursue him, and he “felt then the consummation of my fate.” His desperation to avoid confessing leads him to wish he could tear out his own tongue, until a force—which he attributes to “an invisible fiend”—strikes him on the back of the neck. He then apparently confesses to the murder—though he doesn’t remember doing so—undoing his so-called “perfect” crime and landing him in prison to be executed.
Active Themes
Reason vs. Impulse Theme Icon
Crime, Justice, and Punishment Theme Icon
Madness and Obsession Theme Icon
Quotes
The narrator concludes his tale by noting that he is currently chained in a cell, but will be “unfettered” the next day, when he will be hanged. He wonders where his soul might finally end up.
Active Themes
Crime, Justice, and Punishment Theme Icon
Madness and Obsession Theme Icon
Quotes