A Tale for the Time Being

A Tale for the Time Being

by

Ruth Ozeki

Teachers and parents! Our Teacher Edition on A Tale for the Time Being makes teaching easy.

A Tale for the Time Being: Part I, Chapter 8: Ruth Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
(1) Ruth thinks that she and Oliver are frittering their lives away, too. The part in Nao’s diary about the hikikomori (“recluses”) made them both uncomfortable, since they, too, are recluses on their island. Ruth feels like changes take place in “a world far away.”
Ruth feels cut off from the world on her desolate island because only the “world far away” seems to change, while everything seems to stay the same on the island. As a result, the island seems frozen in time, and Ruth feels like she is wasting her time as a “recluse” on the —she’s cut off from change, and by extension, excitement and progress.
Themes
Time, Impermanence, and the Present  Theme Icon
(2) The following morning, Ruth approaches her memoir with a sense of determination. She’s wearing the antique watch and she decides to time herself by it, resolving to do 30 minutes of uninterrupted work. However, Ruth gets distracted by the watch itself, and she starts trying to decipher the kanji characters etched on its back. With the help of her kanji dictionary, she discovers that they read “sky soldier.” She begins to google “WWII” and “sky soldier” to try to locate the manufacturer of the watch. Ruth lands on a forum for watch enthusiasts and discovers that the watch was made by Seiko Company during World War II. She finds out that the numbers engraved on the back were the serial number of the soldier who wore it.
The watch is a symbol of passing time, and Ruth intends to use it to stay focused on her memoir. However, the watch ironically distracts her more  and leads her back to Nao’s story, which seems to suggest that this is a more productive use of her time than being stuck in her unpleasant past with her memoir.
Themes
Time, Impermanence, and the Present  Theme Icon
(3) Ruth googles “Haruki Yasutani” but finds nothing about either a kamikaze pilot or a computer programmer. She also cannot find Haruki or Tomoko among the Yasutanis who were missing or dead in the earthquake and tsunami, and Ruth is relieved. She looks for Jiko Yasutani and Zen temples but once again draws a blank. Finally, she looks for “Chuo Rapid Express” and misspells Haruki as “Harryki” in the search bar; she is surprised by the results.
A misspelling—another fortunate mistake—seemingly leads Ruth to information about Haruki on the internet. This is an example of a lucky coincidence that connects the characters.
Themes
Coincidences and Connections Theme Icon
(4) The website Ruth lands on belongs to Dr. Leistiko, a professor of psychology at Stanford University who researches first-person accounts of suicide. Dr. Leistiko has posted an excerpt from a letter from a Japanese man who calls himself “Harry.” The man writes that, in Japan, suicide is regarded as a something beautiful, honorable, and meaningful.
Ruth’s discovery seems very fortunate: the subject of the website, and the fact that Harry is from Japan, indicates that this is probably Haruki writing under a pseudonym.
Themes
Life vs. Death  Theme Icon
Coincidences and Connections Theme Icon
Get the entire A Tale for the Time Being LitChart as a printable PDF.
A Tale for the Time Being PDF
Harry continues by saying that in modern, technology-ridden society, people complain about how everything feels unreal. However, Harry says, this is the way life has always been. Even Plato wrote that “things in this life are only shadows of forms.” Suicide, Harry says, makes life real—and it  feels like “stopping Time Forever.” However, he acknowledges that this is a delusion, too, since suicide is a part of life. 
Harry ties ideas of suicide both to modern technology and famous Western philosophers like Plato. This is further evidence that Harry is indeed Haruki, who was reading books on Western philosophy and works in computers. 
Themes
Life vs. Death  Theme Icon
Coincidences and Connections Theme Icon
Harry says that suicide is popular in Japan among middle-aged salarymen like himself because of the recession. Men like him are ashamed that they can’t support their families; they spend their days on park benches. Harry says that the most popular method of suicide is by hanging, and another popular way is to jump in front of a train like the Chuo Rapid Express. He says that he’s tried the train method, but he failed.
This passage makes it clear that Harry is indeed Haruki; while Haruki was unable to speak to Nao and Tomoko about the feelings that led him to attempt suicide, he seems much more forthcoming in his letter to Dr. Leistiko. Perhaps he feels like he won’t be judged as harshly by Dr. Leistiko, which encourages him to share how he really feels.   
Themes
The Difficulty of Communication  Theme Icon
Life vs. Death  Theme Icon
Coincidences and Connections Theme Icon
Harry says that young people in Japan prefer to jump off roofs to kill themselves. He worries about his daughter, who is unhappy in her Japanese school. Some young people form suicide “clubs”: they meet online, rent a car together, drive to the countryside, and then kill themselves by inhaling carbon dioxide from the car’s exhaust.
While Haruki never told Nao that he knew that she was being bullied in school, and that this worried him, he confides all of this to Dr. Leistiko. Nao would have surely appreciated his concern if Haruki had expressed it to her—but instead, they both felt disconnected and alone in their struggles.
Themes
The Difficulty of Communication  Theme Icon
Harry fears that his attitude toward suicide is unhealthy for his daughter. Initially, he wanted to kill himself to spare her the shame of his failures—but after he threw himself in front of the train, he saw that his daughter looked incredibly sad.  Now, Harry wants to live, but he’s too afraid to do so. He asks Dr. Leistiko to teach him how to love his life—he wants to find “the meaning of [his] life” for his daughter.
This passage shows Haruki’s love for Nao. While Nao thought he was reading all the tomes on Western philosophy just to kill time, he actually was looking for advice on how to keep living despite his feelings of hopelessness. Haruki wanted to live for Nao’s sake and was trying his best to find “the meaning of his life” so that he could keep being her father. Though the reader can see this, Nao, unfortunately, doesn’t realize it. 
Themes
The Difficulty of Communication  Theme Icon
(5) Ruth sends a quick email to Dr. Leistiko, asking him if “Harry” from the letter is, in fact, a man named Haruki Yasutani who used to live in Sunnyvale. She says that she needs to reach either Mr. Yasutani or his daughter, Naoko, as soon as possible, since Ruth is concerned about Naoko’s well-being. After she does this, Ruth is disappointed to see that it is already one in the afternoon—she hasn’t managed to get any writing done. Even worse, she hears someone’s car outside.
Ruth’s discovery of Dr. Leistiko’s website is a fortunate find—it seems like it will lead her to information about the Yasutanis. Ruth still hasn’t had any time to work on her memoir, which she is disappointed about. However, it seems like Nao’s story is rescuing Ruth from the past in its own way—it’s helping her enjoy her present as she works on solving these mysteries.
Themes
Time, Impermanence, and the Present  Theme Icon
Coincidences and Connections Theme Icon
(6) The car outside Ruth’s house is Muriel’s. Residents of the island often drop in without warning, which Ruth and Oliver dislike. Out of politeness, Ruth sits with Muriel and Oliver as they chat about garbage—but she’s bored. She inspects the packet of letters that came in the lunch box and finds that one envelope is thicker than the rest and is wrapped in wax paper. Inside is a thin, folded composition book written in French. Ruth interrupts Muriel and Oliver to ask if they can help her with the French.
Ruth’s dislike of some of the islanders’ practices, and her boredom at being forced to socialize with other residents, are other elements that add to her unhappiness. She seems to feel that she is too different from the people on the island to form true friendships here.
Themes
Time, Impermanence, and the Present  Theme Icon
The Difficulty of Communication  Theme Icon
(7) Neither Muriel nor Oliver get very far with the French in the composition book, and as Muriel prepares to leave, she suggests that Ruth call Benoit—another resident of the island—to help her decipher it. Watching Muriel walk tentatively down the steps, Ruth is reminded of Nao’s description of the old naked ladies in the public baths. Ruth, too, is beginning to feel her age in her knees and hips, and she recalls that she never had trouble getting enough exercise when she lived in New York, because she walked everywhere. Ruth’s memories of New York feel “vivid and real,” just like Nao’s memories of Sunnyvale.
Despite Ruth’s negative perception of the islands’ residents, they seem to be helpful and intelligent—for instance, Benoit is capable of deciphering something that Ruth herself struggles with. This suggests that Ruth’s grudges against them might be based on her own prejudices rather than on reality. Ruth’s memories of New York are happy—and therefore seem “real”—as she thinks back on her younger self enjoying city life. However, she has aged and changed since then, so her memories might not be as “real” and true as she thinks.
Themes
Time, Impermanence, and the Present  Theme Icon
The Difficulty of Communication  Theme Icon
Muriel is surprised to see the Japanese Jungle Crow as she gets into her car. Oliver tells her that he thinks it rode the same drift as the lunch box. Muriel tells him that the Sliammon people who used to live in British Columbia believed that a crow named T’Ets was a “magical ancestor who could shape-shift and take human or animal form.” After Muriel has driven away and Oliver has gone into the garden, Ruth speaks aloud to the crow, asking it what it wants. The crow stares silently back at her, and Ruth is convinced that it's waiting for something.
Muriel’s story about the Sliammon people’s belief in a magical crow ancestor not only suggests that the Jungle Crow might also be supernatural—it also links the old legend with the events in Ruth’s life, showing how people and stories are mysteriously connected across time.
Themes
Coincidences and Connections Theme Icon