Hamilton

Hamilton

by Lin-Manuel Miranda

Hamilton: Act 2: Cabinet Battle #1 Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
Hamilton and Jefferson face off about whether or not to create a national bank. Washington moderates the debate. Jefferson chastises Hamilton for moving money around, claiming that “in Virginia, we plant seeds in the ground. We create.” Hamilton retorts, “keep ranting / we know who’s really doing the planting.”
In this cabinet debate, modeled after a rap battle, Hamilton turns Jefferson’s words and ideas against him. Hamilton’s reference to “planting” is also the show’s way of addressing that Jefferson, despite writing the Declaration of Independence, was a prominent slaveholder. A lyric in “What’d I Miss?” even hints at his affair with Sally Hemings, an enslaved Black woman at his estate in Monticello.   
Active Themes
Collaboration, Disagreement, and Democracy Theme Icon
Quotes
Hamilton and Jefferson continue to trade barbs. When things get a little too heated (“turn around, bend over / I’ll show you where my shoe fits”), Washington shuts the battle down.
Washington knows that there is value to debate, but only up to a point: go too far, and animosity will get in the way of real governance.
Active Themes
Collaboration, Disagreement, and Democracy Theme Icon
Hamilton is frustrated that Jefferson and Madison are ganging up on him, but Washington is firm that the only way to create a national bank is to get Congress to vote on it (“winning was easy, young man. Governing’s harder”). Hamilton worries that Madison will block his proposal—and worse still, that if his proposal fails, he may be ousted as Secretary of the Treasury.
Active Themes
Collaboration, Disagreement, and Democracy Theme Icon
Ambition and Mortality Theme Icon