Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom

by August Wilson

Cutler Character Analysis

Cutler is a Black guitar and trombone player in Ma Rainey’s band. He is the group’s unofficial leader, making sure the band plays whatever Ma wants. Unlike Levee, he believes in simply doing whatever he’s told, insisting that the point of this band is not for the individual musicians to shine, but for them to accompany Ma. Because of his selfless outlook, he takes issue with Levee’s idealized notions about art and musicianship, trying to get him to see that, as long as he’s in Ma’s band, the only thing that matters is what Ma says—not Levee’s grand ideas about art and music. A serious man, Cutler also dislikes Levee’s tendency to speak blasphemously. But Levee doesn’t care about offending Cutler; in fact, he even seems to purposefully get under his skin by suggesting that God doesn’t care about Black people. Cutler eventually punches Levee in the face because of his blasphemous statements, prompting Levee to take out a knife and swipe it through the air—a precursor to his violence toward Toledo at the end of the play. In a way, Cutler tries throughout the play to help Levee avoid trouble by urging him to stop behaving with such selfish confidence, but he ultimately fails to impress the importance of this message on the young musician.

Cutler Quotes in Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom

The Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom quotes below are all either spoken by Cutler or refer to Cutler. For each quote, you can also see the other characters and themes related to it (each theme is indicated by its own dot and icon, like this one:
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
).

Act 1 Quotes

CUTLER is in his mid-fifties, as are most of the others. He plays guitar and trombone and is the leader of the group, possibly because he is the most sensible. His playing is solid and almost totally unembellished. His understanding of his music is limited to the chord he is playing at the time he is playing it. He has all the qualities of a loner except the introspection.

Related Characters: Cutler, Levee, Ma Rainey
Page Number and Citation: 20
Explanation and Analysis:

CUTLER: Slow Drag’s all right. It’s you talking all that weird shit about art. Just play the piece, nigger. You wanna be one of them...what you call...virtuoso or something, you in the wrong place. You ain’t no Buddy Bolden or King Oliver...you just an old trumpet player come a dime a dozen. Talking about art.

LEVEE: What is you? I don’t see your name in lights.

CUTLER: I just play the piece. Whatever they want. I don’t go talking about art and criticizing other people’s music.

Related Characters: Cutler (speaker), Levee (speaker), Slow Drag, Ma Rainey
Page Number and Citation: 26
Explanation and Analysis:

CUTLER: Well, until you get your own band where you can play what you want, you just play the piece and stop complaining. I told you when you came on here, this ain’t none of them hot bands. This is an accompaniment band. You play Ma’s music when you here.

LEVEE: I got sense enough to know that. Hell, I can look at you all and see what kind of band it is. I can look at Toledo and see what kind of band it is.

Related Characters: Levee (speaker), Cutler (speaker), Toledo, Ma Rainey
Page Number and Citation: 27
Explanation and Analysis:

TOLEDO: That’s African.

SLOW DRAG: What? What you talking about? What’s African?

LEVEE: I know he ain’t talking about me. You don’t see me running around in no jungle with no bone between my nose.

TOLEDO: Levee, you worse than ignorant. You ignorant without a premise.

(Pauses.)

Now, what I was saying is what Slow Drag was doing is African. That’s what you call an African conceptualization. That’s when you name the gods or call on the ancestors to achieve whatever your desires are.

SLOW DRAG: Nigger, I ain’t no African! I ain’t doing no African nothing!

TOLEDO: Naming all those things you and Cutler done together is like trying to solicit some reefer based on a bond of kinship. That’s African. An ancestral retention. Only you forgot the name of the gods.

Related Characters: Toledo (speaker), Slow Drag (speaker), Levee (speaker), Cutler
Page Number and Citation: 32
Explanation and Analysis:

LEVEE: See, I told you! It don’t mean nothing when I say it. You got to wait for Mr. Irvin to say it. Well, I told you the way it is.

CUTLER: Levee, the sooner you understand it ain’t what you say, or what Mr. Irvin say...it’s what Ma say that counts.

SLOW DRAG: Don’t nobody say when it come to Ma. She’s gonna do what she wants to do. Ma says what happens with her.

LEVEE: Hell, the man’s the one putting out the record! He’s gonna put out what he wanna put out!

SLOW DRAG: He’s gonna put out what Ma want him to put out

Related Characters: Levee (speaker), Cutler (speaker), Slow Drag (speaker), Irvin, Ma Rainey, Sturdyvant
Related Symbols: The Song (“Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom”)
Page Number and Citation: 36
Explanation and Analysis:

TOLEDO: See, now...I’ll tell you something. As long as the colored man look to white folks to put the crown on what he say...as long as he looks to white folks for approval...then he ain’t never gonna find out who he is and what he’s about. He’s just gonna be about what white folks want him to be about. That’s one sure thing.

Related Characters: Toledo (speaker), Levee, Cutler, Ma Rainey
Related Symbols: The Song (“Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom”)
Page Number and Citation: 37
Explanation and Analysis:

TOLEDO: It ain’t just me, fool! It’s everybody! What you think…I’m gonna solve the colored man’s problems by myself. I said, we. You understand that? We. That’s every living colored man in the world got to do his share. Got to do his part. I ain’t talking about what I’m gonna do...or what you or Cutler or Slow Drag or anybody else. I’m talking about all of us together. What all of us is gonna do.

Related Characters: Toledo (speaker), Cutler, Slow Drag, Levee, Sturdyvant
Page Number and Citation: 42
Explanation and Analysis:

MA RAINEY: I’m gonna tell you something, Irvin...and you go on up there and tell Sturdyvant. What you all say don’t count with me. You understand? Ma listens to her heart. Ma listens to the voice inside her. That’s what counts with Ma. Now, you carry my nephew on down there...tell Cutler he’s gonna do the voice intro on that “Black Bottom” song and that Levee ain’t messing up my song with none of his music shit. Now, if that don’t set right with you and Sturdyvant...then I can carry my black bottom on back down South to my tour, ‘cause I don’t like it up here no ways.

Related Characters: Ma Rainey (speaker), Irvin, Sturdyvant, Levee, Cutler
Related Symbols: The Song (“Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom”)
Page Number and Citation: 63
Explanation and Analysis:

CUTLER: You talking out your hat. The man come in here, call you a boy, tell you to get up off your ass and rehearse, and you ain’t had nothing to say to him, except “Yessir!”

LEVEE: I can say “yessir” to whoever I please. What you got to do with it? I know how to handle white folks. I been handling them for thirty-two years, and now you gonna tell me how to do it. Just ‘cause I say “yessir” don’t mean I’m spooked up with him. I know what I’m doing. Let me handle him my way.

Related Characters: Cutler (speaker), Levee (speaker), Sturdyvant
Page Number and Citation: 67
Explanation and Analysis:

Act 2 Quotes

MA RAINEY: They don’t care nothing about me. All they want is my voice. Well, I done learned that, and they gonna treat me like I want to be treated no matter how much it hurt them. They back there now calling me all kinds of names…calling me everything but a child of god. But they can’t do nothing else. They ain’t got what they wanted yet. As soon as they get my voice down on them recording machines, then it’s just like if I’d be some whore and they roll over and put their pants on. Ain’t got no use for me then.

Related Characters: Ma Rainey (speaker), Cutler, Irvin, Sturdyvant, Slow Drag, Sylvester
Page Number and Citation: 79
Explanation and Analysis:

MA RAINEY: If you colored and can make them some money, then you all right with them. Otherwise, you just a dog in the alley. I done made this company more money from my records than all the other recording artists they got put together. And they wanna balk about how much this session is costing them.

Related Characters: Ma Rainey (speaker), Sturdyvant, Cutler, Irvin
Page Number and Citation: 79
Explanation and Analysis:

MA RAINEY: White folks don’t understand about the blues. They hear it come out, but they don’t know how it got there. They don’t understand that’s life’s way of talking. You don’t sing to feel better. You sing ‘cause that’s a way of understanding life.

Related Characters: Ma Rainey (speaker), Sturdyvant, Cutler
Page Number and Citation: 82
Explanation and Analysis:

LEVEE: […] That’s what’s the matter with you all. You satisfied sitting in one place. You got to move on down the road from where you sitting...and all the time you got to keep an eye out for that devil who’s looking to buy up souls. And hope you get lucky and find him!

Related Characters: Levee (speaker), Cutler
Page Number and Citation: 94
Explanation and Analysis:

CUTLER: I done told you about that blasphemy. Taking about selling your soul to the devil.

TOLEDO: We done the same thing, Cutler. There ain’t no difference. We done sold Africa for the price of tomatoes. We done sold ourselves to the white man in order to be like him. Look at the way you dressed...That ain’t African. That’s the white man. We trying to be just like him. We done sold who we are in order to become someone else. We’s imitation white men.

Related Characters: Cutler (speaker), Toledo (speaker), Levee, Sturdyvant
Page Number and Citation: 94
Explanation and Analysis:

LEVEE: It don’t matter what you talking about. I ain’t no imitation white man. And I don’t want to be no white man. As soon as I get my band together and make them records like Mr. Sturdyvant done told me I can make, I’m gonna be like Ma and tell the white man just what he can do. Ma tell Mr. Irvin she gonna leave...and Mr. Irvin get down on his knees and beg her to stay! That’s the way I’m gonna be! Make the white man respect me!

CUTLER: The white man don’t care nothing about Ma. The colored folks made Ma a star. White folks don’t care nothing about who she is...what kind of music she make.

Related Characters: Cutler (speaker), Levee (speaker), Irvin, Ma Rainey, Sturdyvant
Page Number and Citation: 94
Explanation and Analysis:

LEVEE: […] Come on and save him like you did my mama! Save him like you did my mama! I heard her when she called you! I heard her when she said, “Lord, have mercy! Jesus, help me! Please, God, have mercy on me, Lord Jesus, help me!” And did you turn your back? Did you turn your back, motherfucker? Did you turn your back?

Related Characters: Levee (speaker), Cutler
Page Number and Citation: 99
Explanation and Analysis:
Get the entire Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom LitChart as a printable PDF.
"My students can't get enough of your charts and their results have gone through the roof." -Graham S.
Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom PDF

Cutler Character Timeline in Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom

The timeline below shows where the character Cutler appears in Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom. The colored dots and icons indicate which themes are associated with that appearance.
Act 1
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
Race and Identity Theme Icon
Cutler, Slow Drag, and Toledo arrive at the studio. Irvin nervously asks these band members where... (full context)
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
Race and Identity Theme Icon
Levee is late because he’s out buying new shoes with money he won from Cutler in a game of craps; he thinks these shoes will impress a young woman he... (full context)
Race and Identity Theme Icon
Collaboration vs. Independence Theme Icon
History, Tradition, and Change Theme Icon
...focus on money, Levee boasts that what he cares about is making art. He criticizes Cutler for including Slow Drag in the band, suggesting that Slow Drag sounds like an uncultured... (full context)
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
Collaboration vs. Independence Theme Icon
...himself as much more than an expendable trumpet player. He has real talent, he tells Cutler. He even gave Sturdyvant some of his songs, and Sturdyvant agreed to record them once... (full context)
Collaboration vs. Independence Theme Icon
History, Tradition, and Change Theme Icon
Cutler’s point doesn’t faze Levee, who says he knows what kind of band he’s in—all he... (full context)
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
Collaboration vs. Independence Theme Icon
History, Tradition, and Change Theme Icon
...but Levee doesn’t want to. He’d rather finish the song he’s working on for Sturdyvant. Cutler tells him this is unacceptable—he’s in the band, so he has to rehearse just like... (full context)
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
Collaboration vs. Independence Theme Icon
History, Tradition, and Change Theme Icon
...more exciting and modern. Irvin even told him that the studio wants his version. But Cutler doesn’t care. The band will play what he tells them to play, not what Levee... (full context)
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
Race and Identity Theme Icon
Collaboration vs. Independence Theme Icon
...clearly nervous because of the pressure Sturdyvant is putting on him. Before he goes upstairs, Cutler asks which version of “Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom” they should play, and Irvin confirms that... (full context)
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
Race and Identity Theme Icon
Collaboration vs. Independence Theme Icon
...however white people expect them to act. Levee, however, insists that he was just telling Cutler which version they’re supposed to play. Again, Cutler gets annoyed, since Levee doesn’t seem to... (full context)
History, Tradition, and Change Theme Icon
...of them with his overly confident, stubborn viewpoints. Eventually, Toledo calls him the devil, and Cutler wholeheartedly agrees. Slow Drag chimes in and says that he once knew someone who sold... (full context)
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
Race and Identity Theme Icon
History, Tradition, and Change Theme Icon
Cutler wants to know what became of Eliza Cottor, assuming that a man who sold his... (full context)
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
History, Tradition, and Change Theme Icon
...would he sell his soul, he’d also help Eliza get others to do the same. Cutler doesn’t like this talk, promising Levee that God will punish him for such blasphemy. But... (full context)
Collaboration vs. Independence Theme Icon
History, Tradition, and Change Theme Icon
None of the band members grasp the significance of Toledo’s metaphor. When Cutler tries to get them to rehearse again, Levee claims that, because he’s nothing but a... (full context)
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
Collaboration vs. Independence Theme Icon
History, Tradition, and Change Theme Icon
...of “Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom,” and she doesn’t care about Levee’s objections. She simply tells Cutler to teach Sylvester his part, then goes back upstairs, leaving Levee to complain that playing... (full context)
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
Collaboration vs. Independence Theme Icon
...polish for his fancy new shoes. The band turns its attention back to rehearsing, as Cutler tries to teach Sylvester his part, which goes: “All right, boys, you done seen the... (full context)
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
Race and Identity Theme Icon
...ready to lash out at white people if necessary, but the band doubts this—after all, Cutler points out, Sturdyvant called him a “boy,” and Levee did nothing but try to please... (full context)
Act 2
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
Collaboration vs. Independence Theme Icon
...As everyone gets ready to record, Ma walks around barefoot and sings to herself. Meanwhile, Cutler pulls Irvin aside and tells him Sylvester can’t get through the part without stuttering. Distressed,... (full context)
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
Collaboration vs. Independence Theme Icon
Catching Levee making eyes at Dussie Mae, Ma tells Cutler to get him in line. Irvin’s voice then sounds over speaker system, as he tells... (full context)
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
Collaboration vs. Independence Theme Icon
...band waits for Slow Drag and Sylvester to come back with the Coke, Ma pulls Cutler aside and chastises him for telling Irvin that Sylvester can’t do the part. She’s the... (full context)
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
Race and Identity Theme Icon
Cutler expresses his concern about one of the other songs on the list, “Moonshine Blues.” The... (full context)
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
Race and Identity Theme Icon
History, Tradition, and Change Theme Icon
Meanwhile, Ma waits in the studio and talks to Cutler about the blues, which she thinks white people don’t understand. When they listen to it,... (full context)
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
Collaboration vs. Independence Theme Icon
...he should focus on the music, not on Dussie Mae—who is, after all, “Ma’s gal.” Cutler tells Levee that Ma will ruin his career as a musician if she finds out... (full context)
Collaboration vs. Independence Theme Icon
History, Tradition, and Change Theme Icon
The band members ignore Levee’s talk about death, instead going on to discuss Cutler’s brother. Toledo used to farm with him, and he misses that life. There’s something calming... (full context)
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
Race and Identity Theme Icon
History, Tradition, and Change Theme Icon
Cutler hates Levee’s blasphemy and warns him about speaking this way. Toledo, however, points out that... (full context)
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
Race and Identity Theme Icon
Although Levee thinks Ma has a certain authority over white men like Irvin and Sturdyvant, Cutler notes that this isn’t real power. After all, she can’t even hail a taxi in... (full context)
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
Race and Identity Theme Icon
Cutler continues his story, saying that the reverend tried to walk calmly away from the white... (full context)
Race and Identity Theme Icon
Collaboration vs. Independence Theme Icon
History, Tradition, and Change Theme Icon
Levee considers Cutler’s story and then snidely asks why God didn’t rescue the reverend from the white men.... (full context)
Race and Identity Theme Icon
Collaboration vs. Independence Theme Icon
History, Tradition, and Change Theme Icon
Cutler is beside himself with rage, punching Levee and yelling at him about insulting God. The... (full context)
Power and Exploitation Theme Icon
Race and Identity Theme Icon
Collaboration vs. Independence Theme Icon
History, Tradition, and Change Theme Icon
...that, his tone becoming increasingly frantic as he now begs Toledo to close his eyes. “Cutler,” he pleads. “Tell him don’t look at me like that.” And then, right as Cutler... (full context)