The Hound of the Baskervilles


Sir Arthur Conan Doyle

Teachers and parents! Struggling with distance learning? Our Teacher Edition on The Hound of the Baskervilles can help.

Criminal Nature vs. Criminal Nurture Theme Analysis

Themes and Colors
The Power of Reason Theme Icon
Strong Women Theme Icon
Natural vs. Supernatural Theme Icon
Criminal Nature vs. Criminal Nurture Theme Icon
The Superiority of Urban Life Theme Icon
LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in The Hound of the Baskervilles, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work.
Criminal Nature vs. Criminal Nurture Theme Icon

Dr. Mortimer, the young man who first introduces Watson and Holmes to the Baskerville case, is a proponent of a school of quasi-medical thought known as phrenology. Phrenology is the belief that characteristics about a person can be determined through exacting measurement and observation of their skull. The central tenet of such a belief is that there exists a biological basis for all behavior that predetermines the way that one acts (as opposed to behavior being formed through one’s upbringing and history, the “nurture” one received in life). That is, according to phrenology, criminals have a distinctly criminal type of skull that can be known, classified, and identified. While the phrenological school of thought had its moment in time, that moment had already passed by the time of Doyle’s writing. The debate of whether or not behavior was formed by nature or nurture, however, was alive and heated; indeed, it was in the late Victorian era that the term “nature vs. nurture” was first popularized. Through Mortimer, Holmes, and the criminals of The Hound of the Baskervilles, Doyle illustrates his stance on the subject: he places criminality as being firmly the result of nurture and not inherent through nature.

This is seen most clearly in the case of Selden. Selden is the only person who the reader knows, all along, is a criminal. He is both a murderer and an escaped convict. Watson blatantly refers to him as “one of the most notorious criminals in the country.” Yet, despite this fact, Selden’s sister—Mrs. Barrymore—is a kindhearted woman who has served the Baskerville family notably for years and been a good wife to her husband, Mr. Barrymore. Were Selden’s criminality biological, one would expect Mrs. Barrymore to show it as well, since the two share the same blood. Instead, Mrs. Barrymore confirms that it was Selden’s upbringing that spoiled him. The child was “humored” too much, and he was raised in such a way that the world belonged to him, and he could do whatever he wanted. This poor upbringing led him to associate with others like him, which in turn made his behavior increasingly worse, until he was a fully-fledged criminal.

The Baskervilles, too, show that criminality is strictly a result of societal factors. Hugo Baskerville, one of the earliest Baskerville progenitors, was a rogue who killed a woman when she tried to escape him. He had planned to rape and imprison her—the crime that provided the essential source of the Baskerville curse. Sir Charles Baskerville and Sir Henry Baskerville, however, are both charitable, mild-mannered men. Furthermore, the only other remaining Baskerville, James Desmond, is described as living a “saintly life” as a perish clergymen. Desmond is so saintly, in fact, that he refuses any money from the Baskerville estate whatsoever.

But if Mortimer’s phrenology were correct, then none of the above relationships could be true. Most importantly, Stapleton could not be the mastermind behind the Baskerville plot. As Stapleton is himself a Baskerville, and we know the Baskervilles to generally be good, solid people.

It’s important to note that, while the story clearly points to a societal reason for behavior, it nevertheless fails to prescribe any sort of solution for how such criminality might be avoided in future generations. This is in stark contrast to many other writers (such as Charles Dickens) who came to the same conclusions on the same debate, and used their writing as a kind of political platform to suggest change. This may indicate that Doyle did indeed see criminal behavior as a result of failed nurture, but he also saw that failure to nurture as being inevitable. That is, regardless of how well-intentioned society might be in overseeing its children, some would probably always slip through the cracks.

Related Themes from Other Texts
Compare and contrast themes from other texts to this theme…

Criminal Nature vs. Criminal Nurture ThemeTracker

The ThemeTracker below shows where, and to what degree, the theme of Criminal Nature vs. Criminal Nurture appears in each chapter of The Hound of the Baskervilles. Click or tap on any chapter to read its Summary & Analysis.
How often theme appears:
chapter length:
Get the entire The Hound of the Baskervilles LitChart as a printable PDF.
The Hound of the Baskervilles PDF

Criminal Nature vs. Criminal Nurture Quotes in The Hound of the Baskervilles

Below you will find the important quotes in The Hound of the Baskervilles related to the theme of Criminal Nature vs. Criminal Nurture.
Chapter 2 Quotes

Such is the tale, my sons, of the coming of the hound which is said to have plagued the family so sorely ever since. If I have set it down it is because that which is clearly known hath less terror than that which is but hinted at and guessed.

Page Number: 260
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 4  Quotes

We are dealing with a clever man, Watson.

Related Characters: Sherlock Holmes (speaker), Dr. John Watson, Jack Stapleton
Page Number: 283
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 5 Quotes

Sir Charles had a reputation for being rich, but we did not know how very rich he was until we came to examine his securities. The total value of the estate was close to a million.

Page Number: 290
Explanation and Analysis:

It might interest you to know that you have been driving Mr. Sherlock Holmes.

Related Characters: Jack Stapleton (speaker), Sherlock Holmes, Sir Henry Baskerville
Page Number: 294
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 6 Quotes

I remembered the case well, for it was one in which Holmes had taken an interest on account of the peculiar ferocity of the crime and the wanton brutality which had marked all the actions of the assassin.

Related Characters: Dr. John Watson (speaker), Sherlock Holmes, Selden
Page Number: 300
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 7 Quotes

Already round this pale-faced, handsome, black-bearded man there was gathering an atmosphere of mystery and of gloom.

Related Characters: Dr. John Watson (speaker), Mr. and Mrs. Barrymore
Page Number: 306
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 8  Quotes

He is much attached to her, no doubt, and would lead a lonely life without her, but it would seem the height of selfishness, if he were to stand in the way of her making so brilliant a marriage.

Page Number: 320
Explanation and Analysis:

Some deep sorrow gnaws ever at her heart. Sometimes I wonder if she has a guilty memory which haunts her, and sometimes I suspect Barrymore of being a domestic tyrant. I have always felt there was something singular and questionable in this man's character […].

Related Characters: Dr. John Watson (speaker), Mr. and Mrs. Barrymore, Selden
Page Number: 323
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 9  Quotes

She kept coming back to it that this was a place of danger, and that she would never be happy until I had left it.

Related Characters: Sir Henry Baskerville (speaker), Dr. John Watson, Beryl Stapleton
Page Number: 330
Explanation and Analysis:

Oh, John, John, have I brought you to this? It is my doing, Sir Henry—all mine. He has done nothing except for my sake, and because I asked him.

Related Characters: Mr. and Mrs. Barrymore (speaker), Sir Henry Baskerville, Selden
Page Number: 334
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 10 Quotes

Her father refused to have anything to do with her, because she had married without his consent, and perhaps for one or two other reasons as well.

Related Characters: Dr. James Mortimer (speaker), Dr. John Watson, Laura Lyons
Page Number: 347
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 12 Quotes

The gleam of the match which he struck shone upon his clotted fingers and upon the ghastly pool which widened slowly from the crushed skull of the victim. And it shone upon something else which turned our hearts sick and faint within us—the body of Sir Henry Baskerville!

Related Characters: Dr. John Watson (speaker), Sherlock Holmes, Sir Henry Baskerville, Selden
Page Number: 369
Explanation and Analysis:

One cannot always have the success for which one hopes. An investigator needs facts, and not legends or rumors. It has not been a satisfactory case.

Related Characters: Sherlock Holmes (speaker), Dr. John Watson, Jack Stapleton
Page Number: 373
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 13  Quotes

That’s lucky for him—in fact, it’s lucky for all of you, since you are all on the wrong side of the law in this matter. I am not sure that as a conscientious detective my first duty is not to arrest the whole household.

Related Characters: Sherlock Holmes (speaker), Mr. and Mrs. Barrymore, Selden
Page Number: 377
Explanation and Analysis:

Yes, it is an interesting instance of a throwback, which appears to be both physical and spiritual. A study of family portraits is enough to convert a man to the doctrine of reincarnation. The fellow is a Baskerville—that is evident.

Related Characters: Sherlock Holmes (speaker), Jack Stapleton
Page Number: 379
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 14 Quotes

The great ordeal was in front of us; at last we were about to make our final effort, and yet Holmes had said nothing, and I could only surmise what his course of action would be.

Related Characters: Dr. John Watson (speaker), Sherlock Holmes
Page Number: 387
Explanation and Analysis:

I said it in London, Watson, and I say it again now, that never have we helped to hunt down a more dangerous man than he who is lying yonder.

Related Characters: Sherlock Holmes (speaker), Dr. John Watson, Jack Stapleton
Page Number: 396
Explanation and Analysis: