The Frogs
by Aristophanes
✓

or to save your progress

The Frogs: Act 2, Scene 1 Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
In Pluto’s palace, Xanthias and Pluto’s slave are working together on some tedious chore. Xanthias gripes about Dionysus, but Pluto’s slave thinks it’s pretty unusual that Dionysus didn’t beat Xanthias for pretending to be him. Xanthias says he’d make Dionysus pay if he did that, and Pluto’s slave brightens on hearing Xanthias disrespect his master—he, too, likes to trash-talk Pluto. The men bond over their mutual love of insulting their masters.
Though Xanthias enjoyed a turn playing Heracles, his transformation was only skin deep, and his glory was ultimately short-lived; now he’s relegated to enslavement once more, sent away to do tedious work with another enslaved person while more important characters tend to more important work.
Active Themes
Appearance vs. Reality  Theme Icon
Quotes
The sound of nearby yelling interrupts Xanthias and Pluto’s slave’s conversation. Pluto’s slave explains that it’s Aeschylus and Euripides who are yelling: they’re presently engaged in something of a “civil war.” In Hades, whoever is the best in their field gets his own chair in Pluto’s great hall, and Aeschylus and Euripides are vying for this same coveted position. Aeschylus previously held the chair for tragedy, but ever since Euripides recently died and came to Hades, he’s been threatening to take Aeschylus’s chair away from him. Xanthias doesn’t understand what the problem is—surely Aeschylus is the best. But Pluto’s slave explains that common rogues and criminals (at this point he gestures toward the audience) decided that they could decide which was the better poet, and hardly any of them sided with Aeschylus. To settle the matter, Pluto has decided to hold a proper competition to test the poets’ skill.
Pluto’s slave establishes a context for the agon, the part of the play in which two speakers engage in debate or contest, with each arguing an opposing side and ending with one speaker being declared the winner. In this case, Euripides (the recently deceased tragedian Dionysus came to Hades to revive) and Aeschylus are debating the merits of their respective bodies of work, thus reinforcing the play’s broader focus on the practice of literary criticism (then called “reading”). Complicating their debate are the people available to judge it—the play’s audience. In claiming that the audience is full of rogues and common criminals, the play reaffirms Aristophanes’s critique of contemporary Athenian society, culture, and politics. He also establishes a link between a society’s cultural literacy and their morality.
Active Themes
Old vs. New  Theme Icon
The Value of Art  Theme Icon
Literary Criticism  Theme Icon
Critique of Athenian Democracy  Theme Icon
Quotes
Xanthias asks if Sophocles is also competing for the chair. Pluto’s slave explains that when Sophocles first arrived, he kissed Aeschylus on the hand and promised not to challenge him. However, if Euripides wins the chair, Sophocles will challenge him. Pluto’s slave explains that the competition will involve using a scale to “weigh” the poetry. He also says that it’s been hard to find anyone smart enough to be a judge, as Aeschylus “[doesn’t] see eye to eye with the Athenians.” In the end, it was decided that Dionysus will judge the competition. Xanthias and Pluto’s slave exit so that the competition can begin.
Active Themes
Old vs. New  Theme Icon
Quotes
Dionysus and Pluto enter and find their seats. Slaves carry in a scale and other tools to weigh and measure the poetry. Euripides and Aeschylus enter next, engaged in a bitter argument. Finally, the Chorus takes the stage and introduces Aeschylus, comparing his words to “weapons.” Next, the Chorus introduces Euripides, whose poetry is filled with “intelligence subtle and keen,” though he throws adjectives around willy-nilly.
Active Themes
The Value of Art  Theme Icon
Literary Criticism  Theme Icon
Get the entire The Frogs LitChart as a printable PDF.
"My students can't get enough of your charts and their results have gone through the roof." -Graham S.
The Frogs PDF
Euripides speaks first, claiming to be the better poet. He argues that Aeschylus’s poetry is all flowery language and grand declarations. Aeschylus finally responds to Euripides, calling him a “son of the seed-goddess.” He criticizes Euripides’s plays for containing overly simple, unadorned language and for including common characters and depraved topics, like incest. 
Active Themes
Literary Criticism  Theme Icon
Quotes
Dionysus announces the start of the contest. He goes to the alter and lights incense and pours a drink into the libation cup. Then he turns to the Chorus and orders them to pray to the Muses. The Chorus invokes the Muses as the two competitors, one whose words are powerful, and one whose words are witty, prepare to duel. Aeschylus prays to Demeter. Euripides explains that he prays to “other gods.”
Active Themes
Literary Criticism  Theme Icon
Quotes
The contest begins. Euripides insults Aeschylus some more, claiming that he “cheat[s]” his audience by relying too much on suspense, like introducing a veiled figure at the beginning of a play and then boring the audience with long speeches instead of revealing the veiled figure’s identity. Dionysus finds Euripides’s criticism convincing, and Aeschylus starts to moan and fidget in discomfort.
Active Themes
Literary Criticism  Theme Icon
Euripides continues. He argues that he saved the art of Tragedy from the poor state Aeschylus left it in. He got rid of all the floral language and unnecessary detail and replaced it with logic and wisdom—he doesn’t tease his audience with non-linear timelines or rambling speeches. And every character in his plays—even the women, slaves, and old crones—serves a purpose. Aeschylus retorts that Euripides deserved to die for this, but Euripides says his death was merely “democracy in action.” He points to the audience and explains that he taught people to “observe” and “interpret” language, “to take nothing at face value…” He wrote about ordinary life that the audience could relate to. He didn’t confuse them with lofty language or “characters like Cycnus or Memnon[.]”
Active Themes
The Value of Art  Theme Icon
Literary Criticism  Theme Icon
Quotes
Dionysus, responding to Euripides’s claim that he taught his audience how to think, mockingly says that Euripides is right: now, Athenians ask questions like, “Why is the flour jar not in its proper place?” and “Who’s been nibbling at this olive?” Without Euripides, they’d just be staring dumbly into space.
Active Themes
Old vs. New  Theme Icon
The Value of Art  Theme Icon
Quotes
Next, it’s Aeschylus's turn to argue. Aeschylus begins by asking Euripides to identify what constitutes a good poet. Euripides replies that good poets “teach people how to be better citizens.” Aeschylus accuses Euripides of portraying noble figures as brutes in his plays. Aeschylus’s plays, like Seven Against Thebes, by contrast, portray heroes as heroic, virtuous, and dutiful. Aeschylus thinks this is the point of poetry: to teach audiences a lesson. Orpheus taught people that murder is wrong, for example. Aeschylus only includes role models in this plays, unlike Euripides, whose plays are full of lustful women like Phaedra. Euripides says his plays never hurt anyone, but Aeschylus claims that “every decent woman” was so aghast at Euripides’s Bellerophon that she went home and poisoned herself.
Active Themes
Old vs. New  Theme Icon
The Value of Art  Theme Icon
Literary Criticism  Theme Icon
Critique of Athenian Democracy  Theme Icon
Quotes
Euripides says it’s not like he came up with the story of Phaedra. Aeschylus agrees but says poets should know not to talk about such vile stories. Instead, they should provide examples of how to behave—a poet is to their audience as the schoolteacher is to their students, after all. Euripides scoffs and asks Aeschylus if it’s better to teach people using lofty language or common, everyday language. Aeschylus says that “noble themes” require noble language—and that this is a matter of respect. Euripides’s plays have taught people to be immoral and lazy and stand around “babbl[ing]” and debating all day.
Active Themes
Old vs. New  Theme Icon
The Value of Art  Theme Icon
Literary Criticism  Theme Icon
Critique of Athenian Democracy  Theme Icon
Quotes
Euripides next attacks Aeschylus’s prologues, claiming they don’t give the audience enough context. He cites the Oresteia trilogy as an example. Aeschylus recites the opening three lines of the play Choephori, in which Orestes stands over his dead father Agamemnon’s grave and speaks of his plans to avenge Agamemnon’s death.  Euripides explains what's wrong with these opening lines. “For I have come back to this land and do return” is redundant, he claims, since coming back already implies a return. Dionysus agrees. Aeschylus replies that “come back” is more general, but that “return” specifically applies to something an exiled person would do. The poets argue back and forth, with Dionysus interjecting shallow commentary here and there.
Active Themes
Old vs. New  Theme Icon
Literary Criticism  Theme Icon
Next, it’s Euripides’s turn to recite his prologue. He recites Oedipus Rex but can barely get through the first line about Oedipus being happy before Aeschylus cuts him off, arguing that this simply isn’t true: Oedipus was never happy, for Apollo had already predetermined that Oedipus would murder his own father. And from there, things just get worse: Oedipus is kept in a pot to prevent him from growing up and murdering his father, then he marries a woman old enough to be his mother, and then it turns out she is his mother. Then he blinds himself. Euripides maintains that his prologues are still good.
Active Themes
The Value of Art  Theme Icon
Literary Criticism  Theme Icon
Aeschylus claims that Euripides’s poetry is rhythmically bad. In fact, Aeschylus can “demolish any prologue […] with a little flask of oil.” To demonstrate this, Aeschylus asks Euripides to recite the opening lines of a prologue—then Aeschylus completes them with the phrase “lost his little flask of oil.” Aeschylus does this four times more, much to Dionysus’s amusement. Dionysus tells Euripides that he’s probably lost this battle and should move on and address Aeschylus’s lyrics instead.
Active Themes
The Value of Art  Theme Icon
Literary Criticism  Theme Icon
Euripides says that Aeschylus’s lyrics are all the same; contrary to their popularity, there’s nothing all that special about them. Euripides then mockingly sings excerpts from Aeschylus’s lyrical writing, ending each excerpt with the phrase “Ai, ai, we’re struck! Come quickly to the rescue!” much as Aeschylus did with the “flask of oil” bit. Aeschylus counters that he might use “traditional elements in [his] lyrics,” but they all serve a specific artistic purpose. Aeschylus then criticizes Euripides’s solo arias, singing a song that starts out sounding serious but ends up being about the theft of a cockerel.
Active Themes
Literary Criticism  Theme Icon
After Aeschylus finishes the aria, he suggests it’s time to use the scales to decide which poet’s “poetry is the weightier[.]” Dionysus calls the two poets to stand before the scale’s two pans. He instructs them to each hold onto a pan and recite one line of their own poetry, then when he calls, “Cuckoo!” the poets should let go. They both do this, and the result is that Aeschylus’s side of the scale slides down lower. Euripides demands they try again. Once more, Aeschylus’s poetry proves weightier.
Active Themes
Old vs. New  Theme Icon
The Value of Art  Theme Icon
Literary Criticism  Theme Icon
Critique of Athenian Democracy  Theme Icon
Euripides isn’t ready to accept defeat. He argues that “Persuasion” ought to carry weight. Dionysus disagrees, calling Persuasion “hollow” and meaningless. Euripides considers something weightier he can offer, but Aeschylus interrupts, saying the “line-against-line business” is pointless—even if Euripides hopped inside the pan with his whole family, Aeschylus would still outweigh him. When it’s time for Dionysus to decide the winner, he struggles. One poet is wise, but he “just love[s]” the other poet. Pluto says that Dionysus should just pick a poet; he can take the poet he picks back to earth with him, and that way he won’t have wasted his time.
Active Themes
Old vs. New  Theme Icon
The Value of Art  Theme Icon
Literary Criticism  Theme Icon
Critique of Athenian Democracy  Theme Icon
Dionysus turns to the poets and explains that he came to Hades to “save” Athens. Therefore, whichever poet can offer the best advice to save Athens is the poet he’ll choose. He poses a question to the poets: “what should be done about Alcibiades?”  Euripides recites lines of verse condemning citizens who act selfishly and harm their country. Aeschylus recites lines of verse about how unwise it is for states to raise a lion cub—but that if they do, they should “tolerate its own peculiar ways.”
Active Themes
Critique of Athenian Democracy  Theme Icon
Quotes
Dionysus can’t decide which poet has given the better answer, so he poses another question: how should Athens be saved? Euripides thinks Athenians should question everything and everyone—even the people and ideas they trust. Aeschylus thinks Athenians are doomed unless they stop electing “hypocrites and swindlers” over noble people, and they need to be prepared to give up land to strengthen their navy.
Active Themes
The Value of Art  Theme Icon
Literary Criticism  Theme Icon
Pluto says it’s time for Dionysus to decide which poet he will take back with him. Dionysus explains how he will pick the winning poet: “I shall select the man my soul desires.” Then he picks Aeschylus. Euripides, irate, calls Dionysus “shameful” and a “traitor.” He asks if Dionysus is really going to leave him here to remain dead, and Dionysus replies mockingly, asking how one can know what life and death really are. Euripides struggles as he’s removed from the arena.
Active Themes
Old vs. New  Theme Icon
The Value of Art  Theme Icon
Literary Criticism  Theme Icon
Quotes
Pluto orders Dionysus and Aeschylus inside to entertain them before they leave. The Chorus stays behind and praises Aeschylus’s “sharp intelligence,” anticipating all the good he will do for Athens. By contrast, “it’s not smart to sit and chat / With Socrates,” nor is it smart to sacrifice “Artistic merit” for “quibbling and pretentious talk,” which is what Euripides does.
Active Themes
Old vs. New  Theme Icon
The Value of Art  Theme Icon
Literary Criticism  Theme Icon
Critique of Athenian Democracy  Theme Icon
Quotes
Pluto, Aeschylus, and Dionysus emerge from Pluto’s palace. Pluto bids his guests goodbye and tells them to return to Athens and “Educate the fools.” Aeschylus asks Pluto to have Sophocles keep his chair away from Euripides while he’s away. The Chorus escorts Aeschylus to Athens, wishing him a safe journey and success in saving the city.
Active Themes
Old vs. New  Theme Icon
The Value of Art  Theme Icon
Literary Criticism  Theme Icon
Critique of Athenian Democracy  Theme Icon
Quotes