Levi believes that Simon’s actions were right because they were the “lesser evil;” for Simon, forgiving Karl would have meant lying, or inflicting a “moral violence” upon himself. Forgiving Karl would have meant releasing him from the terror of punishment, but for Simon, it would have been meaningless.
Like Kushner and others, Levi (who is also a Holocaust survivor) believes that Simon’s own well-being should be prioritized over Karl’s. He agrees with Simon’s friends that forgiving Karl would have made Simon feel even guiltier.
Levi adds that, had Karl not been on his deathbed, he would not have repented until much later. It was also exploitative, as he was using Simon as a tool to unload his anguish onto someone who had already experienced so much suffering.
Levi also argues that Karl continues to cause Simon suffering by recounting how he had committed a terrible crime and by causing Simon guilt in initiating this moral dilemma.